US bid to cement global leadership stumbles in Gaza
Loading...
| London
Two wars, each with high stakes and painful costs, are together posing a critical test of President Joe Biden鈥檚 core foreign policy vision: a vigorous reassertion of America鈥檚 post-World War II role as global leader.
That鈥檚 because the political passions stirred by the wars in Ukraine and Gaza are threatening the support he will need to put that vision into practice.
Mr. Biden sees the catalysts for both conflicts 鈥 Russian President Vladimir Putin鈥檚 invasion of Ukraine, and Hamas鈥 Oct. 7 rampage through southern Israel 鈥 as a single challenge. 鈥淗amas and Putin,鈥 he declared in a rare Oval Office address on Oct. 19, 鈥渨ant to completely annihilate a neighboring democracy.鈥
Why We Wrote This
A story focused onJoe Biden鈥檚 bid to reassert U.S. global leadership is running into international doubts over Washington鈥檚 support for Israel. It would help if he could impose a humanitarian pause on Israel鈥檚 Gaza assault.
But key political constituencies, at home and abroad, are not convinced about that parallel.
At home, bipartisan support for helping Israel remains strong. But with regard to Ukraine, it is fraying. A growing number of Republicans in the House of Representatives, echoing former President Donald Trump, question continued U.S. support for Kyiv. The newly elected House speaker, Mike Johnson, this week proposed a funding package limited to supporting Israel.
Mr. Biden may yet muster sufficient Republican support for Ukraine.
But abroad, the controversial issue is U.S. support for Israel. And that support is straining coalitions that the president has been counting on to reassert American leadership in the face of the rival ambitions of Russia, China, and Iran.
The first sign of this has come in the response of many countries in the Global South to Israel鈥檚 all-out bombing campaign against Hamas in Gaza, which has flattened large areas and killed nearly 9,000 people, according to figures from local authorities.
Last year, Washington was able to woo the overwhelming majority of those countries into opposing, or at least staying neutral toward, Russia鈥檚 Ukraine invasion. But now, most of them are defying the United States and demanding a cease-fire that Israel says would give Hamas fighters an advantage.
In March 2022, a mere handful of countries sided with Moscow against a United Nations General Assembly resolution deploring Russia鈥檚 invasion, while 141 nations stood with the U.S.
Last week, by 121 to 14, the same body voted in favor of a 鈥渟ustained humanitarian truce鈥 in Gaza, rejecting Washington鈥檚 insistence on an explicit condemnation of Hamas鈥 surprise attack and hostage-taking. The U.S. stood isolated, even from some of its European allies.
World attention is showing signs of shifting away from last month鈥檚 attack on Israel to focus more on the humanitarian crisis and civilian casualties in Gaza.
That has fed growing grassroots protests across the Arab and Muslim world and beyond. Bolivia this week severed diplomatic ties with Israel, while Chile and Colombia recalled their ambassadors.
Of most immediate concern in Washington will be its Arab allies 鈥 key to Mr. Biden鈥檚 hopes, dashed for now by the Israel-Hamas war, of securing a peace deal between Israel and Saudi Arabia as part of a regional bulwark against Iran.
These Arab states still see Iran as a shared threat, and last month鈥檚 brutal attack by Iran鈥檚 proxy, Hamas, has reinforced that view.
But in public, they have increasingly focused on the need for a humanitarian pause in the Gaza fighting, so as to protect civilians and get aid into the area. In the longer term, they are insisting 鈥 after years of Israeli government disinterest and international diplomatic neglect 鈥 on a return to serious efforts to secure a two-state peace deal between Israel and the Palestinian territories.
On Wednesday, Jordan 鈥 a longtime U.S. ally, formally at peace with Israel since 1994 鈥 recalled its ambassador in protest over the 鈥淚sraeli war on Gaza鈥 and the 鈥渦nprecedented humanitarian disaster鈥 there.
The Biden administration is not about to weaken its support for what it sees as Israel鈥檚 right to defend itself in the wake of the killing and abduction of hundreds of its civilians. But it is clearly aware of the diplomatic price it may pay for that support.
In an interview with Foreign Policy magazine this week, Ehud Barak, the former Israeli prime minister and defense minister, predicted that 鈥渨ithin a week or two we will probably lose the support of public opinion in many parts of the free world, and within another two or three weeks we might lose support of many of the governments in the free world. I think that America will still be with us, but it will be more and more complicated for them to stay behind us.鈥
To reduce such complications, Washington has been redoubling efforts this week to get large-scale aid deliveries to Palestinian civilians, and to establish a credible 鈥渟afe zone鈥 in the southern part of Gaza, so far without success.
And while sharing Israel鈥檚 view that a full cease-fire would leave Hamas strengthened politically, Mr. Biden this week called for a 鈥減ause鈥 that would allow the release of hostages Hamas holds. U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, arriving in Israel on Friday, was expected to push the government to arrange more such pauses for humanitarian purposes.
鈥淎merican values are what make us a partner other nations want to work with,鈥 Mr. Biden said in last month鈥檚 White House address. 鈥淎merican leadership is what holds the world together.鈥
If the U.S. president can use that strength to ensure that humanitarian relief reaches the residents of Gaza, he will have greatly reinforced his bid to reassert his country鈥檚 global moral and political leadership.