A conspiracy theory goes to Washington: Three questions about QAnon
It started online in 2017 with a cryptic post on a bulletin board known for its inflammatory right-wing memes. Since then, it has openly gained a foothold in the halls of power.
QAnon, a phenomenon variously described as a sprawling conspiracy theory, a millenarian religion, and, to its adherents, a mass political movement aimed at cleansing the world鈥檚 governments of satanic child molesters, has rapidly materialized as a force to be reckoned with. Thirteen GOP congressional candidates who have expressed support for the movement will be on the ballot in November, and several of those have already won their primaries in safe districts.
Where did this all come from?
Why We Wrote This
Typically, believers in the most elaborate conspiracy theories are far removed from the halls of power. But adherents of the false QAnon worldview are becoming influential in some of Washington鈥檚 highest offices.
On Oct. 28, 2017, an anonymous poster claiming to have top-secret government access posted on the free-for-all anonymous internet site 4chan. The poster, now known as 鈥淨,鈥� wrote that President Donald Trump was planning a countercoup against the so-called deep state, the purported hidden government within the U.S. government that actually pulls the strings.
Since then, Q has been regularly posting on various conservative message boards, offering more information 鈥渄rops鈥� on the coming purge. 鈥淓njoy the show鈥� is a common QAnon slogan.
QAnon is often seen as an offshoot of the Pizzagate conspiracy theory 鈥� which linked several high-ranking Democratic officials and several Washington-area restaurants to an alleged child prostitution ring. The QAnon conspiracy takes Pizzagate further, falsely claiming that high-ranking government officials and other elites around the world are running a satanic child sex trafficking/murdering operation. These criminals, the QAnon conspiracy goes, will soon be arrested en masse and either shipped to Guantanamo Bay or executed. Some QAnon believers think that John F. Kennedy Jr., who died in a plane crash in July 1999 off Martha鈥檚 Vineyard, actually faked his death and will return to help overthrow the deep state.
Harvard political scientist Nancy Rosenblum, author of 鈥淎 Lot of People Are Saying: The New Conspiracism and the Assault on Democracy,鈥� argues that QAnon represents a hybrid between traditional conspiracy theories and a new kind of thinking, what she calls 鈥渃onspiracy without the theory.鈥�
On the one hand, 鈥渋t鈥檚 not about anything. Nothing has happened yet,鈥� Professor Rosenblum says. 鈥淚t鈥檚 a prophetic prediction.鈥� Unlike traditional conspiracy theories, which seek to uncover evidence of secret machinations by the powerful, she says that the new form relies on bare assertions, repetition, and attacking sources of knowledge.
鈥淚t鈥檚 a closed system,鈥� she says of QAnon鈥檚 theory. 鈥淭he evidence against it is the evidence for it because the evidence comes from the enemy.鈥�
鈥淥n the other hand,鈥� she says, 鈥淨Anon does seem to have the apparatus of a theory.鈥� And聽it's one with an ominous historical resonance, she says. It links the enemy to sexual degeneracy. It says the enemy doesn鈥檛 deserve to live. And it has leaped from discussion boards to the real world.
鈥淨 is this open source thing,鈥� Professor Rosenblum says. 鈥淚t has the characteristic of a participatory role-playing game.鈥�
Why does QAnon matter?
Though it sounds like a fringe movement, it鈥檚 joining the Republican mainstream. This year, 63 QAnon supporters ran in congressional primaries in 27 states and received nearly 600,000 votes, according to Media Matters. Of these candidates, 13 are poised to be on the ballot in November. The most prominent of these, Marjorie Taylor Greene, a Georgia GOP candidate from a safe Republican district, called Q a 鈥減atriot鈥� in a 2018 video.
QAnon has also made significant inroads into the White House. In 2018, President Trump invited a QAnon believer to meet him in the Oval Office. And, according to a November 2019 New York Times report, President Trump has retweeted accounts from QAnon and other promoters of 鈥渇ringe鈥� conspiracies 145 times. More recently, Michael Flynn, President Trump鈥檚 first national security adviser, posted a video in which he leads a small group in reciting, at the end of an oath of office, a QAnon slogan: 鈥淲here we go one, we go all.鈥�
It鈥檚 very difficult to gauge QAnon鈥檚 popular support, but an investigation by the Guardian newspaper in June found more than 3 million followers supporting QAnon on Facebook, a number that is growing fast.
Kathryn Olmsted, a University of California, Davis political scientist and the author of the 2009 book 鈥淩eal Enemies: Conspiracy Theories and American Democracy, World War I to 9/11,鈥� says that QAnon is remarkable in both its complexity and its extremism.
鈥淚t鈥檚 quite elaborate,鈥� she says. 鈥淚t is extreme, though. Some of its theories seem quite outrageous to people who aren鈥檛 on the inside.鈥�
She suggests that the complexity is part of QAnon鈥檚 appeal. 鈥淔or many people a conspiracy is like a game, like a puzzle people can solve,鈥� she says. 鈥淥nce you have the internet, there are always clues online.鈥�
How are social media platforms dealing with this?
On July 21, Twitter permanently removed about 7,000 accounts associated with QAnon, and limited 150,000 more.
In a聽聽posted on the platform via its @TwitterSafety account, the company announced that it will refuse to serve any accounts associated with QAnon. It also announced other measures to prevent QAnon content from spreading on its platform, including blocking URLs and limiting its appearance in search results.
The New York Times聽聽that Facebook, which in May聽removed several groups associated with QAnon, is set to take further聽measures against the movement. Two Facebook workers who spoke anonymously to the paper said that the company is coordinating with Twitter and other platforms and plans to make an announcement next month.
Twitter and Facebook are not the first to enact QAnon bans. In 2018, Reddit banned the QAnon subreddit r/GreatAwakening for violating the site鈥檚 policy against 鈥渋nciting violence, harassment, and the dissemination of personal information.鈥� Last month,聽the video-streaming company Roku removed a dedicated QAnon channel from its options.
Experts note that bans can be effective. Joan Donovan, of the nonprofit Data and Society, talked to Vice Magazine about her research on what happens when figures like Alex Jones and Milo Yiannopoulos are banned from large networks. 鈥淕enerally the falloff is pretty significant,鈥� she said, 鈥渁nd they don鈥檛 gain the same amplification power they had.鈥�
But no ban can be 100% effective. For instance,聽The Guardian reports that many groups Facebook鈥檚 dragnet in May by changing their name to 鈥�17,鈥� a reference to Q鈥檚 position in the alphabet. Others simply to conservative social media platforms like Parler and Gab.
