Can homeless people care for their pets? A Santa Fe controversy points to solutions.
-
Michael Benanav Special contributor
| Santa Fe, N.M.
This past April, social media users shared a video that was said to show a homeless man brutally beating his dog in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Within days, the dog鈥檚 owner, Chris McMurtry, began receiving threats from animal-lovers. Some commenters on the local Nextdoor platform suggested that someone should offer to buy the corgi mix, named Desi, while others proposed stealing her, in order to save her life. Within weeks, Desi went missing.
Mr. McMurtry immediately phoned the Street Homeless Animal Project, a nonprofit advocate for homeless people and their pets. 鈥淭he worst has happened,鈥� he said.
As Santa Fe, like many cities across America, grapples with how to address homelessness, tensions are spiking over the welfare of homeless people鈥檚 pets. And some residents, frustrated by what they perceive to be abusive and neglectful behavior by some homeless dog-owners, may have decided to take the law into their own hands, police believe.
Why We Wrote This
Human beings have long had special relationships with canine companions. But are the dogs of people without housing cared for? Our correspondent investigates.
But here鈥檚 the thing: The person in the video is not Mr. McMurtry. And, while the man in the footage is evidently inebriated, making strange, contorted motions with his upper body, Desi is seen standing off to the side, wagging her tail, for most of the half-minute clip. According to the head of the Santa Fe Animal Services department, there is no indication in the video or otherwise that Desi was being abused. 鈥淭he dog is just looking at him like, 鈥榃hat鈥檚 the deal?鈥欌�� says Capt. Amanda Monta帽o.
When I caught up with Mr. McMurtry one day behind a Dollar Tree store, he was unequivocal: He was there, he says, just off camera, and the man in the video 鈥渨as not hitting Desi.鈥�
The Santa Fe Police Department is investigating Desi鈥檚 disappearance as an animal abduction, a misdemeanor theft, and suspects that vigilante dog 鈥渞escuers鈥� were involved. Her whereabouts, six months later, remain unknown.
Mr. McMurtry is devastated by Desi鈥檚 absence. He has owned Desi for over six years, he explains, adopting her when she was about 8 weeks old from another homeless person who couldn鈥檛 take care of her. He hadn鈥檛 been looking for a dog, but she quickly became the center of his world.
At one point during our conversation, he breaks down, crying. 鈥淚 have a big heart, and I love my dog,鈥� Mr. McMurtry says. 鈥淭his is the worst possible thing that could happen to me.鈥�
Mr. McMurtry takes pride in being 鈥渁 really good dog-owner. I would do anything for my dog.鈥� But now, he feels, 鈥渢he whole town is looking at me as a dog abuser. It鈥檚 insane what people were saying.鈥� Still devoted to Desi, he hasn鈥檛 gotten a new dog. 鈥淚 have to have closure,鈥� he says. 鈥淚鈥檒l never stop trying to find her.鈥�
But there鈥檚 not much he can do on his own, and police say there are 鈥渘o new leads鈥� in the case.
Are homeless people able to care for dog companions?
Santa Fe is home to around 90,000 residents. Official estimates put its homeless population at some 375 individuals, though new data suggests there may be as many as 1,600.
On any given day, it鈥檚 impossible to drive around town without spotting homeless people holding signs on median strips asking for help, approaching shoppers in grocery store parking lots, or hanging out in public spaces. A substantial, though uncounted, number of them have companion animals 鈥� mostly dogs.
As a lifelong dog-lover who lives near Santa Fe, I often wondered how these animals are doing. Do they have enough food and water? Are they too hot in summer, too cold in winter? Do they have shelter at night? At heart, I suppose, I questioned how well a person who is apparently struggling to meet their own needs could properly care for another living being.
I took an interest in local social media threads that painted the situation as dire. Some posters called for bans on homeless people owning pets, while others accused specific individuals of animal abuse, referring to them as 鈥渟cum鈥� and 鈥渆vil,鈥� among other unflattering characterizations. I had no idea whether any of the allegations about the conditions of unhoused canine companions were true, and wanted to find out.
One woman whom I met at a coffee shop, who wished to remain anonymous for fear of local retribution, expressed deep concern for the welfare of the dogs. She described scenes of dogs abandoned for hours while their owners were off somewhere using fentanyl. She named certain homeless people as serial dog abusers. Speaking of many homeless folks, she says, 鈥淚f they can鈥檛 take care of themselves, they can鈥檛 take care of an animal.鈥� The same sentiment is expressed by someone else, word for word, in one of the Nextdoor threads about Desi. On the face of it, this logic made sense.
But then I asked the Animal Services department and the Santa Fe Animal Shelter about a handful of the dogs that are most frequently mentioned in online forums as victims of cruelty. According to their records, which were corroborated by interviews I conducted on the streets, none of the dogs about which I inquired have shown any signs of being abused or malnourished.
One instance of neglect was confirmed by a dog鈥檚 owner, Brad Wolleson, who says he was sick one cold winter night and left his dog in the care of a friend. That person abandoned the dog and tied her to a pole in a street median. The dog, Lily, was picked up by a passerby and taken to the animal shelter.
鈥淚t was a mistake,鈥� Mr. Wolleson says with remorse. 鈥淚 don鈥檛 let other people watch her anymore.鈥� He says he takes better care of Lily, who looks fit and healthy, than of himself. 鈥淪he always has food and water, even if I don鈥檛.鈥�
Santa Fe鈥檚 Street Homeless Animal Project
Some animal advocates in Santa Fe believe the best way to help these pets is not to rehome them, but to give their owners the assistance they need to care for them. One of these advocates is Karen Cain, who runs the Street Homeless Animal Project.
The back of Ms. Cain鈥檚 white pickup truck is stocked like a dog-centric outdoor specialty store: Most days find her driving around town passing out bags of kibble, harnesses, bowls, and blankets for the pets of homeless people, while also giving tarps, tents, sleeping bags, heaters, and $20 food cards to their humans. If one of these dogs is sick or injured, the project will pay its veterinary bills, also covering the costs of wellness checkups, heartworm prevention, and spaying and neutering. Ms. Cain鈥檚 mission is to 鈥減rovide support for companion animals of unhoused people.鈥�
鈥淲hen we started back in 1998, it was just about the animals,鈥� she told me. 鈥淣ow, it鈥檚 about the 鈥榝amily鈥� 鈥� if a person is not OK, their dog is not OK.鈥�
Those who believe that dogs can live good lives with homeless owners often point out that having a roof over its head is no guarantee that a dog isn鈥檛 suffering.
Taimie Bryant, a UCLA law professor who is deeply engaged with animal rights issues, says that people without housing are subject to a 鈥渧isibility bias.鈥�
鈥淲e see dogs living on the street who clearly need more than they receive,鈥� Dr. Bryant says. 鈥淏ut we don鈥檛 see what鈥檚 going on behind closed doors in many homes where dogs are housed. We can鈥檛 assume that housed dogs are treated well, just as we can鈥檛 assume that unhoused dogs are treated badly.鈥�
Real-world experience shows how flawed such assumptions can be. One Santa Fe Animal Services officer, Mariah Anderson, says, 鈥淲e encounter neglect more often in dogs that live in homes.鈥�
Mr. Wolleson tells me that he understands why people are concerned about the dogs they see with homeless people. But he says, 鈥淚f someone on the street isn鈥檛 taking care of their dog, you can talk to them and they鈥檒l fix it 鈥� and the ones who don鈥檛 will usually give their dog away. Usually, people listen. It just depends on how you talk to them.鈥�
Still, that doesn鈥檛 mean that cases of abuse or neglect don鈥檛 exist on the streets. Some people without housing who own dogs struggle with serious addiction problems, or simply don鈥檛 have the emotional bandwidth to consistently care for an animal.
Though Ms. Cain鈥檚 goal is to keep homeless people and their pets together, when she becomes aware of a potentially problematic situation, she alerts Animal Services. 鈥淣ot everyone should own a dog,鈥� she says, 鈥渨hether they鈥檙e housed or unhoused.鈥�
Decisions about whether to separate a dog from its owner are left to the discretion of Animal Services officers 鈥� and ultimately would be resolved by a court, if the case gets that far, since, legally, a dog is the property of its owner and can鈥檛 be taken away without due process. While many places have anti-cruelty statutes, Dr. Bryant says that these are 鈥渧alues expressed in law鈥� that do not grant dogs any actual rights.
She and other experts working on animal rights issues say the legal terrain is fraught with complexities. Laura Ireland, associate director of the Animal Law and Policy Institute at Vermont Law and Graduate School, points out that conferring rights on animals could have wide-ranging implications, from food production to decisions about veterinary care.
One key question she raises is, 鈥淲ho gets to speak for the animals? If someone lives in Alaska and owns a husky, great. But what if that person decides to move to a small apartment in southern Arizona? Should that dog be taken away,鈥� since it might be miserable there? she asks.
It鈥檚 possible, Ms. Ireland suggests, that the lives of dogs who belong to people without housing 鈥渁re actually better than those who are stuck inside alone all day.
鈥淚f you鈥檙e looking at the emotional well-being of an animal, the pet who is with their person all the time may be happier,鈥� she says.
Critics of Santa Fe鈥檚 Animal Services division say that, when it comes to the homeless community, animal ordinances are not enforced as vigorously as they should be.
In response, Deputy Police Chief Ben Valdez says, 鈥淚t鈥檇 be cruel to have black-and-white enforcement to seize dogs. Some of these pets are the only family people have. And it鈥檚 not good for the animals to be in the shelter 鈥� it鈥檚 heartbreaking.
鈥淥ur staff looks at the overall welfare of the dog and what鈥檚 going to be in the best interest of getting the situation addressed,鈥� he continues. Actual instances of people without housing abusing their dogs are 鈥渧ery rare.鈥�
Deputy Chief Valdez notes that when a wellness check was performed on Desi after the video was posted, the dog showed no signs of abuse or neglect. 鈥淭hat guy cared for Desi 鈥� those two were tight.鈥� As for the allegations she was beaten, he says, 鈥淪omeone made an assumption.鈥�
Another homeless man about whom assumptions have been made on social media is Brandon Tadlock, a U.S. Army veteran who served in Afghanistan.
When photos of Mr. Tadlock鈥檚 dog Annie were posted online showing some marks on her face, some people leaped to the conclusion that he had deliberately burned her. 鈥淏ut they were just nibble marks from when she was playing with a puppy,鈥� he explains to me.
After a veterinarian assessed the dog, she confirmed Mr. Tadlock鈥檚 account in a written report, adding, 鈥淎nnie is in great shape and I have met her guardian who loves her and takes wonderful care of her.鈥�
Some didn鈥檛 want to believe it. 鈥淭hey called the vet a liar,鈥� Mr. Tadlock says. 鈥淚 would never hurt her [Annie]. I love her, and she loves me.鈥�
Homeless people who have pets are well aware that some in Santa Fe wish they didn鈥檛. Ciprianna Roybal, who was born here and has been living on and off the streets for a couple of years, owns Little Fatty 鈥� who is stocky, but not little.
When I met her, Ms. Roybal was also fostering Amor, a 17-week-old puppy who belongs to a homeless friend of hers who 鈥渉as a lot on his plate,鈥� she says.
鈥淚 guess a lot of people think that homeless people shouldn鈥檛 have pets,鈥� Ms. Roybal says. 鈥淏ut Fatty keeps me safe. There are a lot of creeps out there.鈥�
鈥淚t鈥檚 none of their business whether we have dogs or not,鈥� she continues. 鈥淚t would be like us saying, 鈥榊ou shouldn鈥檛 have kids.鈥� Who are you to say we shouldn鈥檛 have dogs? My dog is as fit as a horse. He eats before I do. I wouldn鈥檛 trade him for anything in the world. He鈥檚 like my kid.鈥�
It鈥檚 not unusual for homeless people to step in and care for dogs that are in tough circumstances, as Ms. Roybal did with Amor and Mr. McMurtry did with Desi.
One man who was camped in an arroyo near a shopping mall and goes by the street name Red Beard says, 鈥淲e save dogs.鈥� His dog, Dazy Duke, whom he adores, 鈥渨ould鈥檝e died from mange and malnourishment if I didn鈥檛 rescue her. She鈥檚 been the best six years of my life.鈥�
Red Beard鈥檚 friend Matthew, who was wearing torn tan overalls and two pairs of glasses taped together, diagnoses the root of the animosity toward homeless pet owners. With his dog, Guido, by his side, Matthew, who along with Red Beard did not want to share their full names, says, 鈥淧eople treat other people like garbage because we don鈥檛 get to know each other.鈥�
鈥淚 have to get her back.鈥�
Many dogs belonging to homeless people spend time, at one point or another, in the Santa Fe Animal Shelter. Most commonly, they鈥檙e taken in when their owners are incarcerated, typically for trespassing or for failure to appear in court.
Since they are their owners鈥� property, the shelter must return them, unless Animal Services or the courts intervene. If a person without housing can鈥檛 afford to pay the shelter fees, the Street Homeless Animal Project, known as SHAP, will cover them. This raises the ire of detractors, who think the dogs would be better off if they were adopted out to owners with homes.
The senior director of operations at the Santa Fe Animal Shelter, Dylan Moore, believes that, in most cases, it is in the best interest of dogs to be reunited with their owners, even if they don鈥檛 have a home.
鈥淣ot all dogs can adapt to a new routine after being on the streets for some time,鈥� says Mr. Moore. 鈥淐an someone adopt them and then leave them in the house and go to work?鈥� Many of these dogs, he adds, respond poorly to being in the shelter, and behave in ways that make them less likely to be adopted.
鈥淭hese dogs stay in the kennel longer. They decompensate, and can spiral down into a welfare concern,鈥� Mr. Moore says. 鈥淎 lot of them face a much higher percentage of euthanasia. If my choice is to expose a dog to more shelter time or euthanasia, I don鈥檛 know why I wouldn鈥檛 give the dog back to an unhoused person, especially if there is support for them like SHAP provides.鈥�
Mr. Moore also speaks of the 鈥渧acuum effect.鈥� If you take a dog away from a person without housing who wants a companion, 鈥渢hey鈥檒l just get another one. And it鈥檒l probably be unvaccinated, and then I鈥檓 concerned about it having puppies. But our ability to help them is diminished, because they won鈥檛 trust us anymore.鈥� He has concluded that if you want to help homeless people鈥檚 dogs, 鈥渢aking them away is not the answer.鈥�
Of course, this is precisely what authorities believe rogue actors decided to do with Desi.
Mr. McMurtry is hoping that whoever has her will learn the truth about him and return her. 鈥淚 have to get her back,鈥� he says. 鈥淭hinking that she thinks I abandoned her is crushing.鈥�
