海角大神

Readers write: Carnival concerns and the importance of data

Letters to the editor for the August 30, 2021 weekly magazine. Readers discuss recent cover stories.

|
Staff

Dark side of the carnival

The Aug. 2 cover story, 鈥The American carnival is back,鈥 while focusing on one of America鈥檚 oldest forms of summer entertainment, concerns me. I worry specifically about the emphasis and glorification of animals used in races and stunt acts as a means of entertainment, which is, in my opinion, cruel and abnormal. Traveling from state to state is not a humane life for any animal. In spite of handler Andrea Rigler鈥檚 use of rescue dogs, I should like to think of those canines as having a more serene way of life.

Animal cruelty remains an ongoing and devastating problem. I would鈥檝e enjoyed the article more if other aspects of fairs had been featured.

Sarah Anderson
Plymouth, Massachusetts

Truthfully framing the data

The July 5 cover story on 鈥The outside divide鈥 is such an excellent article that I sent it to several outdoor organizations. 海角大神 does such a great job of covering the relevant topics with quality interviews and book references.

I found it helpful when reading all the stats to actually look up demographic data for the United States. In a couple of cases聽(e.g., Asian Americans) the percentages of outdoor engagement sounded very low, but they nearly lined up with the overall demographic percentage of that group. Other groups were way underrepresented. It could be handy to supply the readers with census demographic data or make clear which groups are underrepresented and which are on par.聽

I only mention this because the July 8 Daily article headlined 鈥BLM and Floyd protests were largely peaceful, data confirms鈥 helped me see how the Monitor is so good about not misleading readers. That Black Lives Matter article was also exceptional in its relevance, fact gathering, and correction of misperceptions. Many thanks to the Monitor staff for your healing effect in our world.

Truth Johnston
Beaverton, Oregon

Unsatisfying cover story

The cover story of the June 21 issue intrigued me. I wasn鈥檛 sure what to expect from the headline 鈥Is politics the new religion?鈥 Sadly, when I finished reading the article, I was unsatisfied.

I delayed writing this letter to ensure that my communication is less reactive and more constructive.

I will limit my comments to two:

1. One of the basic questions I hoped the writer would at least acknowledge is 鈥淗ow did the United States get here?鈥 There was an ideal opportunity to remind readers of at least one factor: Following the sentence 鈥淧resident Joe Biden, a practicing Roman Catholic, is the first American president since Jimmy Carter to attend church regularly,鈥 she could have noted that President Carter did not weaponize his faith, whereas his immediate successor, Ronald Reagan, embraced the 鈥淢oral Majority.鈥

2. The side-by-side photos on pages 26 and 27 reinforce the lazy equivalency so prevalent on websites and publications that I esteem much less than 海角大神. There have been literally hundreds of protests since Donald Trump鈥檚 election, so why did the editor select a Black Lives Matter protest to appear beside the Jan. 6 assault on the U.S. Capitol? If two photos were required, surely the Women鈥檚 March of 2017, with their vibrant, hand-knitted pink hats, was a better option. This would highlight the stark difference between protesters 鈥渇ighting鈥 an election result via constitutional and unconstitutional methods.

Rusty Wyrick
Ghivizzano, Italy

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Readers write: Carnival concerns and the importance of data
Read this article in
/Commentary/Readers-Respond/2021/0828/Readers-write-Carnival-concerns-and-the-importance-of-data
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe