海角大神

House GOP blocks Obama immigration plan, but there's an asterisk

House Republicans voted to defund Obama's executive action on immigration. But the effort is likely to fail in the Senate, and a path to piecemeal immigration reform might remain.

|
J. Scott Applewhite/AP
Rep. Tom Cole, (R) of Oklahoma said in a Monitor interview that he still believes pieces of immigration reform could be passed.

House Republicans vented their anger at President Obama Wednesday by denying him the funds he needs to carry out his executive immigration action.

But will that be the epitaph for immigration reform during the Obama years?

To hardliners like Rep. Steve King (R) of Iowa, yes. But some more moderate Republicans still see a glimmer of hope for moving forward on immigration reform 鈥 not as a single, comprehensive bill but on smaller pieces that could get bipartisan support.

The template for that would be December鈥檚 vote to fund most of the federal government through September, says Rep. Tom Cole (R) of Oklahoma. The bill passed with the support of roughly two-thirds of Republicans and one-third of Democrats, sidelining dozens of hard-line conservatives.

"That's the only formula that鈥檚 really going to work in this situation," said Representative Cole, a close ally of the speaker, in an interview with the Monitor. Ditto for any other major reforms that Congress might tackle in the next two years, he adds.

It might not work. An attempt by House Speaker John Boehner (R) of Ohio to move immigration reform forward last year never even got past the discussion stage. But the situation might be different this time. Not only can House Republicans count on the GOP-controlled Senate as an ally, but Republicans' need to woo Hispanic voters ahead of the 2016 presidential elections could shift the political calculus.

"John Boehner has made no secret of the fact that he wants us to attack this problem," Cole says, but first, "you've got to let him play out his hand."

That meant moving forward with the effort Wednesday by House Republicans to block funding for Mr. Obama's executive action, which was attached to a funding bill for the Department of Homeland Security. It now moves to the GOP-controlled Senate but it is highly unlikely to survive a Democratic filibuster there. The White House also has threatened a veto.

The House鈥檚 move "is primarily a reaction to the president, whom we think is overreaching, and we鈥檙e going to have this fight," Cole says.

But his eye is already on areas of potential agreement among some Republicans, Democrats, and the White House, such as better border security, more high-tech visas, as well as a seasonal program for agricultural workers, which especially affects Republican districts.

"It behooves us to follow with some other things that we know Democrats and the president can accept," he says.

Representative King, one of the most conservative members of the House, dismisses such talk. Obama鈥檚 November executive action to defer deportation for millions of undocumented immigrants showed that 鈥渢he president has proven he鈥檚 less trustworthy than before. So ... there isn鈥檛 much merit in the idea of going down a path and thinking that we can do something to improve immigration policy when we have a president who thinks he鈥檚 the king of America,鈥 he told a small group of reporters on Tuesday.

Immigration reform, he said, will have to wait for another president.

Cole doesn鈥檛 deny the anger over Obama鈥檚 actions, which is widespread. But he says that things have changed since last January, when Boehner failed to persuade House Republicans to back a set of 鈥減rinciples鈥 on immigration reform due to lack of trust in the president and concern about the mid-term elections.

House Republicans also were worried that the Democratic-led Senate would take any bill they passed and try to turn it into the comprehensive reform bill the Senate passed in 2013.

"The fear was always that if you got into that [and sent House bills over to the Senate], you鈥檇 see the full Senate bill attached, and kicked back to us. So the decision was made not to go ahead," Cole says.

That concern is now gone.

The upcoming presidential election has also altered the landscape. Presidential elections tend to draw far more Democratic voters than midterms do, making Republican senators 鈥 and the Republican presidential candidate 鈥 vulnerable. Appealing to Hispanic voters, who traditionally lean Democratic, through immigration reform might be one way to undercut that advantage.

If moving ahead means following December鈥檚 budget-vote formula, one key pro-immigration reform Democrat is all for it. When asked whether the budget model might work for immigration reform, Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D) of Illinois, said 鈥渁bsolutely it is possible.鈥 Despite his admittedly 鈥渉arsh鈥 language on reform, he said he 鈥 and the president 鈥 are still willing to listen to Republican ideas.

鈥淚鈥檓 willing. We are all waiting,鈥 he said, pointing to the many concessions he made as a member of a House 鈥済ang of eight鈥 who tried to hammer out a bipartisan compromise.

But Congressman Gutierrez also staunchly defended the president鈥檚 executive action, pointing to President Harry Truman鈥檚 1948 executive order to desegregate the US armed forces -- and the two decades that elapsed before Congress passed landmark civil rights and voting rights legislation.

鈥淧residents do take these kinds of issues on,鈥 he said. 鈥淵ou want to debate whether he鈥檚 gone too far? Take it to the court.鈥

That鈥檚 exactly what may happen, if House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R) of Virginia has his way. At a Monitor Breakfast on Wednesday morning, the chairman said that if the House鈥檚 effort to block the president鈥檚 immigration 鈥渙verreach鈥 ultimately fails, Congress should sue.

He told reporters that immigration would be 鈥渁 very hot topic鈥 at a two-day retreat for House and Senate Republicans in Hershey, Pa., that begins Wednesday. And while he says his committee is reviewing and revising the immigration bills passed in the last Congress, he won鈥檛 be rushed.

鈥淔or the committee, I think it鈥檚 most important for us to stay focused on getting it done right, rather than getting it done under any particular timeline, or for any political purpose, because this is going to endure well beyond 2016.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to House GOP blocks Obama immigration plan, but there's an asterisk
Read this article in
/USA/Politics/DC-Decoder/2015/0114/House-GOP-blocks-Obama-immigration-plan-but-there-s-an-asterisk
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe