COVID-19 and the (possibly) changing climate debate
-
Ned Temko Correspondent
| London
鈥淲ill we learn the lessons?鈥�
As the COVID-19 pandemic spreads worldwide, that question is being heard ever more widely. Yet the potentially more critical question is what lessons we鈥檒l learn. And on at least one key policy challenge, climate change, the terms of debate have been getting clearer and starker.聽
Climate change will be far from the only subject of post-pandemic policy debate, given the sheer scale of the human cost of the COVID crisis and the unprecedented economic and political actions governments are taking to constrain it. Tug of wars are certain to surface domestically on issues like welfare provision, public health, economic security, or the trade-off between surveillance and individual rights. Internationally, we'll see them on the future of badly strained international institutions, the workings of the global economy, and relations with China.
Why We Wrote This
Many climate activists see the world's community-spirited response to the coronavirus as potentially shaping a more robust response to another collective challenge: global warming.
Yet even as the pandemic continues to spread, the 鈥渨hat lessons鈥� question has brought a dramatically new context and urgency to the debate around climate change.
Editor鈥檚 note: As a public service,聽all our coronavirus coverage聽is free. No paywall.
For those already urging a far stronger worldwide response 鈥� scientists, policy specialists, politicians, and the growing numbers of grassroots campaigners inspired by the teenage Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg 鈥� the pandemic is being viewed as a potentially pivotal moment.聽
They鈥檙e presenting it as important new evidence both of why action on climate change matters, and why such action is also possible if leaders summon the political will.
Exhibit A
Exhibit A聽came in late February, with satellite photos of mainland China in the wake of its economic shutdowns聽showing聽a dramatic聽drop in emissions of one toxic gas, nitrogen dioxide.聽By聽midway through March, scientists聽were estimating a roughly 25% decrease from the usual level of carbon emissions聽in China, the world鈥檚 single largest source of the pollutant.
Since then, millions of people across the world have seen and felt the environmental effects of COVID-related economic lockdowns. In large cities from New Delhi to Bangkok in Asia, London to Rome in Europe, and New York to Bogota in the Americas, not only were the streets suddenly quieter, the air was much clearer.
And in what climate activists see as an important signpost for the way forward, huge numbers of people have responded to COVID-19 鈥� like global warming, a product of human interaction with the natural world 鈥� with generosity, altruism, and community-spirited action.
The main lesson climate activists are drawing, however, is that in times of crisis, with a scientific consensus on what is necessary and what will work, leaders can act decisively. For the advocates of stronger action on climate change, the takeaway is clear. As Ms. Thunberg remarked on a recent Zoom call with fellow activists and supporters, 鈥�every crisis needs to be treated like a crisis.鈥�
The advocates of climate change action also know, of course, that the shutdown of wide areas of the world鈥檚 major economies is, in the longer run, neither sustainable nor desirable. Their hope 鈥� reflected in an open letter last month by an alliance of scientists, politicians, religious leaders, and climate activists 鈥� is that in the push to revive and rebuild world economies, greener priorities become the drivers.
That鈥檚 where the other side of the debate, the pushback, is likely to come to the fore. And there have already been signs of the tradeoffs that major governments are going to have to weigh.
Oil and airlines
Take the world's largest economy, the United States. The oil industry and the airlines, two major contributors to carbon emissions, have been severely hit. Given the prospect of continued low oil prices and reduced air travel even when the worst of the COVID-19 crisis has passed, the federal government will have to decide how extensively to intervene in support of their recovery. The signs from the Trump administration, at least so far, is that both are likely to receive high-priority attention.
In France, where President Emmanuel Macron has been an advocate of international action on climate change, it is clear he, too, will face difficult decisions. In an effort last year to blunt the 鈥渄irect democracy鈥� demands of yellow-vest protesters who had been staging street demonstrations across the country, he empowered a citizens鈥� panel to come up with policy recommendations on reducing emissions. He pledged not to ignore them. But the agenda they鈥檝e produced includes radical constraints on everything from air travel and automobile sales to telecommunications infrastructure 鈥� now coinciding with a COVID-19 crisis that is expected to shrink France鈥檚 economy this year by at least 6%.
Nor is China immune. In the first three months of the year, its economy shrank by 6.8% 鈥� the first such contraction since official quarterly GDP figures were first released nearly three decades ago.
In theory at least, President Xi Jinping could further re-burnish his post-crisis international image by prioritizing lower-carbon technologies in his drive to get the economy growing again.聽
There would be another potential advantage to doing that. The main policy tool used to respond to the last major economic jolt 鈥� the 2008 world financial crisis 鈥� might not be as attractive this time around. Back then, the answer was a huge financial stimulus. It worked. Yet it also hugely raised the scale of debt inside China, a problem President Xi has in recent years been actively seeking to bring under control.
Still, the immediate imperative 鈥� for Mr. Xi鈥檚 authoritarian regime no less than for democratically elected leaders like President Trump or President Macron 鈥� will be to get a comprehensively battered economy back in action as quickly as possible. So it鈥檚 at least as likely that the Chinese leader will focus on reviving his country鈥檚 existing economic machine.
This story was published as part of Covering Climate Now, a global journalism collaboration strengthening coverage of the climate story.
Editor鈥檚 note: As a public service,聽all our coronavirus coverage聽is free. No paywall.
