海角大神

The new normal in adoption: Birth parent no longer secret

A new survey shows that more than 55 percent of adoption cases are fully open -- and 95 percent involve at least some relationships between birth parent and adoptive family.

|
John Tarrats/AP
The new normal in adoption, a new study shows, is openness. There are at least some birth parent and adoptive family relations in 95 percent of all adoptions. For example, Dawne Era (right) of Warwick, R.I. and her adopted son, Grady, (left) 鈥 pictured here on a holiday in London in 2008 鈥 have maintained contact with his birth mother.

The secrecy that long shrouded听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽has given way to聽openness, and only about 5 percent of infant听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍s聽in the US now take place without some ongoing relationship between birth parent and聽adoptive聽family, according to a comprehensive new report.

Based on a survey of 100听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽agencies, the Evan B.聽Donaldson聽Adoption聽Institute reported today that the new norm is for birth parents considering听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽to meet with prospective聽adoptive parents and pick the new family for their baby.

Of the roughly 14,000 to 18,000 infant听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍s聽each year, about 55 percent are fully聽open, with the parties agreeing to ongoing contact that includes the child, the report said. About 40 percent are "mediated"听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍s in which the听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽agency facilitates periodic exchanges of pictures and letters, but there is typically no direct contact among the parties.

"The degree of聽openness聽should be tailored to the preferences of the individual participants," said Chuck Johnson of the National Council for聽Adoption, which represents about 60 agencies. "It points to the huge importance of the right people being matched with each other."

The聽Donaldson聽institute, citing its own research and numerous other studies, said most participants find open听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍s聽a positive experience. In general, the report said,聽adoptive聽families are more satisfied with the adoption聽process, birth mothers experience less regret and worry, and the聽adopted聽children benefit by having access to their birth relatives, as well as to their family and medical histories.

"The good news is that听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽in our country is traveling a road toward greater聽openness聽and honesty," said Adam Pertman, the institute's executive director. "But this new reality also brings challenges, and there are still widespread myths and misconceptions about聽open听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍."

The challenges, according to Mr. Pertman and other听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽experts, often involve mismatched expectations as to the degree of post-adoption contact. The聽Donaldson聽report recommends counseling and training for all the adults involved, as well as post-adoption services to help them and their children work through any problems that arise.

The president of one of the largest US adoption聽agencies, Bill Blacquiere of Bethany 海角大神 Services, said his staff encourages expectant birth mothers to meet with the prospective聽adoptive聽family to discuss the array of options for an聽open听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍.

"As much as possible, we allow the parties to design that themselves," Mr. Blacquiere said. "We mediate to make sure both parties are getting what they need."

The post-adoption relationship may start out warily, then become more comfortable as time passes, but Blacquiere said each party should keep the other's expectations in mind even as circumstances change.

"For聽adoptive聽families, they need to make sure they live up to their commitments, and not try to go back on their initial agreement," he said. "On the birthparent side, they need to remember that this isn't co-parenting 鈥 part of their role has to be blessing the new home that their child has."

One common pattern, according to听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽agency officials, is that the birth parent initially wants more frequent contact with the child than the聽adoptive聽family prefers, followed by a gradual shift.

"When the children get older, it's often the聽adoptive聽families wanting more contact, and the birthparents may have moved on in their lives and at that point are interested in less," said David Nish, director of听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍 programs for New York-based Spence-Chapin聽Adoption聽Services.

Mr. Nish said Spence-Chapin espouses the principle of self-determination in working with birth mothers on their hopes for post-adoption arrangements. But he said the agency won't work with聽adoptive聽parents who insist on having no contact with the birth mother.

"We try to educate them," he said. "If they're really set on it being closed, we tell them we don't do closed adoptions."

For Dawne Era, a psychotherapist from Warwick, R.I., the decision to embrace an聽open听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽evolved step by step 23 years ago when she and her husband decided to聽adopt聽after unsuccessful attempts to conceive on their own.

They made contact with a pregnant 18-year-old from Nebraska who'd decided to place her baby up for adoption, then got to know her as the young woman spent her pregnancy in nearby Boston.

After the birth and听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽of a baby boy named Grady, the birth mother and the聽adoptive聽parents agreed to remain in contact. It was an informal pact, yet it led to a mutually satisfying relationship that has continued throughout Grady's life 鈥 occasional phone conversations, a handful of face-to-face visits and, more recently, ongoing contact via Facebook between Grady and his birth mother and his younger half-sister.

For Ms. Era, there was a stressful moment when she and her husband got divorced while Grady was a toddler, and she had to inform the birth mother.

"That was very difficult," Era said. "We had promised to take Grady in and raise him in a two-parent family. I thought she would be very disappointed in me, but she took it well."

Overall, said Era, the聽open听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍聽"has been very positive for all of us."

Mr. Pertman of the聽Donaldson Institute has a daughter聽adopted聽14 years ago. He said challenges can sometimes arise even after聽adoptive聽parents and birth parents grow comfortable with the rhythms of an聽open听补诲辞辫迟颈辞苍.

He recalled how many members of his daughter's birth family 鈥 including her birth mother, grandparents, a brother and an uncle 鈥 came to her bat mitzvah.

"For us and them it was normal, but not for everybody else in the room," Pertman said. "They got some looks, like 'What's this all about?' "

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to The new normal in adoption: Birth parent no longer secret
Read this article in
/The-Culture/Family/2012/0321/The-new-normal-in-adoption-Birth-parent-no-longer-secret
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe