海角大神

Reform or reverence? Thai royalists, protesters size up monarchy.

Mass pro-democracy protests in Thailand are calling for reforms of the monarchy, but for many Thais, especially of an older generation, the palace is revered and considered above politics.

|
Matthew Tostevin/Reuters
Royalist Thitiwat Tanagaroon stands in his house in front of a portrait of former King of Thailand Bhumibol Adulyadej, in Nonthaburi, Thailand, Nov. 6, 2020. 鈥淔or me, the monarchy is god," says Mr. Thitiwat, who grew up watching the nightly royal news on television.

The words the Thai king spoke to Thitiwat Tanagaroon have been tattooed on his arm: 鈥渧ery brave, very good, thank you.鈥

The restaurant manager never imagined he would win praise from King Maha Vajiralongkorn when he brandished a royal portrait at an anti-government protest last month. Nor had he expected online attacks and calls for him to be fired from his job.

鈥淭here are a lot of people who still love the monarchy and worship the monarchy but they don鈥檛 come out,鈥 he told Reuters.

鈥淲hoever comes out gets harassed.鈥

Just months ago, criticizing Thailand鈥檚 monarchy was taboo and few dared brave the country's harsh royal insult laws.

Now, defending the monarchy can also draw criticism 鈥 a monumental shift in a kingdom where the institution has been promoted for decades and must be revered according to the constitution.

The palace did not respond to a request for comment on changing attitudes since protests began in July.

鈥淭he new generation and youth, they鈥檙e not into it,鈥 protest leader Tattep Ruangprapaikitseree said of the deference generations of Thais have shown for the monarchy.

鈥淭hey see that they鈥檙e human, the king is human, not a god.鈥

Like many Thais his age, Mr. Thitiwat grew up watching the nightly royal news on television. He saw people kneel as royal cars passed on streets lined with royal portraits. The monarchy was the one thing he always put faith in, he said.

鈥淚t鈥檚 the same love I have for my dad and mum,鈥 he said. 鈥淔or me, the monarchy is god.鈥

A decade ago, he himself joined street protests 鈥 staged by royalist 鈥測ellow shirts鈥 鈥 to bring down an elected populist government.

Dramatic change

He was among thousands who prayed and slept outside the hospital when King Bhumibol Adulyadej fell sick in 2016. And when King Bhumibol died after a seven-decade reign, Mr. Thitiwat 鈥 like the rest of Thailand 鈥 dressed in black for a year.

But Thailand has changed dramatically since protests that began in July against Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha, a former army chief.

Anti-establishment demonstrations have evolved into demands to curb the powers of the monarchy, which critics accuse of abetting military domination, taking excessive authority, lavish spending, and allowing a crackdown on critics.

The protesters have emphasized that they seek to reform the monarchy, not abolish it, though royalists distrust them.

For Mr. Thitiwat, all accusations against the king are lies and the monarchy stands above politics.

His anger boiled over when chants on the street changed from vulgar expletives thrown at Mr. Prayuth to cursing the king, and he fumes at the now widespread criticism of royalty on social media.

鈥淚t makes me want to vomit,鈥 said Mr. Thitiwat.

The protests have drawn tens of thousands of people, including to the Pinklao suburb where Mr. Thitiwat works: a humdrum tangle of choked roads, flyovers, and shopping malls.

鈥淗alf the people support the protesters and half are against,鈥 said Gade, who supports the demonstrations and has a clothes stall 100 meters from Mr. Thitiwat鈥檚 restaurant.

On the day Mr. Thitiwat stood nearby with his picture of the late king, there was no confrontation, the royalist said. Protesters just raised their emblem of defiance, the three-finger 鈥淗unger Games鈥 salute.

But online, he said he was branded 鈥渄isgusting鈥 and much worse. The restaurant鈥檚 rating was knocked from 4.8 stars to 1 and it was bombarded with calls to fire him, its owner said.

鈥淚 was very scared,鈥 said the owner, Bo, who did not want to give her full name or have her restaurant identified.

On Facebook, one user called Mind Pain wrote 鈥淚鈥檓 disappointed, time to find a new place to eat.鈥 However, the owner said royalists were now coming in solidarity.

While royalists condemn such attacks, protesters complain of worse.

鈥淭hink about what the pro-democracy side endured in recent years. Prosecuted, followed, harassed, put into choke holds,鈥 Mr. Tattep said. 鈥淭here has to be dialog, not harassment.鈥

Sentiment shift

Gauging the shift in the country of 70 million is hard. The biggest protests have been bigger than royalist shows of support, but one recent poll said 60% of people thought the protesters should not attack the monarchy 鈥 though without explaining why.

Change is evident. Not everyone stands for the royal anthem in cinemas any more. When a woman slapped a teenager who didn鈥檛 stand for the national anthem at a railway station, it was she who faced public condemnation.

Mr. Thitiwat鈥檚 emergence as a hero for monarchists came when the king praised him outside the Grand Palace on the evening of Oct. 23 as he knelt with thousands of other well-wishers.

Mr. Thitiwat said the encounter was not staged, as critics have suggested. He burst into tears of emotion and later couldn鈥檛 sleep. The video he posted of the meeting went viral.

But many were not sympathetic. They accused the king of stoking division by praising Mr. Thitiwat while ignoring protest demands. A week later, the king said protesters were 鈥渓oved all the same,鈥 but there has been no royal response to their demands.

Some radical monarchists say they are ready for violence, but Mr. Thitiwat saw no place for that.

鈥淭he kids are like family,鈥 he said. 鈥淚鈥檒l try to be tougher and endure the hatred.鈥

This story was reported by Reuters. Reuters writer Chayut Setboonsarng contributed to this report.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
What is the Monitor difference? Tackling the tough headlines 鈥 with humanity. Listening to sources 鈥 with respect. Seeing the story that others are missing by reporting what so often gets overlooked: the values that connect us. That鈥檚 Monitor reporting 鈥 news that changes how you see the world.
QR Code to Reform or reverence? Thai royalists, protesters size up monarchy.
Read this article in
/World/Asia-Pacific/2020/1113/Reform-or-reverence-Thai-royalists-protesters-size-up-monarchy
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe