海角大神

Has the US Senate lost its cool over Elizabeth Warren?

Traditionally, the Senate has been the place where cooler heads prevail, where bipartisan deals are struck, where House passions are tamed. That鈥檚 the way the Founding Fathers designed this slower-moving chamber.

But Tuesday鈥檚 rare move by Republicans, in which Senator Warren (D) of Massachusetts was forced to sit down and cease speaking for 鈥渋mpugning鈥� fellow Sen. Jeff Sessions (R) of Alabama, illustrates the ratcheting up of sharp-edged partisanship.

That has some senators and observers very concerned that the Senate is losing its character 鈥� if it鈥檚 not lost already 鈥� as the chamber of reasoned, civil deliberation. They鈥檙e particularly concerned that this is happening at a time when a president with a fiery temperament occupies the White House.

鈥淕iven the tone of the Trump campaign and the Trump presidency so far, the Senate has the opportunity to take the political high road and model respectful partisan differences鈥�. But that opportunity is being missed,鈥� says Amy Black, a political scientist at Wheaton College in Illinois.

And there's no sign of backing down. Republicans plan to push through major changes in health care and taxes using a budget procedure that leaves out Democrats 鈥� exactly the GOP complaint when President Obama forced through the Affordable Care Act without a single Republican vote.

Meanwhile, Democrats have brought the confirmation process of the president鈥檚 cabinet nominees to a historic crawl, using boycotts and maximum debate time between confirmations. Ahead looms a tense showdown over the president鈥檚 Supreme Court nominee.

A rare invoking of rule 19

The latest fight unfolded during an all-night debate leading up to Wednesday evening's expected confirmation of President Trump's nominee for attorney general, Senator Sessions of Alabama.

On Tuesday evening, Warren was reading from a 1986 letter by civil rights leader Coretta Scott King that spoke of her 鈥渟trong opposition鈥� to Sessions for consideration as a federal judge over civil rights issues.

Warren, the liberal icon known for standing up to Mr. Trump,聽received a warning from the presiding officer that she was breaking Senate Rule 19, a rarely used rule that forbids a senator from 鈥渋mpugning鈥� the motives of another senator or referring offensively to another senator. In the past, it has applied even to the writings of others.

Warren continued, but was later silenced by majority leader Mitch McConnell (R) of Kentucky, who repeated as evidence the senator鈥檚 quoting of Mrs. King's statement that 鈥淪essions has used the awesome power of his office to chill the free exercise of the vote by black citizens.鈥�

Told to take her seat, Warren appealed but lost on a party-line vote. She then left the chamber to read the letter via Facebook. The entire incident has gone viral on social media, powered by the hashtags #LetLizSpeak and #ShePersisted.

鈥淚 certainly hope that this anti-free speech attitude is not traveling down Pennsylvania Avenue to our great chamber,鈥� said Senate minority leader Charles Schumer (D) of New York, in a vigorous defense of Warren on the Senate floor on Wednesday.

Later Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina, the Senate鈥檚 only African-American Republican, took to the Senate floor to give an impassioned defense of Sessions.

After reading tweets criticizing his support of Sessions, leaving out those that used the "n-word," he said, "You see, what I鈥檓 surprised by 鈥� just a smidgen, is that the liberal left that speaks and desires for all of us to be tolerant do not want to be tolerant of anyone that disagrees with where they are coming from."

When playing hardball 'feels principled'

Julian Zelizer, a political historian at Princeton University in New Jersey, says the deep partisanship incentivizes both parties to play hardball. "There is no cooling function left" in the Senate, he says in an email to the Monitor.

On top of that, Democrats are now facing massive policy threats and a president many believe is dangerous to democracy, he says. 鈥淧laying hardball in those circumstances feels principled, not just political,鈥� he adds.

Asked to comment on the Warren-McConnell-Sessions flap 鈥� especially in the era of Trump 鈥� Sen. Susan Collins (R) of Maine described it as 鈥渦nfortunate.鈥� The rare invocation of the rule 鈥渟hows a breakdown of comity on the Senate floor.鈥�

Senator Collins, one of the few moderate Republicans left in the Senate, is very concerned about the level of political discourse in the country, describing it as 鈥渢he worst it鈥檚 ever been.鈥� That rolls back to Washington, she says.

In an interview, Collins cited Senator Schumer's blasting of her compromise bill to replace the Affordable Care Act before he had even read it or it had been introduced.

鈥淭here鈥檚 fault on both sides, but people are so whipped up into a frenzy, and have not come to grips with the fact that the campaign is over.鈥�

Her colleague, Sen. Bob Corker (R) of Tennessee, sees things differently. In an interview, he described the Warren flap as not that big deal, 鈥渁 blip on the radar screen.鈥�

He and others tried to defuse the situation by talking to Warren on the Senate floor, he said.

But if聽she鈥檚 running for president, she 鈥渕ay not want it to go away,鈥� he added. As for the Democrats鈥� big slowdown of nominees, they have to show their base they鈥檙e putting up a fight. 鈥淭his too will pass.鈥�