From Milan to Miami, locked-in nations try to soften an economic blow
| Washington, Berlin, and Mexico City
It鈥檚 a seemingly intractable dilemma, suddenly as salient in Berlin or Tokyo as it is in Washington: How do you save people鈥檚 economic livelihoods while telling those same people to stay home?聽
A global recession, many forecasters say, is already here and is growing more severe by the day, as millions of consumers and workers in Europe, Asia, and North America have been sidelined as governments take extreme measures to stem the COVID-19 pandemic.聽
Finally, though, actions by governments and central banks appear to be ramping up, not so much in an effort to prevent a recession as simply to weather a storm that could easily become more severe than the global financial crisis a decade ago.聽
Why We Wrote This
Turmoil in financial markets reflects widespread fears over a global recession amid the coronavirus pandemic. How policymakers respond could be critical to the length and depth of such a recession.
Help can鈥檛 come soon enough for Dominik Wilkinson and his co-workers at a restaurant in the northern German town of Bielefeld. The restaurant鈥檚 40 staff members are already working sharply reduced hours, and there鈥檚 talk in town of curfews starting Friday. A prolonged closure would be, 鈥渄eath, in terms of revenue. It鈥檚 basically the same for every small and medium-sized company,鈥� says Mr. Wilkinson, a shift manager.聽
[Editor鈥檚 note: As a public service,聽all our coronavirus coverage聽is free. No paywall.]
In the United States, the past few days have seen automakers mothball factories, hotel chains furlough tens of thousands of workers, and major retailers trim store hours or go online only. A Labor Department report today showed claims for unemployment benefits spiking to 281,000 last week. Every day brings more turmoil in global stock and bond markets as investors seek safe havens, even as central banks cough up amounts not seen since the financial meltdown of 2008.聽
Yet the situation鈥檚 very severity is spurring governments into action. Relief measures range from mortgage or tax holidays to cash infusions for households, while also lending or simply giving money to businesses to prevent mass layoffs or permanent closures.
Analysts say these are precisely the kinds of measures that can help, but their effectiveness will hinge greatly on their magnitude and speed of delivery. And what makes this crisis different, they add, is that a pandemic must also be tamed because the economic and health crises are intertwined.
The Group of Seven international economic organization has already issued a 鈥渨hatever it takes鈥� statement of determination. The International Monetary Fund and World Bank are . But so far it鈥檚 an open question whether global leadership today can match the kind of concerted effort that emerged from the depths of the 2008 crisis.聽
鈥淎 lot of people didn鈥檛 quite measure the gravity of the situation for a while, including myself to be honest,鈥� says Ioana Marinescu, an economist at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. 鈥淲e have to think about supporting business. That鈥檚 very important because if we allow businesses to fail, we are losing jobs. ... We鈥檙e also losing capital.鈥�
Economic side effects
The top priority remains a pandemic that has killed more than 9,000 people and spread to every continent except Antarctica. Yet, if the economic side effects are left unaddressed, the result would be significant human hardship of another kind. It is costly to rehire workers, let alone to start new businesses from scratch. And the more workers lose jobs and paychecks now, the sharper the downward spiral.聽
So in the U.S., members of Congress are considering emergency relief for the economy that could surpass $1 trillion in value, of which about half may be cash handouts to families that can be spent as quickly as possible. But in parallel, the Trump administration wants to bail out airlines and other hard-hit industries, and offer loans to help small businesses cope.聽
Other steps around the world include emergency loans in China and Japan, unemployment benefits for French workers forced into part-time status, and to halt evictions by landlords during the pandemic.
In Washington, a sense of urgency has blunted partisan edges, at least in part.聽On Wednesday, Republican Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell successfully urged his colleagues to approve a measure, crafted by Democrats in the House, to expand unemployment benefits and paid sick leave, and to make tests for the coronavirus free.
鈥淢ore than usually, this touches many, many, many actors and not just the most vulnerable. So I think that鈥檚 a reason to go broad鈥� with emergency support, says Dr. Marinescu.聽鈥淚t鈥檚 like we鈥檙e firefighting 鈥� first dropping water on the whole building,鈥� then thinking about more targeted relief going forward.
Last week, Germany green-lit a host of fiscal measures to offset the pandemic crunch. Companies large and small can access increased credit, apply for funds to pay idled workers, and seek tax deferrals.
But Katja Sator, owner of a precision engineering company in the southwest state of Baden-W眉rttemberg, worries the emergency aid only amounts to a 鈥渕ound of debt,鈥� whereas grants wouldn鈥檛 weigh down her balance sheet.
鈥淚t鈥檚 great that we鈥檙e receiving help with liquidity and that we can get new credit,鈥� says Ms. Sator, whose company, Frankenstein Pr盲zision GmBH,聽makes precision parts for automakers and other industries. 鈥淏ut we have to pay everything back. That means it鈥檚 not clear whether we鈥檒l be in the red for the year if we have to close down production.鈥澛�
She hasn鈥檛 laid anyone off, but she鈥檚 not extending temporary contracts. Her production lines are still running, with technicians spaced 2 meters (6 1/2 feet) apart.聽
Limits to monetary policy
As markets react to the pandemic, central banks have in many cases acted faster since they are inherently nimbler than legislatures. But unlike in 2008, when the crisis began in an over-leveraged financial sector, the coronavirus has slammed into the real economy, which monetary policy alone is hard-pressed to rescue.
On Tuesday, the U.S. Federal Reserve reopened two programs last used during the global financial crisis a decade ago, to keep the from clogging.
And on Wednesday, European Central Bank President Christine LaGarde cited 鈥渘o limits鈥� to as the bank launched an $820 billion program to buy government and corporate debt.
For all the actions underway, the question economists raise is what will be enough in these extraordinary times. Forecasting the depth of the slowdown is challenging; recent estimates suggest up to a 14% drop in U.S. economic output (annualized) in the second quarter.
Although the term 鈥渇iscal stimulus鈥� often is used for recession-fighting programs, the goal today is really about helping individuals and businesses survive this economic stallout. A rebound will come later. The challenge is to contain the current damage by slowing the spread of COVID-19 while minimizing job losses and firm closures.聽
鈥淩ight now what needs to happen is flattening the curve [of the outbreak] while still doing whatever it takes ... to keep the fabric of the economy and of society alive,鈥� says Fabio Ghironi, an economist at the University of Washington in Seattle.
That means economic rescue should include support for stretched health care systems, he says 鈥� something far different from recessions with purely economic causes.聽
The U.S. and other governments are making some big efforts, but Dr. Ghironi argue much more will be needed.聽聽
Mangoes for sale聽
Many less-developed economies face an especially hard time finding the resources for both a public-health crisis and an economic one.聽
In Mexico City, Julio Bisrreal Alcantaria stands beneath a lush green tree on the sidewalk beside his fruit truck slicing mangoes and papayas. He hasn鈥檛 seen much of a slowdown in business due to the coronavirus, he says, but expects nationwide school closures starting this week to hit his business hard.
鈥淚 can make it about two weeks with slow sales, and then I鈥檓 in trouble,鈥� he says. 鈥淚f kids aren鈥檛 in school and people aren鈥檛 going to their offices, I have no one to sell to.鈥澛�
Mr. Bisrreal is one of the estimated 30 million Mexicans working in the informal economy 鈥� without social security or job protections. As with gig economy workers in the U.S., flexibility becomes moot if a pandemic forces people indoors and consumer spending evaporates.聽
Mexico鈥檚 finance ministry has proposed lines of credit, debt refinancing, and helping small businesses stay afloat. But 鈥渢here鈥檚 no real discussion鈥� in the legislature about economic stimulus, says Valeria Moy, an economist at Mexico 驴Como Vamos?, a think tank.聽
School closings aside, President Andr茅s Manuel L贸pez Obrador has resisted an economywide lockdown, arguing that it would hurt poor people. There are 鈥減ressures of all types. Close the airport, shut down everything, paralyze the economy. No,鈥� he told a press conference.聽
Workers scramble for a foothold
Worldwide, the stakes are high.聽In Odemira, Portugal, Domingos Vicente owns a fruit distribution business with 40 employees, mostly migrants.聽
鈥淚f my business shuts down, I won鈥檛 be able to pay them to stay at home not working, and they will not stay around, which means it will be hard to start over again once it鈥檚 possible and hire new workers. That means trouble for the agricultural supply in Portugal.鈥�
In Italy, the nation hardest hit in Europe by the virus, the government is helping employers meet their payrolls and freezing loan and mortgage payments for many who are affected by the crisis.
But as in other nations, the emergency programs take time to reach people and may not be enough. That鈥檚 especially true for workers in the gig economy like Claudia Bellante, a freelance journalist in Milan. Her husband, a photographer, has seen his work dry up. He鈥檒l be eligible for some emergency grants, but she won鈥檛.聽
鈥淚 understand these are emergency measures for this time, but I worry when the pandemic ends we鈥檙e going to be in a very difficult place,鈥� Ms. Bellante says. 鈥淚 doubt there will be enough money for everyone.鈥�
Dr. Ghironi, the Italian-born economist at the University of Washington, says South Korea has shown how to fight the pandemic without economy-debilitating lockdowns by using prompt testing and infection tracing.聽Whatever steps work, he says the public-health approach and economic rescue go hand in hand.
鈥淲e need the resources and the stimulus to be injected, while the [public health] pieces of the mechanism are put in place, so the lockdown can be lifted as soon as possible.鈥�
Lenora Chu in Berlin, Whitney Eulich in Mexico City, and Catarina Fernandes Martins in Castelo Branco, Portugal, contributed to this article.
[Editor鈥檚 note: As a public service,聽all our coronavirus coverage聽is free. There is no paywall.]
