海角大神

With stalemate looming, Iran needs nuclear deal more than US

Nuclear talks between Iran and six world powers are almost certain to go on past Tuesday's deadline, making a stalemate increasingly likely.

|
Laurent Gillieron/Keystone via AP/File
US Secretary of State John Kerry, right, speaks with Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif in January, as they walk in Geneva, Switzerland. A stalemate between six world powers and Iran on a nuclear deal is looking increasingly likely ahead of the June 30 deadline.

With the Iran nuclear talks almost certain to grind on past a Tuesday deadline, prospects for a stalemate that puts off further efforts to reach a deal on Iran鈥檚 nuclear program appear to be growing.聽聽

If the two sides in the talks 鈥 six world powers and Iran 鈥 do walk away from the negotiating table, even if for just a matter of weeks, the pause will largely reflect the economic and political crosscurrents the Iranian leadership is navigating, some regional analysts say.

鈥淭he supreme leader is in a dilemma鈥 that juxtaposes dueling economic and political 鈥渋mperatives,鈥 says Karim Sadjadpour, an Iran expert at Washington鈥檚 Carnegie Endowment for International Peace (CEIP), referring to Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

Allowing the talks to enter a stalemate, with the issue of Iran鈥檚 nuclear program going unresolved for additional months or longer, is a bigger problem for Iran than for the US and other world powers, some experts say.

鈥淚ran clearly needs this deal [while] the US wants this deal,鈥 says Mr. Sadjadpour, underscoring what he calls the 鈥渁symmetry鈥 in the importance a deal represents to the two sides.

Iran鈥檚 hard-hit economy would receive a substantial boost if international sanctions were lifted under a nuclear deal,聽 Sadjadpour says. But at the same time, Mr. Khamenei鈥檚 hard-line political base would find it hard to swallow a deal that offers too much compromise to Western powers, and in particular the United States.

Khamenei is presented with 鈥渁n economic imperative to sign the deal鈥 while 鈥渉ardliners [represent] a political imperative to continue to resist the US,鈥 says Sadjadpour. At some point, he adds, those two motivating factors 鈥渁re irreconcilable.鈥

The world could know on Tuesday how Khamenei has decided to address the dueling pressures, at least for now. Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif, who left the talks in Vienna on Sunday for consultations back in Tehran, is expected back Tuesday with either an 鈥渁ye鈥 or a 鈥渘ay鈥 in his pocket to wrap up negotiations under the terms of a 鈥渇ramework鈥 agreement reached in April. 聽聽

Last week, Khamenei gave a speech in which he laid down 鈥渞ed lines鈥 for a final nuclear deal 鈥 most notably ruling out inspections of military sites as part of any inspections regime 鈥 that appeared to be at odds with what Iran agreed to in April.

Resolving the outstanding areas of disagreement remains possible, if not by the Tuesday deadline then within the first few days of July, backers of a deal as laid out in the framework agreement say.

鈥淣egotiators are focused on completing the deal by June 30, but more important is getting the details of the deal right,鈥 says Kelsey Davenport, director for nonproliferation policy at the Arms Control Association (ACA) in Washington.

Ms. Davenport, who is in Vienna for the talks, says the two sides are 鈥渙n their way to reaching agreement on the technical implementation鈥 of key outstanding issues 鈥渨ithin the next several days.鈥 The requirements of the two sides 鈥渙verlap just enough鈥 to allow for meeting core demands and a comprehensive deal, ACA experts say.

As for Khamenei鈥檚 鈥渞ed lines,鈥 Davenport says they were 鈥渘ot helpful鈥 but that the supreme leader has made 鈥渟imilar comments in the past鈥 that turned out to be more political positioning than unbendable requirements.

But others who see this as a defining moment for Iran are not so sure.

Based on the turn of events at other pivotal moments in the decade of on-and-off negotiations with Iran on its nuclear program, Foreign Minister Zarif may very well return from presenting Khamenei with the world powers鈥 bottom line and say, 鈥 鈥楽orry, I鈥檝e just been in Tehran ... and we can鈥檛 do that,鈥 鈥 says George Perkovich, vice president for studies and nuclear nonproliferation expert at Carnegie Endowment.

If that happens, Dr. Perkovich says he would expect the talks to break off and for Secretary of State John Kerry to return to Washington to allow the administration to consider what to do next.

鈥淚t鈥檚 not the worst thing for Kerry to come home and for there to be a pause in the process,鈥 says Perkovich, who adds that he does not 鈥渆xpect the next couple of days to yield an agreement.鈥

Iranian leaders insisted over the weekend that their country is not desperate to reach an accord with the six world powers. 鈥淒o not think that Iran needs a deal,鈥 said Ali Larijani, the speaker of Iran鈥檚 parliament, in comments Sunday on an official broadcast. 鈥淚 do not want [the West] to think that if you exert more pressure, Iran will tolerate it.鈥

But others say Iran鈥檚 economic straits and broad public support for a deal belie such bravado. 聽聽

President Obama would still like to secure a nuclear deal with Iran as part of a legacy of 鈥渞econciliation,鈥 Sadjadpour says. But he says that in any case the US has impressed its partners in the talks, including Russia and China, that it truly does want a deal with Iran 鈥 and he says that will continue to color relations among the six powers even if the nuclear talks enter a period of stalemate.

鈥淭here鈥檚 a sense that Washington has made unprecedented overtures to Iran,鈥 he says.

On the other hand, failure to reach a deal is likely to soon enough return the US-Iran relationship to one of open confrontation, others say. An Iran outside the limitations of ongoing negotiations might re-accelerate its nuclear program and advance its steps toward nuclear weapons capability.

鈥淚f the negotiations fail to the point of an open break 鈥 the resulting failure will make all of the current tensions far worse,鈥 says Anthony Cordesman, a national security expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, says in a Monday. 鈥淎ny such end to the talks will again raise the issue of Israeli or US preventive strikes.鈥 聽

But unlike Obama鈥檚 hoped-for legacy of reconciliation, Sadjadpour says Khamenei, who is likely entering the twilight of his reign, is tending 鈥渁 legacy almost of resistance.鈥

If no deal is reached this week, Perkovich says the world also has to consider the Iranian perspective that past experience with the West鈥檚 covert operations has made backing down on red lines 鈥渞eally difficult.鈥

Putting himself in Iranian shoes, Perkovich says, 鈥淵ou want to visit our scientists so you can assassinate them 鈥 You want to visit our military sites so you can know where to target us militarily.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to With stalemate looming, Iran needs nuclear deal more than US
Read this article in
/USA/Foreign-Policy/2015/0629/With-stalemate-looming-Iran-needs-nuclear-deal-more-than-US
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe