Crash course in democracy: 26 candidates, 2 weeks
Tunisia, one of the world鈥檚 youngest democracies, is electing a president in a lightning campaign that鈥檚 emphasizing policy over partisanship.
Tunisia, one of the world鈥檚 youngest democracies, is electing a president in a lightning campaign that鈥檚 emphasizing policy over partisanship.
A death, a dictator, and a deadline. The combination has kicked off the world鈥檚 most whirlwind presidential elections.
But even as Tunisians race to choose among more than two dozen candidates in two weeks of campaigning, there are nevertheless signs that one of the world鈥檚 youngest democracies is solidifying in an unstable region.
Among the dynamics in play in the shortened contest: close regulation of media coverage is limiting outside influences on the election and driving campaigns into an intensive grassroots mode; and the sheer number of candidates is prompting voters to focus less on personality and party, and more on policy.
Many here are suggesting that having overcome initial growing pains, this up-and-coming democracy may have a lesson or two to offer to established Western democracies under siege from populist strongmen, ideological divisions, and disinformation.
鈥淭he lesson we Tunisians can teach the world is how to go beyond divisions based on ideology, race, and religion and get to the heart of the matter 鈥 the solutions,鈥 says Seifeddine Makhlouf, a defense lawyer who at 44 is the race鈥檚 youngest candidate.
鈥淧eople here have gone through a crash-course on democracy and are wiser and more skeptical,鈥 he says. 鈥淲e want a battle of ideas, not a battle of ideologies or personalities.鈥
Constitutional crisis
When 92-year-old Tunisian President Beji Caid Essebsi died in office on July 25, Tunisians, who just eight years ago ousted dictator Zine El Abidine Ben Ali in a democratic revolution, found themselves in an uncomfortably familiar spot.
The country was suddenly ruled by an unelected caretaker executive with a constitutional mandate set to expire in 60 days.
With the still fresh memory of a dictator trampling constitutional norms, all Tunisian parties and institutions agreed to push through elections at a breakneck speed for the sake of their country.
On July 31, the country鈥檚 Independent High Electoral Commission announced the date for Tunisia鈥檚 presidential elections 鈥 September 15 鈥 and gave candidates seven days to register and gather 10,000 signatures.
Impressively, 92 candidates applied; in the end, 26 were approved.
Name your politics and there is a candidate for you: socialists, communists, Islamists, neoliberals, military men, media moguls, billionaires, even a Ben Ali apologist who wants to bring back the former dictator鈥檚 party.
There are so many candidates, each has been designated a number. The digits are prominently placed on posters and billboards across the country, often larger than the candidate鈥檚 face itself.
Media minima
But amid the mad dash to the presidency, something else unusual is happening in Tunisia.
Given the sheer number of candidates and the two-week campaigning period, media are barely having an impact. 听
With Tunisians fatigued by nonstop television spots, radio ads, and Facebook posts, such factors as grandstanding, personal attacks, quips, and name recognition are barely registering. There are simply too many voices at once.
Following the meddling of Gulf Arab- and Turkey-backed media outlets and social media campaigns that polarized Tunisians in previous polls, the electoral commission is also closely scrutinizing campaign coverage.听Outlets are not the only ones held accountable for infringements and fabrications听鈥 candidates too face suspension for violations.
Election authorities are even imposing a two-day 鈥渆lectoral silence鈥 鈥 a ban on campaigning and media coverage on the eve of polls and election day to prevent an 11th-hour bombshell from swaying voters.
鈥淭his time, the media can no longer give a candidate an advantage; the only way to win votes is through grassroots campaigning on the ground,鈥 says Rihab Trilla, youth campaign coordinator for Moncef Marzouki, Tunisia鈥檚 first post-revolution president, who is running again after losing to Mr. Essebsi in 2014.
鈥淧eople demand to see candidates in person and be convinced by what they have to say and their sincerity.鈥
Cafe culture
As in a U.S. primary, Tunisian candidates are crisscrossing the country to towns and villages many have never visited before, literally introducing themselves and fighting for each and every vote.
Yet while U.S. Democratic candidates glad-hand and eat novelty fried food at Midwest fairs and farmers markets, Tunisia鈥檚 candidates are descending on cafes.
With Tunisians鈥 affinity for sitting in cafes from dawn to midnight, they are the perfect place for a captive audience.
An outdoor cafe in downtown Ras Jebel, 40 miles north of Tunis, was the first stop on Thursday for Abdelkarim Zbidi, Tunisia鈥檚 defense minister, who despite being an ally of the recently deceased president is largely unknown to the public.
Mr. Zbidi, dressed in internationally recognized politician casual 鈥 jacketless, button-down shirt, open collar, no tie, and rolled-up sleeves 鈥 shook hands with curious cafe-goers one by one as 20 supporters donning white T-shirts emblazoned with his name chanted 鈥淟et鈥檚 unite over Zbidi.鈥
鈥淢ake this country safe again!鈥 shouted one supporter. Mr. Zbidi nodded and smiled. 鈥淭hat is my vow.鈥
Sharif Rafrafi, 69, clasped Mr. Zbidi鈥檚 hand and pulled him close for an animated chat, urging him to 鈥渕ake Tunisia strong!鈥
Smiling politely, the candidate eventually broke free and sat at a table for a shot of espresso.
Mr. Rafrafi came away impressed.
鈥淲e want someone who will strengthen the president鈥檚 powers and bring back law and order,鈥 says Mr. Rafrafi. He listed the woes plaguing his hometown: crime, smuggling, and drug abuse.
鈥淎fter seeing Zbidi in action, I believe this is the person for the job.鈥
A group of four undecided voters who had come to see Mr. Zbidi in the flesh sat in the corner unswayed, nursing their glasses of espresso.
The four men say they have a favorite who champions their causes: firebrand socialist Hamma Hammami, who runs on a platform of nationalizing resources and guaranteeing a living wage.
But due to a number of similar left-leaning candidates borrowing Mr. Hammami鈥檚 socialist talking points, they doubt he will make the 500,000-vote threshold needed for a potential second round.
In their words, 鈥渉e doesn鈥檛 have a chance.鈥
Instead, the four have a greater priority: selecting a candidate with the best chance of stopping front-runner Youssef Chahed. Or, as they call him, 鈥渢he disaster.鈥 The outgoing prime minister has overseen painful IMF austerity measures that many believe have caused unemployment, inflation, and currency devaluation.
鈥淯nfortunately, we are not casting a vote for the candidate we want, we are casting a vote for the candidate who is the most electable, and least objectionable,鈥 says Munaam Kawash,听a 38-year-old science teacher.
鈥淲e are learning that having a choice is not the same as having a chance.鈥
Rapid evolution
Four enthusiastic but charged elections over the past eight years have led to a rapid evolution of Tunisian voters鈥 behavior.
In the wake of Mr. Ben Ali鈥檚 ouster, Tunisians rushed in 2011 toward the group the dictator oppressed the most, voting in the Islamist party Ennahda. Three years later, political paralysis and mismanagement led Tunisians to again vote for the opposite: the centrist, secular Nidaa Tounes party and Mr. Essebsi, a Ben Ali-era minister.
Now, with the government鈥檚 economic program failing, observers and voters say Tunisians are looking beyond party and personalities and focusing on one thing: policies.
鈥淭he political mood in Tunisia has gone from a pure ideological divide to a more sophisticated policy divide based on criticisms of economic policy,鈥 says Youssef Cherif, a Tunis-based analyst.
There is plenty to debate: nationalizing Tunisia鈥檚 gas and phosphates, renegotiating foreign contracts inked in the Ben Ali era, Tunisia鈥檚 relations with Europe, climate change, job creation, and amending the country鈥檚 parliament-president hybrid system.
鈥淔or the first time people are making a vote based not on a reaction to the past or the present, but with an eye to our future,鈥 says Ms. Trilla, the campaign organizer.
Not everything has been smooth. Nabil Karoui, a populist media mogul some have likened to Donald Trump, was arrested at the start of the campaign for allegedly receiving illicit foreign funds听鈥 a case he claims was politically motivated. He remains behind bars, but is still on the ballot.
Yet if candidates say Tunisia has lessons for more established democracies, even this up-and-coming model has no answer for one of politics鈥 age-old challenges.
Ali Qassem, a 58-year-old former police sergeant, shook his head as Mr. Zbidi and his supporters marched past his vegetable stand in Ras Jebel. Two more candidates were scheduled to pass through the town that afternoon.
鈥淒emocracy in Tunisia has been 33% successful,鈥 says Mr. Qassem.
鈥淲e have won the freedom to vote for whom we want, but we still haven鈥檛 figured how to get them to show up after election season.鈥