海角大神

'Moriarty' is a Sherlock Holmes tale with no Holmes in sight

'Moriarty' is far gorier than anything Arthur Conan Doyle ever penned.

Moriarty By Anthony Horowitz HarperCollins 304 pp.

When Sir Arthur Conan Doyle sent Sherlock Holmes plunging over Reichenbach Falls, he was thoroughly sick of the character that had made him famous. The last thing he intended was to give his consulting detective an escape route. Hence, Holmes鈥檚 subsequent resurrection in 鈥淭he Empty House鈥 may have struck some close readers of the text as a little, um, narratively problematic, as a result.

鈥淒oes anyone really believe what happened at Reichenbach Falls?鈥 Frederick Chase, the narrator of Anthony Horowitz鈥檚 new Moriarty, asks in the novel鈥檚 opening sentence, before pointing out a few of the larger plot holes.

For one thing, what possessed Holmes to flee London, which was his home turf and was peppered with boltholes where he could have gone to ground? 鈥淗olmes鈥 disguises were so brilliant that he could have spent the next three years as a Catholic priest without anyone being the wiser,鈥 Chase, a Pinkerton detective deployed to London, points out.

And if Moriarty was such a criminal mastermind, why on earth didn鈥檛 he bring a weapon to the showdown? Speaking of weapons, Moriarty鈥檚 No. 2, Colonel Sebastian Moran, was on hand at the falls: 鈥淸W]hy didn鈥檛 he try to help? Where is his gun? Has the greatest marksman in the world accidentally left it on the train?鈥

The creators of the BBC鈥檚 鈥淪herlock鈥 had a great deal of fun speculating about Holmes鈥檚 escape from death in 2014鈥檚 鈥淭he Empty Hearse.鈥 Fun, unfortunately, is one of the things missing from 鈥淢oriarty.鈥 Two others are Holmes and Watson.

That said, coming up with a new Sherlock Holmes story is not an enviable task: The character remains so popular that he鈥檚 solving crimes in not one, but two current TV series. (Elizabeth Bennet got her petticoats muddied in a crime-solving miniseries in 2013, and Jayne Eyre now sends texts, but Holmes appears to have a particularly strong grip on the public鈥檚 imagination.) Horowitz, the only author authorized by the Conan Doyle to produce sequels, has his work cut out for him. And he鈥檚 operating without Benedict Cumberbatch, which must be seen as a handicap.

The creator of 鈥淔oyle鈥檚 War,鈥 鈥淢idsomer Murders,鈥 and the "Alex Rider" series has a long and acclaimed history with the mystery genre and his first authorized sequel, 鈥淗ouse of Silk,鈥 won over both critics and fans. In that novel, Watson was writing up a tale that would have shocked Victorian society right out of its boots, with orders that it not be published until 100 years after his death. With 鈥淢oriarty,鈥 Horowitz tries something more challenging: a Holmes tale with no Holmes in sight.

Instead, Chase and Scotland Yard detective inspector Athelney Jones try to fill the void. The two meet over the body of the man who gives the novel its title.

鈥淚 was at Reichenbach five days after the confrontation that the world has come to know as 鈥楾he Final Problem.鈥 Well, there was nothing final about it, as we now know, and I guess that just leaves us with the problem,鈥 Chase writes.

Crime abhors a vacuum and, with Moriarty having been plucked from his web and most of his confederates rounded up by Scotland Yard, an American crime boss has taken over London. Clarence Devereux鈥檚 methods lack elegance 鈥 he rules by violence and terror rather than mathematical precision. He鈥檚 also never had his picture taken, meaning that Jones and Chase have to track him through his lieutenants.

Like 鈥淗ouse of Silk,鈥 鈥淢oriarty鈥 is far gorier than anything Conan Doyle penned, with Jones and Chase investigating a houseful of people killed in brutal fashion.

Jones, a minor character in 鈥淭he Sign of Four,鈥 did not fare well in his first encounter with the great detective. Since then, he鈥檚 become obsessed. He knows Holmes鈥檚 methods, and he appears to employ them with more success than faithful Watson. Chase, meanwhile, is happy to fill the role of scribe and sidekick. Other characters also make cameos, such as one from the story 鈥淭he Red-Headed League.鈥

Horowitz is an excellent plotter, and despite going in expecting narrative traps and literary double-crosses, he absolutely got me. 鈥淢oriarity鈥 doesn鈥檛 lack for deductive reasoning or a solid mystery.

But while the novel is clever, it鈥檚 a cold-blooded cleverness. And it鈥檚 unlikely to satisfy fans of the world鈥檚 only consulting detective. Without Holmes or Watson, the game not only isn鈥檛 afoot, it never fully gets off the ground.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to 'Moriarty' is a Sherlock Holmes tale with no Holmes in sight
Read this article in
/Books/Book-Reviews/2014/1218/Moriarty-is-a-Sherlock-Holmes-tale-with-no-Holmes-in-sight
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe