海角大神

Is Assad losing Syria? As concerns grow, US urges halt to 'intimidation.'

A realization appears to be growing in the West and the Middle East that Assad's regime is falling apart amid its crackdown on dissent. The State Department urges him to accept political dialogue.

The United States turned the rhetorical heat on Syria up a notch Tuesday 鈥� as sentiment grows among Western and regional powers that Syrian President Bashar al-Assad is gradually doing himself in.

With the Assad regime鈥檚 forces encircling the opposition stronghold of Hama Tuesday and reported to have caused at least six more civilian deaths there, the State Department said the US is 鈥渧ery concerned鈥� about continuing and spreading violence that is taking Syria 鈥渋n the wrong direction.鈥�

The US is urging the Syrian government to 鈥渋mmediately halt its intimidation and arrest campaign鈥� and to proceed with the political dialogue President Assad has promised, State Department spokesperson Victoria Nuland told reporters.

Noting that as recently as last week Hama was a 鈥減ositive example鈥� of how political expression could proceed, Ms. Nuland referred to the weekend violence there and added, 鈥淲e are going in the wrong direction.鈥�

Hama remains an international symbol of the Assad regime鈥檚 history of violent repression, since it was there that the current ruler鈥檚 father, Hafez al-Assad, put down a 1982 insurrection by killing at least 10,000 of the city鈥檚 residents.

The State Department comments reflect what appears to be a dawning realization among a number of international powers, including the US, that a regime until recently thought likely to weather the protest storms 鈥� and which was assumed to still have time to right its ship 鈥� may indeed be falling apart. About 1,500 people have been killed in Syria since the protests began.

Syria鈥檚 abandonment by some traditional allies, including Turkey and Gulf states, plus the sight of continuing and even growing protests despite intense repression, have some European capitals reconsidering assumptions about Assad鈥檚 survivability.

鈥淧eople think at least that things are never going to be the same for [Assad],鈥� says one European official, adding that the perception is growing that Assad is losing control. 鈥淲hat has impressed people is that even after a violent crackdown, [Assad] is confronted with huge protests,鈥� the official adds.

The US has stopped short of calling on Assad to step down from power, in part reflecting the deep concerns of some US allies in the region 鈥� first among them Israel 鈥� that a Syria without Assad would be an even bigger problem.

But some Middle East experts say they have detected a shift in thinking among some US officials toward the idea that Assad is bungling his challenge and causing his own demise.

鈥淭here are a number of people in the US government who think the Syrian government is crumbling from within,鈥� says Patrick Clawson, director of research at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. Assad is seen to be gradually losing control of the state鈥檚 security forces as he stretches the special units in his control to confront mushrooming protests, Mr. Clawson says. And that, he adds, is leading people to wonder how or if he can recover.

鈥淭he special units have not been able to bring things under control,鈥� he says, 鈥渁nd to the extent they鈥檙e in the whack-a-mole game, they鈥檙e in a big problem.鈥�

Turkey is a prime example of a friend Assad could have used in the international community, but which he has now lost. Not only has the Turkish government referred to Assad鈥檚 repression of protesters as 鈥渟avagery,鈥� but it is now threatening to enter Syria to create a buffer zone to insulate itself from a further onslaught of refugees.

Some human rights advocates are calling for Assad to face the same fate as Libya鈥檚 Muammar Qaddafi 鈥� indictment by the International Criminal Court (ICC) for crimes against humanity.

But that seems unlikely to happen, perhaps because Colonel Qaddafi suffered that fate first. According to the European official, Syria is not a party to the statute that created the ICC, and so is not subject to its indictments.

The UN Security Council could refer the Syria case and Assad specifically to the ICC. But that is the avenue by which Qaddafi was recently hit with an ICC indictment, and some Security Council members 鈥� notably Russia 鈥� have since got cold feet about aggressive Security Council action against leaders facing domestic political uprisings.

France and Britain, joined by the US, continue to want a Security Council resolution on Syria, but officials from both European governments acknowledge that resistance on the council to such action continues to put off a council vote.

The Europeans do not believe that the continuing violence in Syria has as yet altered what one official calls the 鈥渄ynamics鈥� at the UN.