海角大神

Are Americans getting a clear picture of just how war in Afghanistan is going?

In bracing testimony before a House Oversight and Government Reform subcommittee this week, top US military officials warned that they are聽not.

The hearing centered around the US-funded Dawood Military Hospital in聽Afghanistan. It鈥檚 hardly a household name stateside, but evidence of聽the 鈥�Auschwitz-type鈥� conditions, as one lawmaker put it, and聽allegations that US military commanders covered it up to put a better聽face on the Afghan war have caused a firestorm of controversy.

The medical care of patients at the hospital includes 鈥渟ome of the聽most horrific, horrendous things I鈥檝e ever seen,鈥� raged Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R) of Utah, who chairs the House Oversight and聽Government Reform鈥檚 Subcommittee on National Security, Homeland Defense, and Foreign Operations. 鈥淎llowing surgery to go on without聽anesthetics, gangrene, open wounds that aren鈥檛 being dressed.鈥�

Afghan hospital staffers reportedly demanded bribes in order to treat聽patients, which included Afghan soldiers fighting alongside US troops聽in the war. If staffers were denied payments by the families, the patients聽did not receive care.

Representative Chaffetz leveled yet another grave charge: 鈥淭hat there was聽an effort to not allow the inspector general to get in there because聽the generals and others on the ground really wanted a positive story聽coming out of Afghanistan, rather than solving the problem.鈥�

This was the testimony of two retired colonels Tuesday. 鈥淲hat this hearing should be about are attempts to over-control the message,鈥� said retired Army Col. Gerald Carozza, Jr., who was chief of legal development assisting the Afghan Army and Defense Ministry. 鈥淚t is about some leadership that puts the best foot forward and relies on the hard-built reputation earned by the military.鈥�

But that was a reputation that was misused, says another officer who charged that a top US commander, Lt. Gen. William Caldwell, sought to conceal revelations surrounding the hospital rather than launching an investigation.

Lt. Gen. Caldwell, who headed the training mission in Afghanistan, 鈥渨as visibly upset鈥� about the possibility of a US military inquiry into the hospital, says Col. Mark Fassi, then-inspector general for the training command. 鈥淗is first response to me was, 鈥楬ow could we make that request with the election coming?' 鈥� he told the subcommittee.

The US military is currently investigating allegations against Caldwell, who was not invited to testify at the hearing. A spokesman for Caldwell says he would 鈥渨elcome the opportunity to respond to any inquiry鈥� and that 鈥渁ll allegations will be proven false.鈥�

It is not the first time that US military commanders have been accused of painting a too-rosy picture of the US war effort.

In a military journal article published in February, Lt. Col. Daniel Davis argued that not only is the war in Afghanistan not going well, but also that his fellow US military officers 鈥� whether due to a misguided 鈥渃an do鈥� spirit or a fear of repercussions within their chains of command 鈥� are misleading the American people.

This apparent lack of candor, in turn, is creating what Davis called a 鈥渃redibility gap,鈥� making it impossible to allow US citizens and lawmakers to 鈥渄ecide if the risk to blood and treasure鈥� inherent in America鈥檚 wars is 鈥渨orth it.鈥�

Citing a 2011 report by an Afghan organization, Davis charged that US military assessments routinely differ from those of other international military forces in the country and are 鈥渟olely intended to influence American and European public opinion ahead of the withdrawal.鈥� He added, 鈥淚鈥檓 hardly the only one who has noted the discrepancy between official statements and the truth on the ground.鈥�

Pentagon officials say that there have been positive developments in the wake of discoveries of patient mistreatment at Dawood, 鈥淚 would point out that some of the problems we saw at the hospital have in fact been resolved, corrective measures have been taken, and patient care was improved as a result,鈥� Pentagon Press Secretary George Little told reporters Tuesday.

Col. Schuyler Geller, the former Command Surgeon of the NATO Training Mission in Afghanistan who also testified at the hearing, confided to lawmakers that he鈥檚 not so sure about that.

Doctors and nurses who committed "unspeakable" acts still "walk the halls of the hospital,鈥� he said, 鈥渦nrepentant, unscathed, and unprosecuted."