Britney Spears' conservatorship ends. What's next for this tool?
Loading...
| Los Angeles
There were no more of the heated arguments or dueling court filings of the past few months, no more tearful testimony or angry accusations.
For one day at least, everyone surrounding Britney Spears agreed. She needed to be freed.
Most important among them was Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Brenda Penny, who at a hearing Friday terminated the conservatorship that聽controlled the pop singer's life and money聽for nearly 14 years.
The Britney Spears case, as The 海角大神 Science聽Monitor reported, raised the profile of this legal approach and breathed life into reform efforts.
Several prominent figures, including federal politicians and other celebrities, have voiced support for Ms. Spears and pushed for more significant changes after her testimonies. A new bipartisan bill that would give conservatees more control is now advancing through Congress.
鈥淭he publicity that Britney鈥檚 case has gotten has made a lot of people go, 鈥極h, I didn鈥檛 understand about conservatorships and guardianships; I had no idea that it was that extreme or could be that extreme,鈥欌 says Jan Costello, a professor at Loyola Marymount University who specializes in mental health law.
Spears did not attend the 30-minute hearing Friday that was almost anti-climactic after the courtroom drama of recent proceedings, in which Spears demanded first the ouster of her father from power over her, then the removal of the legal shackles on her life.
It felt almost like a formality. The celebration that followed was plenty dramatic, though.
鈥淏est day ever 鈥 praise the Lord 鈥 can I get an Amen???鈥 Spears said on Twitter and Instagram minutes after the ruling.
Jubilation erupted outside the courthouse, with fans cheering and shouting after the decision was announced. The crowd chanted 鈥淏ritney! Britney! Britney!鈥 and fans sang and danced to Spears鈥 song 鈥淪tronger.鈥
鈥淕ood God I love my fans so much it鈥檚 crazy!!!鈥 Spears said in her posts. 鈥淚 think I鈥檓 gonna cry the rest of the day!!!!鈥
The decision capped a stunning odyssey that saw Spears publicly demand the end of the conservatorship,聽hire her own attorney, have her聽father removed from power聽and finally win the freedom to make her own medical, financial and personal decisions for the first time since 2008.
Those surrounding Spears said she is equipped to make those decisions.
鈥淲e have a safety net in place for Britney both on the personal side and on the financial side,鈥 her attorney Mathew Rosengart said outside the courthouse. 鈥淏ut Britney, as of today, is a free woman and she鈥檚 an independent woman. And the rest, with her support system, will be up to Britney.鈥
Jodi Montgomery, the court-appointed conservator who oversaw the singer鈥檚 life and medical decisions starting in 2019, developed a care plan with her therapists and doctors to guide Spears into the aftermath.
鈥淭here is no reason Ms. Spears can鈥檛 lead a safe, happy, fulfilling life after this conservatorship,鈥 Montgomery鈥檚 attorney, Lauriann Wright, said at the hearing.
Penny's decision came with remarkably few caveats.
She gave no orders that Spears should undergo mental evaluations first, something legal experts had assumed would be part of the conservatorship's endgame. The judge said California law did not require her to order further evaluation of Spears if no one requested it.
The judge kept a small part of the conservatorship temporarily in place so that the singer鈥檚 money can be moved around in the coming months as financial power is transferred back to her.
California law says a conservatorship, called a guardianship in some states, is justified for a 鈥減erson who is unable to provide properly for his or her personal needs for physical health, food, clothing, or shelter,鈥 or for someone who is 鈥渟ubstantially unable to manage his or her own financial resources or resist fraud or undue influence.鈥 The conservator, as the appointee put in charge is called, may be a family member, a close friend or a court-appointed professional.
As recently as last spring, it appeared that Spears' conservatorship could continue for years. Then it unraveled with surprising speed.
Key to the unraveling was a聽speech Spears made at a hearing in June聽when she passionately described the restrictions and scrutiny as 鈥渁busive鈥 and said 鈥淚 just want my life back,鈥 a line her lawyer repeated in court Friday.
The consensus on display Friday is unlikely to last.
Rosengart has further vowed to pursue聽an investigation of James Spears鈥 role in the 13 years he oversaw the conservatorship.聽He said he and his team have found mismanagement of Britney Spears鈥 finances, suggesting she could pursue further legal action. Court records put her net worth at about $60 million.
He also said law enforcement should investigate revelations in a New York Times documentary about a listening device placed in her bedroom.
James Spears鈥 attorneys said Rosengart鈥檚 allegations ranged from unsubstantiated to impossible, and that he only ever acted in his daughter鈥檚 best interest.
The post-conservatorship fight has in some ways already begun. James Spears has parted ways with the attorneys who helped him operate it, and he has hired Alex Weingarten, a lawyer specializing in the kind of litigation that may be coming.
In court filings last week, Britney Spears鈥 former business managers, Tri Star Sports and Entertainment Group, pushed back against Rosengart鈥檚 demands for documents about the firm鈥檚 involvement in the conservatorship from 2008 to 2018. The group also denied any role in or knowledge of any surveillance of the superstar.
Britney Spears was a 26-year-old new mother at the height of her career when her father established the conservatorship, at first on a temporary basis, in February 2008 after a series of public mental health struggles.
It ends a few weeks before her 40th birthday, with her sons in their mid-teens and her career on indefinite hold, as聽she is engaged to be married聽a second time.
A turning point came early in 2019, when聽she canceled a planned concert residency聽in Las Vegas. Her career has been on hold ever since.
Convinced she was put in a mental hospital against her will, fans began coalescing and demanding that the court #FreeBritney. At first, they were dismissed as conspiracy theorists, but the singer herself gave them validation in 2020 in a聽series of court filings聽that said they were correct to demand greater transparency and scrutiny of her legal situation.
Those filings proved to be the first indication from Spears, who had remained silent on the conservatorship for years, that she would seek major changes.
Britney Spears has indicated that she'll focus on family and her newfound freedom for now. She may or may not resume making music.
鈥淲hether Britney performs again will be up to Britney, at the right time,鈥 Rosengart said.