Inside Kashmir鈥檚 lockdown: Barbed wire and a sense of loss
| Srinagar, Indian-administered Kashmir
For the past week, since India鈥檚 government revoked the special status of Jammu and Kashmir, the streets of this long-disputed region have been mostly deserted, dotted with troops and barbed-wire barricades. The people are inside聽鈥� worried about family, amid a communications blackout; wondering about their children鈥檚 futures; waiting out a lockdown.聽
But still, one thing is palpable: a sense of lost identity.
On Monday, Aug. 5, Prime Minister Narendra Modi鈥檚 government announced it was revoking Article 370 of India鈥檚 Constitution, which granted Kashmir聽鈥� the nation鈥檚 only Muslim-majority state聽鈥� special status and limited autonomy. By the end of Tuesday, it was no longer a state: parliament passed a bill to strip Kashmir鈥檚 statehood, splitting the region into two federal territories.
Why We Wrote This
India鈥檚 revoking of Kashmir鈥檚 special status may reverberate in world capitals. But in Kashmir itself, people鈥檚 sense that the world has shifted beneath their feet goes much deeper than politics.
Thousands of troops have flooded often-volatile Kashmir, which is also claimed by Pakistan, and imposed a curfew. Over the weekend, some restrictions were lifted as residents prepared for the Muslim holiday of Eid al-Adha, honoring Abraham鈥檚 willingness to sacrifice his son to God. But during Eid itself, the curfew was back.
Critics of Mr. Modi鈥檚 Hindu nationalist-led government have criticized last week鈥檚 moves as undemocratic and perhaps unconstitutional聽鈥� and a further challenge to resolving Kashmir鈥檚 status with Islamabad. But many Kashmiris also fear that more fundamental changes to their community lie ahead. In revoking Article 370, the government did away with a prohibition on non-Kashmiris buying property, permanently settling, and applying for government jobs in the famously beautiful region.
鈥淭hey slit our throat and it is the time to respond with unity,鈥� Abdul Hamid says passionately, waiting for a temporary phone booth set up by the government amid the blockade.
鈥淥ur children are unaware right now but they will realize it in future,鈥� he continues. 鈥淭hey will be forced to become Hindus. The repercussions of this decision will pan out in the future.鈥�
Kashmir has been in and out of conflict since the partition of British India in 1947, when India and Pakistan achieved independence. The two nuclear-armed countries have fought two formal wars over the wider Kashmir region, which both nations claim in full but which each only partially controls. A violent armed rebellion demanding independence or Pakistani control has roiled Indian-administered Kashmir for 30 years; the military has repeatedly been accused of human rights violations in its response.聽
Mr. Modi鈥檚 Bharatiya Janata Party, known as the BJP, has argued that Indian-administered Kashmir鈥檚 special status has contributed to the unrest and blocked economic development. The party promised voters it would normalize Kashmir鈥檚 status ahead of general elections in 2014, when Mr. Modi first became prime minister, and again in 2019, when the BJP won again聽鈥� a few months after a suicide attack in Kashmir killed at least 40 security forces.
Outside Kashmir, many Indian citizens have celebrated the decision to strip the state鈥檚 autonomy, hailing the BJP for delivering on its promise.
But in Kashmir, people see it as the loss of their identity聽鈥� as Kashmiris, as Muslims, and as citizens of India, in the terms they understood it.聽
The ultimate aim of the government鈥檚 decision is to change the demographics of Kashmir, argues historian and political analyst Siddiq Wahid. 鈥淚t is not accidental that they have left [Hindu-majority] Jammu and [Muslim-majority] Kashmir together because they can demographically flood Jammu and then let that seep into Kashmir,鈥� he says.
Others argue it will be a long time, if ever, until many Hindu Indians move to the region, given its depressed economy and violence. With the announcement of the decision last Monday, many nonnative workers left the Valley in the nearest vehicle they could find and afford. 鈥淲e have no work here,鈥� said Ram Prasad, who hails from a village in Uttar Pradesh, 600 miles away. 鈥淲e come here to work but the government has taken a decision that impacted our livelihood. We should have been taken care of first.鈥�
Last Friday, ahead of the festival, the grand mosque in Srinagar, the region鈥檚 capital city, was locked up. 鈥淭hey removed our guts,鈥� says a policeman on duty. 鈥淣ow what is left of us?鈥� Elsewhere, with the curfew eased to permit Friday prayers, people took to protests, with some pellet gun injuries reported. Police said no bullet was fired. Dozens of incidents of protesters throwing stones at security forces have been reported.
On Eid, many families sacrifice an animal, recalling the ram that God substituted for Isaac. At Srinagar鈥檚 main market for the livestock, customers and sellers looked gloomy, but went ahead with trade. 鈥淭he price is much less this year聽鈥� it is only half,鈥� says seller Mohammed Shafi. 鈥淭he reason is people who would sacrifice four animals are deciding they will do one. There is no certainty how the situation will be on Eid.鈥� Last year, he says, he sold 300, but suspects the number will be lower this year. Traditionally, Muslims give one-third of the sacrifice to the needy, and one-third to relatives. But during the curfew, many doubt they can make those visits.
With little information available, rumors have been afloat. Indian state radio has reported more than 500 arrests. Several people who once supported pro-Indian parties say they won鈥檛 come out into the streets for them again; with leaders detained, even staunch supporters are feeling betrayed. What will the next generation see, people ask聽鈥� the same bloodshed?
A 20-year-old student, who recently began college in Srinagar, says that now he is determined not to leave Kashmir for something better.聽The government鈥檚 decision has 鈥渇inished mainstream politics but don鈥檛 realize yet what does it mean,鈥� he said. 鈥淲ith time, they will understand when there will be no jobs or development in reality. People think it鈥檚 a loss for the [regional parties] National Conference and People鈥檚 Democratic Party, but it is for people 鈥� everyone has lost.鈥�
