Putin rebounds at home, but global ambitions stymied
Loading...
| London
It is a tale of two crashes, with a sobering message for Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Which is that while Mr. Putin has reinforced his power at home in recent weeks, the grand geopolitical ambition that inspired his invasion of Ukraine 鈥 reasserting Russia鈥檚 Soviet-era status as a great world power 鈥 is looking increasingly threadbare.
Of the two Russian craft that went down this month, the one signaling the Russian president鈥檚 robust authority at home made the bigger headlines worldwide: the plane carrying Yevgeny Prigozhin, the Wagner Group militia leader who had mutinied against Mr. Putin鈥檚 military chiefs last June, which crashed near Moscow.
Why We Wrote This
A story focused onVladimir Putin appears to have reasserted his authority at home, following June鈥檚 mutiny, but Russia鈥檚 international standing is taking a beating.
In the wake of that crash, which Western intelligence analysts attributed to a bomb, Mr. Putin issued a decree requiring all militia fighters to swear allegiance to the Russian state.
Yet the other disaster underscored a longer-term challenge to the Russian president鈥檚 global aspirations 鈥 exacerbated by his failure to achieve the short, sharp victory he clearly expected when he sent his invasion forces into Ukraine 18 months ago.
That crash occurred 240,000 miles away, on the moon.
It involved an uncrewed vehicle dubbed Luna-25, launched from Russia鈥檚 Far East. Russian space engineers lost control of it two weeks ago as it descended toward the moon鈥檚 surface.
They had hoped it would land near the moon鈥檚 south pole, where scientists have detected signs of ice. Water and its constituents, hydrogen and oxygen, could permit an extended human presence on the moon, and facilitate fuel production for interplanetary exploration.
But for Mr. Putin, the launch was also intended as a geopolitical statement.
It was his country鈥檚 first lunar mission since 1976, and after a Cold War space race in which the Soviet Union had notched up spectacular triumphs 鈥 notably the world鈥檚 first crewed orbital flight, in 1961, by Yuri Gagarin.
Had this month鈥檚 lunar mission succeeded, Russia would have become the first nation to achieve a soft landing at the moon鈥檚 south pole.
Instead, according to a terse official statement, Luna-25 鈥渕oved into an unpredictable orbit and ceased to exist as a result of a collision with the surface of the moon.鈥
In the days afterward, Mr. Putin was confronted with reminders of how much more complicated his bid for Russian great-power influence has become amid his war against Ukraine.
First, another rising world power 鈥 India 鈥 succeeded where Russia had failed. It landed its own uncrewed craft at the moon鈥檚 south pole.
Amid worldwide messages of congratulation, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi basked in the plaudits of fellow members of the BRICS economic alliance 鈥 Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa 鈥 at their summit in Johannesburg.
If there was a consolation for Mr. Putin, it was that he wasn鈥檛 there.
But the reason for his absence served only to bring home his 鈥 and his country鈥檚 鈥 shrinking geopolitical horizons in the face of Western diplomatic and economic sanctions.
Had he gone, South Africa, as a member of the International Criminal Court, would have been obliged to arrest Mr. Putin on ICC charges of deporting Ukrainian children to Russia during the war.
This week, the Kremlin announced Mr. Putin would also skip the G20 summit in India Sept. 9.
While Mr. Putin鈥檚 decision not to travel may have been prompted by more substantial motives than reluctance to chat with Mr. Modi about moon landings, the importance that Mr. Putin attaches to space triumphs as a reflection of Russia鈥檚 place in the world is not in doubt.
He has regularly praised Mr. Gagarin鈥檚 exploits, only recently announcing a national 鈥渟pace achievement鈥 award in his name.聽And on the 60th anniversary of the Gagarin flight, he declared that 鈥淩ussia must maintain its status as one of the leading nuclear and space powers, because the space sector is directly linked to defense.鈥
Nor can the more fundamental contrast with India have escaped him. Russia is a larger country, with far greater reserves of oil, gas, and other resources. But India鈥檚 economy is nearly twice as big 鈥 with a much more vibrant high-tech sector, a major boost to its space program.
And India, unlike Mr. Putin鈥檚 increasingly sanctioned nation, has ready access to the array of microchips, instrumentation, and other equipment essential to space flight.
After the Luna-25 crash, the head of Russia鈥檚 space agency insisted on the need to push ahead with the program. Echoing Mr. Putin鈥檚 views, he said, 鈥淭his is not just about the prestige of the country and the achievement of geopolitical goals. It is about ensuring defensive capabilities and achieving technological sovereignty.鈥
But he also seemed to imply limits to what Russia could achieve on its own, emphasizing plans for a joint mission with China.
The logic is clear: China, especially since the Ukraine invasion, has become Russia鈥檚 main, indispensable ally.
But while Russia has been on the moon exploration sidelines for nearly five decades, China has been mounting increasingly complex missions in recent years. It is planning a crewed flight by 2030.
So although cooperation with China in space does make sense for Russia, it will come at a price.
The former superpower will be the junior partner.