China鈥檚 health crisis as a leadership crisis
Every year hundreds of books are written about leadership, reflecting not only a rising desire to understand it but also evolving ideas about what it is. Yet there is nothing like watching a country actively debate it. And not just any country.
China, with a fifth of the world鈥檚 population, seems to be in serious introspection about its top-down, one-man rule following widespread anger at the government鈥檚 response to the coronavirus outbreak. The introspection is even evident at the top.
On Monday, the head of the ruling Communist Party, Xi Jinping, met with other leaders and admitted there had been 鈥渟hortcomings and deficiencies鈥� in the response. The public health crisis, they said, is 鈥渁 major test of China鈥檚 system and capacity for governance.鈥� They also cited a need for a systematic review of 鈥渁reas of weakness鈥� in government.
For a party that regards both itself and its vision for Chinese society as infallible, this is a rare expression of humility, a character trait highly recommended in current books on leadership. Yet in another key trait 鈥� listening 鈥� the party has only stepped up censorship of any online criticism of officials. One prominent intellectual, Xu 颅Zhiyong, wrote on social media that Mr. Xi should resign for his 鈥渋nability to handle major crises.鈥� Another, Xu Zhangrun, a law professor at Tsinghua University in Beijing, wrote that the party鈥檚 restriction of freedoms only hindered the people鈥檚 ability to raise concerns during the early days of the outbreak. And instead of assigning party members by merit to serve the people, as the party did in the past, the leadership now deems loyalty to the party to be more important.聽
鈥淭he political system has 颅collapsed under the tyranny, and a governance system [made up] of bureaucrats, which has taken [the party] more than 30 years to build has foundered,鈥� he said.
Many Chinese are trying to help their leaders be better leaders. As a prominent novelist, Xu Kaizhen, told The New York Times, 鈥淚f they can rearrange the order in their hearts, we鈥檒l see a very different governance style.鈥� For China this is a healthy debate, made possible by a health crisis that is truly a test of leadership
