Did overturning Roe hand Democrats a lifeline? The view from Virginia.
| Culpeper, Va.
Wearing a pink linen blazer and her congressional pin on a necklace chain, Abigail Spanberger bounces in the passenger seat of Roy Whitlock鈥檚 old truck as the octogenarian farmer drives his congresswoman to the wooded pasture where his cattle are hiding from the August sun.听
Mr. Whitlock tells Ms. Spanberger about how his life has gotten harder recently, now that filling up his truck with gas a few times is equivalent to the profit from selling a calf.
The farm is one of several stops on a Field to Fridge Supply Chain Tour, in which Representative Spanberger is meeting with farmers, business owners, and voters in Virginia鈥檚 new 7th Congressional District that stretches from the northern suburbs to western farmlands. She has just come from a roundtable where farmers were lamenting the labor shortages impacting almost every area of their work, from truck drivers to veterinarians.听
Why We Wrote This
Pundits originally predicted that overturning Roe wouldn鈥檛 have much impact on November鈥檚 elections. But the summer is suggesting otherwise.
Concerns about labor shortages, inflation, gun violence, democracy, and an array of other issues have led a vast majority of Americans to say the country is on the 鈥溾�� ahead of this fall鈥檚 midterm elections. That pessimism, coupled with President Joe Biden鈥檚 low approval ratings and the tendency for post-presidential midterms to swing against the party in power, has led to grim election forecasts for the Democratic Party.听
But in late June, following the Supreme Court ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women鈥檚 Health Organization that overturned Roe v. Wade, Democratic strategists and pollsters saw a glimmer of hope. With polls showing the support legal abortion, and protests erupting across the country, some Democrats reorganized their campaign messaging around a woman鈥檚 right to choose. Subsequent electoral tests this summer, such as on a Kansas ballot measure and , suggested the Dobbs decision might work to counteract the 鈥渞ed wave鈥� pollsters had predicted this November.听
To be sure, Democrats still face a challenging landscape 鈥� especially in competitive House races like Virginia鈥檚 7th District. As Ms. Spanberger knows, many voters have serious economic concerns, which are often the top priority when casting a ballot. Abortion is likely to be just one issue among many that voters will consider when they head to the polls. Still, it appears to be giving Democrats a measurable boost, scrambling the political calculus and suggesting a Republican takeover of Congress is no longer a slam-dunk.听听
鈥淟et鈥檚 say, hypothetically, the economy is where it was three years ago, Joe Biden has a 50% job approval rating and the country is humming along 鈥� and then we have a reversal of Roe. That could really make a difference,鈥� says Charlie Cook, a political analyst and founder of the Cook Political Report. 鈥淏ut that鈥檚 not the circumstance that we have. Will it motivate some people? Yes. But there are so many other things that are going on.鈥澨�
A shift toward Democrats
Polling suggests the national landscape has improved for Democrats in recent weeks.听
Just last week, for the first time this year, Democrats eked out a narrow lead (albeit of 0.1%) over Republicans in 听generic congressional ballot test. And a found more Americans would prefer Democratic over Republican control of Congress, an improvement from June. Likewise, a Fox News poll from last week found voters evenly split between preferring a Democrat or a Republican candidate for Congress, after Republicans had held a 7-point advantage in May 鈥� with the shift .
鈥淭here is a nervousness that鈥檚 there among Republican strategists that wasn鈥檛 really there 30 or 45 days ago,鈥� says Mr. Cook. 鈥淵ou don鈥檛 have to paint them a picture about how this could go the wrong way.鈥澨�
Democrats have also gained confidence from recent legislative wins 鈥� particularly the Inflation Reduction Act, which takes historic steps toward addressing climate change, along with lowering the costs of prescription drugs and raising taxes on corporations. Passage of that bill came shortly after the killing of Al Qaeda鈥檚 leader in Afghanistan, gas prices dropping below $4 a gallon, and a strong jobs report, rounding out a spate of positive news cycles for the Biden administration.听
But the biggest source of optimism for Democrats unexpectedly came from Kansas, where 听of voters in that largely conservative state voted earlier this month against removing abortion protections from the state constitution, with higher than expected turnout in . 鈥淜ansas is the earthquake that is going to rattle every assumption about what is going to happen this fall,鈥� Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee Chairman Sean Patrick Maloney听听
Then last week, in two special U.S. House elections in Minnesota and Nebraska districts 鈥� both areas former President Donald Trump had won by double digits in 2020 鈥� Republican candidates , with Democrats over-performing in .听
鈥淭here鈥檚 still time for things to snap back before November, but we鈥檙e no longer living in a political environment as pro-GOP as November 2021,鈥� Cook Political Report鈥檚 House editor David Wasserman tweeted .听
GOP strategists are quick to point out that a ballot measure on one specific issue is very different from a multifaceted congressional election in which voters are weighing candidates and a variety of issues. They say the abortion ruling may help Democrats cut in on Republicans鈥� margins somewhat, but not enough to pull off outright wins.
鈥淧eople can latch onto anything for hope,鈥� says Matt Gorman, former communications director for the National Republican Congressional Committee and current vice president at Targeted Victory. 鈥淭he midterms are going to be dominated by the economy and inflation. That鈥檚 what people are feeling right now, and in every poll that鈥檚 what they鈥檙e caring about.鈥澨�
To Mr. Gorman鈥檚 point, the found that 24% of voters ranked economic policy as the most important issue in a congressional vote choice, followed by gun control policy (which has almost doubled in importance over the past three months) and abortion policy (which has actually fallen by 8 percentage points) tied at 17%. In third place is health control policy, followed by climate change and then immigration.听
Ms. Spanberger recognizes the array of issues voters are considering.听
鈥淚n a room full of people you might have, you know, 10 there who were there because they care about democracy-related issues and they鈥檙e worried about the fact that so many colleagues wouldn鈥檛 certify the election. You might have some folks who are just like, 鈥榊ou are the ones voting to lower prescription drug costs and that鈥檚 my issue,鈥欌�� Ms. Spanberger tells the Monitor after her truck ride with Mr. Whitlock.听
鈥淭hen there鈥檚 going to be people who are motivated because of the Dobbs decision,鈥� adds the congresswoman. 鈥淪o I don鈥檛 think it鈥檚, like, the singular animating issue. But from what I鈥檝e witnessed thus far, there are people for whom life is OK. Yes, maybe gas is more expensive and there are challenges here and there, but knowing we are in a position where there is a right that has been in place for 50 years and we鈥檙e now backtracking 鈥� for a certain group, that鈥檚 a pretty animating issue.鈥澨�
View from a competitive House district
Ms. Spanberger鈥檚 reelection campaign may be one of several House races where this is particularly so. Holding one of the this fall, Ms. Spanberger is running in a new 7th District that was redrawn to include both rural and suburban areas around Culpeper and Fredericksburg. Her campaign highlights the two-term congresswoman鈥檚 moderate bona fides: She was recently ranked the of the U.S. House by The Lugar Center.听
Her Republican opponent, Yesli Vega, a Prince William County board supervisor and former police officer in northern Virginia, has drawn national attention as one of several Republican Latina candidates running for office this year. She at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) earlier this month about the GOP鈥檚 ability to attract new support among minority voters.听
But Ms. Vega also made news earlier this summer when, in response to a question about state-level abortion restrictions, she by questioning a woman鈥檚 ability to get pregnant following a rape. Ms. Vega and her campaign did not respond to the Monitor鈥檚 repeated requests for comment.听
Steve Mourning, chair of the Culpeper GOP and a software developer, says he鈥檚 feeling a level of energy among Republican voters comparable to 2020, when Republican Nick Freitas lost to Ms. Spanberger by .听
鈥淎bortion just doesn鈥檛 seem to be that big of a factor in the race. Folks are suffering from inflation and gas prices,鈥� says Mr. Mourning, adding that a few of the Republican committee鈥檚 retired members stopped coming to meetings in person due to the cost of gas.听听
But Jen Heinz, co-chair of the neighboring Orange County Democrats, says the issue of abortion has been coming up regularly when she is out canvassing.听
鈥淚n the past couple of weeks, you can really feel the uptick in support,鈥� says Ms. Heinz.听
At the county fair in late June, shortly after the Supreme Court ruling came down, Ms. Heinz says three young women approached the Orange County Democrats鈥� booth to ask about Ms. Spanberger鈥檚 position on abortion. After Ms. Heinz responded that the congresswoman had voted to codify a woman鈥檚 right to an abortion into law, one of the girls asked how she could register to vote.
鈥淗ere is a young woman who has never voted before,鈥� says Ms. Heinz, 鈥渂ut feels motivated to fill out the form.鈥�
