海角大神

Chain, chain, chain ... chain CPI

Is the Consumer Price Index really the best way to measure inflation?

Over at the Moment of Truth project (a continuation of the president鈥檚 fiscal commission), Adam Rosenberg and Marc Goldwein make that the government should use a different inflation measure when calculating cost of living increases and indexing the tax code:

Maintaining purchasing power in spending programs and indexing various parts of the tax code is an important policy goal. However, policymakers should ensure that the most accurate measure of inflation is being used.

To correct the problem of over-indexation, many have proposed switching to the chained CPI [consumer price index] to provide a more accurate measure of inflation for indexed provisions in the federal budget. This switch was recommended by the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform (鈥�Fiscal Commission鈥�) and the Bipartisan Policy Center 鈥榮 Debt Reduction Task Force (鈥淒omenici-Rivlin鈥�). It has been incorporated into a large number of other plans, including from the Heritage Foundation on the right and the Center for American Progress on the left. An overwhelming majority of economists from both parties agree that the chained CPI is far more accurate measure of inflation than the CPI measurements currently in use.

In addition to improving technical accuracy, switching to chained CPI would have the secondary benefit of reducing the deficit 鈥� by about $300 billion over the next decade alone.

For the reasons they mention, I endorse this change and predict it will be part of any 鈥済rand bargain鈥� on America鈥檚 budget.

With apologies to Aretha Franklin (and any of you with sensitive music sensibilities), let me suggest a theme song for the effort:

Chain, Chain, Chain, Chain CPI

Chain, chain, chain, chain, chain, chain

Chain, chain, chain, chain CPI

For these long years, we have indexed all wrong

We pay too much, that leads to fiscal pain

And now money鈥檚 getting tight

But we have no need to cry

We know what to do, oh a better measure we can try

Chain, chain, chain, chain CPI

P.S. To my readers who believe that the regular CPI understates inflation, rather than overstating it: Yes, Aretha鈥檚 song is 鈥淐hain of Fools鈥�. And yes, that makes it easy for you to make up lyrics that mock the chain CPI rather than endorse it. Have fun.

--------------------------

海角大神 has assembled a diverse group of the best economy-related bloggers out there. Our guest bloggers are not employed or directed by the Monitor and the views expressed are the bloggers' own, as is responsibility for the content of their blogs. To contact us about a blogger, click here. To add or view a comment on a guest blog, please go to the blogger's own site by clicking on the link above.