海角大神

Would the lights go out if superstorm Sandy hit the Netherlands? Nope.

The US can learn from the modern, disaster-resistant electric grid in the Netherlands.

In Wessel Bakker鈥檚 hometown of Gouda, the Netherlands (like the cheese), there are wooden utility poles like the ones downed by Hurricane Sandy. But in Gouda, the structures are more nostalgia than infrastructure.

鈥淚n my neighborhood 鈥� it鈥檚 a small, nice town 鈥� there are the last remaining wooden poles,鈥� said Bakker, Regional Director of Electricity Transmission and Distribution for , an energy consulting, testing, and certification company. 鈥淸The poles] have been marked as a landscape monument.鈥�

These are not simply the last remaining utility poles in Gouda. They are just about 鈥渢he only poles left in the country,鈥� said Bakker. 鈥淢aybe there are two or three more locations.鈥�

RELATED: 4 smart ways to rebuild after superstorm Sandy

Nearly three weeks after Hurricane Sandy hit the East Coast, . Many are living in shelters because their homes lack heat, hot water, and electricity, while thousands more have completely lost their homes. The storm took more than 100 lives.

But as utility workers repair an aging American grid 鈥� and as climate change promises to bring stronger storms more frequently 鈥� Latitude News wonders what the U.S. can learn from the Netherlands鈥� modern, disaster-resistant power grid.

I asked Wessel Bakker what would happen to power supplies if a storm like Sandy hit the Dutch coast, a storm that comes ashore with 30-foot waves and 80-mile-per-hour winds.

He paused for a long moment, then said: 鈥淚n the worst case scenario, I think nothing will happen.鈥�

The electrical grid in the Netherlands has some similarities to its American counterpart. Both are composed of a transmission grid 鈥� big, high-voltage lines, like the ones you might see while driving along a major highway 鈥� and a distribution grid 鈥� small, low-voltage lines which comprise the patchwork of cables running through cities and neighborhoods.

But here鈥檚 one major difference: The Netherlands鈥� distribution grid is largely underground. That鈥檚 one less thing cluttering up the country鈥檚 picturesque landscape, and one less hazard if the wind hits 80 m.p.h.

When Hurricane Sandy barreled through New Jersey and New York, strong winds ravaged local distribution grids 鈥� tree limbs became projectiles, power lines snapped, and utility poles were uprooted.

It is physically impossible for this kind of damage to happen to the Netherlands鈥� distribution grid. The wind may blow, but the power lines are safe underground.

But flooding was equally damaging to the electrical infrastructure during the superstorm. Bakker points to lower Manhattan, where many substations, transformers, and switchboards 鈥� the machinery that regulates the electricity in cables 鈥� are built at ground level.

鈥淲hat happened in Manhattan is a peculiar situation,鈥� Bakker said. 鈥淭he flooding was 14 feet above normal level. That鈥檚 extremely high. That is the root cause behind the failure.鈥�

Even if severe flooding hit the Netherlands, damage to underground cables would be minimal. However, it is possible that a flood could damage ground-level substations and other infrastructure in the Netherlands. But that is assuming the Netherlands actually experienced a major flood, a disaster for which the country has been preparing for more than听 half a century.

Much of the Netherlands would be underwater if not for the nation鈥檚 10,000-plus miles of dikes, dams, and other structures. Major flooding was an accepted part of life in听the Netherlands until 1953, when a deluge of cold seawater destroyed infrastructure and killed 1,800 people. After that tragic event, the Netherlands got serious about natural disasters, embarking on a .

The Netherlands flood-resistant infrastructure is built to withstand a 10,000-year flood, a flood so large and powerful it could only happen once in 10,000 years. By way of contrast, the levees built in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina are designed to withstand a 100-year storm.

In addition to a grid infrastructure designed to withstand heavy winds and flooding, the layout of the Dutch grid also makes it far more reliable than the American grid.

Much of the U.S. grid is designed in star patterns, meaning power lines fan out in straight lines toward homes and communities. That means if a power line connecting a community to the bulk grid goes down, the power won鈥檛 come back on until that line is repaired.

But in the Netherlands, the grid is laid out in a circular formation. If you lose power from one direction, you can quickly receive it from the other direction. And, increasingly, the Dutch grid is interconnected with neighboring Germany, Norway, Belgium, and the UK. Inter-connectivity improves reliability.

All of these factors 鈥� a massive infrastructure designed to resist floods, an extensive network of underground power lines, and a highly interconnected grid 鈥� make the Dutch grid far more reliable than the American grid.

鈥淚n Holland,鈥� said Bakker, 鈥渨e have about average 24 minutes outage annually.鈥�

Bakker points to a of the American grid, which came to very different conclusions.

鈥淪ome of the most reliable utilities are in the heartland states of Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, the Dakotas, Nebraska, and Kansas,鈥� Bakker said. 鈥淚n those states, the power is out an average of 92 minutes per year. On the other end of the spectrum, utilities in New York, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey averaged 214 minutes of total interruptions each year. These figures don鈥檛 include power outages blamed on tornadoes or other disasters.鈥�

I asked Bakker when was the last time the Netherlands experienced a big power outage. Again, he paused for a long moment: 鈥淚t depends what you call 鈥榖ig.鈥� There was a large one in the western region about 15 years ago.鈥�

More than 1 million people lost power 鈥� for about an hour.

In some ways, comparing the American and Dutch grids isn鈥檛 quite fair. The Netherlands is about the size of a densely populated Maryland, whereas the U.S. is enormous with a widely distributed power grid. The Netherlands鈥� unique topography has effectively required it to build major flood infrastructure, whereas building thousands of miles of dikes might be an expensive overreaction to Hurricane Sandy. Plus the American grid is overseen and maintained by a patchwork of federal, regional, and local bodies. Most power generation companies in the Netherlands are privately owned, just like American utility operators.

Having said that,听it鈥檚 also the case that the country is much smaller than the U.S., making management, oversight, and distribution of power far more streamlined.

But here are some sobering statistics. A recent report to Congress (entitled 鈥溾��) estimated that each year storms cost the U.S. $20 billion to $55 billion in damages and lost economic productivity. However, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo that Hurricane Sandy, one single storm, caused $50 billion in damage, most of it in New York state. That means in 2012, the US hit its annual quota in one day. The report, written two months before Sandy hit the coast, also noted that 鈥渢he trend of outages from weather-related events is increasing.鈥�

Wessel Bakker doesn鈥檛 envy the American situation.

鈥淵ou have large challenges ahead of you,鈥� said Bakker. He says the U.S. must 鈥渋dentify the optimum road map to improve the reliability for [the American] grid.鈥�听

But can the U.S. really do what听the Netherlands has done 鈥� pump billions, if not trillions, into smart-grid technologies and disaster-resistant infrastructure?

The U.S. might not have a choice, according to the (ASCE). In a 2011 report called 鈥�,鈥� ASCE called the American grid a 鈥減atchwork system鈥� that could break down without a $673 billion investment by 2020. At current rates of investment, the ASCE report says, the economy will grow more slowly and be more susceptible to fits and starts induced by nasty weather.

The report to Congress makes a few seemingly 鈥淒utch鈥� suggestions: trimming trees, laying distribution and some transmission lines underground, investing in a modern and focusing utility maintenance practices on power-system reliability. Essentially, doing what听the Netherlands has done, but on a much larger scale.

But Bakker points to a cultural shift that may be necessary as well. He says the Dutch public and government have simply developed a lower tolerance for power outages.

After three weeks without power, some Americans are certainly feeling less tolerant too.

鈥� at , an online news site that covers stories showing the links between American communities and the rest of the world.

鈥� Sign up to receive a weekly selection of practical and inspiring Change Agent articles by .