海角大神

As graduation approaches, colleges struggle to balance free speech and safety

Protests over the Israel-Hamas war are shadowing U.S. colleges鈥� and universities鈥� preparations for graduation ceremonies. The institutions face the responsibility to keep students safe while still honoring their free speech rights.

First Look

The University of Michigan is informing students of the rules for upcoming graduation ceremonies: Banners and flags are not allowed. Protests are OK but in designated areas away from the cap-and-gown festivities.

The University of Southern California canceled a planned speech by the school鈥檚 Muslim valedictorian. At Columbia University, where 100 students were arrested last week following protests, officials聽temporarily canceled聽in-person classes April 22 as they work to find a resolution to the crisis.

This is commencement season 2024, punctuated by the tension and volatility that has roiled college campuses since Hamas鈥櫬燿eadly Oct. 7 attack聽on southern Israel. Militants killed about 1,200 people, most of them civilians, and took roughly 250 hostages. In response, Israel has killed more than 34,000 Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, according to the local health ministry.

Since聽the war聽began, colleges and universities have struggled to balance campus safety with free speech rights amid intense student debate and protests. Many schools that tolerated protests and other disruptions for months are now doling out more heavy-handed discipline. A series of recent campus crackdowns on student protesters have included suspensions and, in some cases, expulsions.

Columbia University President Minouche Shafik said the Middle East conflict is terrible and she understands many are experiencing deep moral distress.

鈥淏ut we cannot have one group dictate terms and attempt to disrupt important milestones like graduation to advance their point of view,鈥� she wrote in a note addressed to the school community April 22.

The new measures have done little to stop protests. As recently as April 22, pro-Palestinian demonstrators set up encampments on campuses around the country, including at Columbia, the University of Michigan, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and Yale University, where several dozen protesters were arrested after officials said they defied warnings to leave.

While the majority of protests across college campuses have been peaceful, some have turned aggressive. Some Jewish students say much of the criticism of Israel has veered into antisemitism and made them feel unsafe.

Protesters are asking universities to take a number of actions, such as calling for a cease-fire in the war, or divesting from defense companies that do business with Israel.

鈥淭he weapons being made in this country are being sent to Israel and being used in the war on Gaza, and so obviously we have to make those connections,鈥� said Craig Birckhead-Morton, a Yale senior who was arrested April 22 after refusing to leave a protest encampment. 鈥淲e have to highlight the difficulties the Palestinian people are going through.鈥�

At MIT, protesters also have asked the university to stop what they say is funding from the Ministry of Defense in Israel to university projects with military objectives.

鈥淲e believe that we have a platform that students in other universities don鈥檛 have because of our unique ties to the Israeli military,鈥� said Shara Bhuiyan, a senior studying electrical engineering and computer science.

The intense emotions on both sides have created a climate that has unsettled both Jewish and Muslim students. More than half of such students, and a fifth of all college students, reported feeling unsafe on campus because of their stances on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict,聽according to a report聽published in March by the University of Chicago Project on Security and Threats.

Earlier this month, the Anti-Defamation League sent an open letter to college and university presidents urging them to 鈥渢ake clear decisive action鈥� to ensure graduation ceremonies run smoothly and safely.

鈥淲e remain deeply concerned regarding the possibility of substantial disruptions during commencement ceremonies,鈥� Shira Goodman, the ADL鈥檚 senior director of advocacy, said in an emailed statement.

Several other college campuses around the country kicked off the new year with revised protest rules. In January, American University banned indoor protests. Harvard started the spring semester with guidance effectively limiting protests to outdoor areas.

The University of Michigan drafted a proposed 鈥淒isruptive Activity Policy鈥� earlier this month. Violations of the policy, which has not yet been implemented, could result in suspension or expulsion of students and termination of university staff.

The proposal came in response to a raucous March 24 protest that halted the school鈥檚 annual honors convocation, a 100-year-old tradition preceding the May 4 graduation. Protesters interrupted a speech by university President Santa J. Ono with shouts of, 鈥淵ou鈥檙e funding genocide!鈥� and unfurled banners that said: 鈥淔ree Palestine,鈥� forcing an abrupt end to the ceremony.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan said in a letter to Mr. Ono that the policy 鈥渋s vague and overbroad, and risks chilling a substantial amount of free speech and expression.鈥�

But in a letter to the campus, Mr. Ono remarked that 鈥渨hile protest is valued and protected, disruptions are not.鈥�

鈥淥ne group鈥檚 right to protest does not supersede the right of others to participate in a joyous event,鈥� he wrote.

At Vanderbilt University in Tennessee, more than two dozen anti-Israel demonstrators stormed the university president鈥檚 office in late March, refusing to leave for hours. Three of the students were expelled, including freshman Jack Petocz.

鈥淚t鈥檚 a very scary moment,鈥� said Mr. Petocz, who is appealing the decision. 鈥淚t鈥檚 about the crackdown on free speech on campuses but it鈥檚 also about campuses becoming police states.鈥�

On 15, the University of Southern California cited 鈥渟ubstantial risks relating to security and disruption at the commencement鈥� when it announced it would break from tradition and not allow valedictorian Asna Tabassum, a first-generation South Asian American Muslim, to deliver a speech at the May 10 commencement.

The decision sparked outrage and several days of protests on campus, prompting another unexpected shake-up days later: the cancellation of a keynote speaker for the first time since 1942.

The events at USC have raised concern that other schools will bow to pressure and erode free speech, said Edward Ahmed Mitchell, a civil rights attorney and national deputy director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations.

鈥淚 am worried that schools might decline to select a qualified visibly Muslim student who advocates for Palestine, to avoid what happened at USC,鈥� he said. 鈥淪chools are going to do more harm than good if they try to censor and silence commencement speakers, and especially students who have received the honor of speaking at their graduation ceremonies.鈥�

This story was reported by The Associated Press. Jocelyn Gecker reported from San Francisco.聽