海角大神

海角大神 / Text

Xi Jinping emerges as forceful No. 1 鈥 rewriting China's power playbook

Not since the days of Mao Zedong has any one individual in China been so visible a leader or held so much control. He's changing China by scrapping 'rule by consensus' and targeting civil society.

By Robert Marquand, Staff writer
Beijing

With a speed and toughness not imagined when he took China's top job as head of the Communist Party, President Xi Jinping has not only consolidated power but is overseeing such an extensive crackdown that some wonder if he鈥檚 accrued too much power.

Not since the days of Mao Zedong has any one individual in China become so visible a leader or held so much control over the rising nation of 1.3 billion people as听Mr.听Xi 鈥 whose father was a prominent comrade of Chairman Mao.听

Nor since Mao has a Chinese leader pushed so complete a program of old-style Communist Party values and blunt force. Not since Tiananmen Square in 1989 has a leader so thoroughly undercut even baby steps toward political openings. Under Xi鈥檚 grip in recent months, even civil society moderates have been harshly silenced 鈥 in what now appears to be a serious purification program of party and society.听

He is being called everything from a new 鈥渄ictator of the party鈥 to a modern day emperor. He is said to see himself as a man of destiny听who is overseeing the waking up of China.

Quietly, he has emerged on the world stage as a leader whose authoritarian direction rivals that of Russia鈥檚 Vladimir Putin. Certainly he鈥檚 dashed hopes of the birth of a more pluralistic civil society here any time soon.

In the past 18 months Xi has rolled up rivals in a vast, multilayered anti-corruption campaign that has often been tantamount to a soft purge. Upwards of 2,000 ranking party cadres have been replaced. Rising young cadres like Guangzhou party chief and mayor Wan Qingliang听can find themselves earning honors one day 鈥 and out the door the next.

Xi鈥檚 tactics are creating fear and uncertainty up and down party ranks, according to a range of sources听in China, Asia, and the United States interviewed about Xi during August and September.

Asians talk about 鈥渒illing the chicken to scare the monkey鈥 鈥 as a form of control. But Xi has also taken down monkeys. A powerful general, Xu Caihou, will soon be court-martialed. An even more powerful party figure, Zhou Yongkang 鈥 whose police and security force network often acted like a second government or mafia 鈥 was taken down in July.听

鈥淭he message is clear, 鈥業f he can get Zhou, who can鈥檛 he get?鈥欌 says David Kelly of the research group China Policy in Beijing. 听

'New concept for China'听

Xi鈥檚 鈥渘ew concept for China,鈥 as state run Xinhua news service put it in August, runs 鈥渇arther and wider than the outside world can imagine.鈥澨齒i refers to this as a great 鈥渞ejuvenation.鈥澨

Xi has听lavishly promoted a vision of a 鈥淐hina Dream鈥 of wealth, status, and national pride that appeals to the urban middle class where he is very popular. It strikes a nationalist chord in a country that has long felt looked down on. Yet Xi is also implementing strict prohibitions found in party circular Document 9 of August 2013, also known as the 鈥淪even No鈥檚.鈥

The manifesto calls on party faithful to stamp out free expression, foreign influences, or anything that faintly smells of democracy, transparency, or independent views.听

In his own backyard, Xi has out-hardlined the hardliners: He clamped down with extra vigor on upstart ethnic Uighers in the far west Xinjiang Province. His messages to Taiwan about unity with the motherland are tougher.听He deep-sixed Hong Kong鈥檚 hopes for free and fair elections in 2017 鈥 something that has come back to bite him on the streets of that former British colony, Asia's financial hub.听

For the first time, China, under Xi,听is taking aggressive stances in Pacific waters, confronting East Asian powers like Japan, Vietnam, the Philippines and the US. It claims vast swaths of ocean and sky.

Right after President Obama visited Asia听this spring听to reassure rattled allies, China moved an oil rig directly into disputed waters off Vietnam. On Sept. 22 after a visit to India he was quoted in Xinhua听telling People鈥檚 Liberation Army military units to make sure they stayed combat ready should they need to win 鈥渁 regional war.鈥澨

鈥淲e didn鈥檛 see this coming,鈥 a White House national security staffer told reporters after China denied a Pentagon account of a mid-air encounter between a PLA jet and a Navy spy plane off Hainan last month.

Orville Schell of the Asia Society US-China program now asks: 鈥淒oes China have any real friends?鈥 US analysts say that Xi and听Mr. Obama will have much to talk about in a November APEC meeting in Shanghai.

Collective leadership wanes听

If Xi鈥檚 rise is a turning point, the reason is because he and a coterie of patriotic elites in 2012 essentially scrapped China鈥檚 鈥渃ollective leadership鈥 model. For decades, ultimate power in China was shared diffusely. Decisions were made by consensus among nine standing committee leaders.

Shared power was designed by听Deng Xiaoping, the reformer who opened China, in part to avert another Mao-like 鈥渃ult of personality鈥 鈥 or another Cultural Revolution. So the collective model had a reassuring quality to it. No one would get too strong. There were brakes.听

Yet Xi is already proving far tougher than his predecessors, Jiang Zemin and Hu Jintao. Their tenures featured a 鈥渇riendly鈥 China that wanted to learn from the outside world and rise 鈥渉armoniously鈥 in Asia. Yet Jiang and Hu are now called caretakers or stewards. What China has been waiting for, so goes the new party line, is a strong man like Xi 鈥 able to rein in the clashing fiefdoms and corruption that threatens party authority and economic progress, two of the sacred听goods听of the People鈥檚 Republic.听

Xi comes from China鈥檚 鈥淩ed Second Generation鈥鈥 children of the nation鈥檚 founders. His father, Xi Zhongxun, was one of 鈥淓ight Immortals鈥 who helped pioneer Mao鈥檚 revolution. The 鈥淪econd Reds鈥 see the party and the nation as one. They feel a deep reproach for opportunists that grew rich and corrupt off the sacrifice made by their parents.听They want to curb those who live ostentatiously but care little for China, those 鈥渨ho take and don鈥檛 give,鈥 as a scholar here put it.

鈥淗e has a 鈥榬ed heart,鈥 as we say,鈥 says Li Datong, an intellectual and prominent former newspaper editor. 鈥淗is generation feels a very deep sense of responsibility. They feel, above all, that faced with a crisis, they must do something.鈥澨

While Xi鈥檚 father was jailed by Mao, as were many, the son is turning to Mao for inspiration. In a new book of essays released Sept. 25, Xi urges party members not to abandon the 鈥渟pirit of Mao鈥 or of Mao鈥檚 idea of constant revolution. Xi is the first Chinese leader since Mao to refer to himself in the first person, notes French Sinologist Francois Godement. Xi believes in a "strongman" theory of history, and is also the first since Mao to hold forth publicly on leadership, saying the 鈥渞ole of听No. 1 is key.鈥澨

China needed a strong hand

The dynamics behind Xi鈥檚 rise to No. 1听date to the early 2000s and the invitation for capitalists to join the party. That invitation is today seen as a very mixed blessing. It was an attempt to harness China鈥檚 economic dynamism into the politics of a 19th听century structure conceived by Vladimir Lenin.听

New fiefdoms, tycoons, and the so-called princeling sons and daughters of China's top families听all vied for connections听within the party.听It听became ground zero for the 鈥guanxi鈥 or relationships needed听for access to cash and credit.听Huge streams of money flowed from sectors like telecommunications, minerals, steel, and construction. By 2010 the cacophony 鈥 the offshore bank accounts, the shark fin soup banquets, the purchase of sex and drink, the elbowing and backstabbing 鈥 threatened, as one source put it, to make China 鈥渦ngovernable.鈥澨

Hu Jintao seemed unable to rein in the surge of money and ambition before his tenure was up in 2012.

Diagnoses of China鈥檚 crisis were many and varied. Some said the party was doomed. Others said the economy was doomed. Some said both. Some of the fundamentals were disturbing: Local governments had borrowed beyond their means to build听apartments, skyscrapers, shopping malls, and highway overpasses.听

The core question was how China was going to turn its export-based economy into an advanced technology-driven one.听Could the party reform itself to allow a more innovative approach 鈥 or was a more authoritarian centralizing of party decisions needed?

As fear in the party deepened, elites turned to the Red Generation for help. And they chose the hard-line route, virtually abolishing any remnant talk of a liberal opening.

Xi first emerged as an almost folksy man of the people who eats jaozi or dumplings, stays in modest hotels, and has a reassuring baritone voice.

Yet when the top six Politburo ministries were remade in 2012,听including national security, finance, military, and reform 鈥 Xi headed them all. He also had the opportunity to quickly dispatch his disgraced former arch-rival, Bo Xilai, in a highly public trial in 2013. 听

Unlike Hu and Jiang,听Xi is seen as not just talking but acting. He has interpreted Document No. 9 to go after moderate reformers, which is new. Xi has 鈥渙bsessively鈥 worried about how the Soviet Union fell under Mikhail Gorbachev and does not want the same corrosive free expression or 鈥glasnost鈥 to topple China, Harvard senior China scholar Roderick MacFarquhar argued in a recent talk on Xi.

Targeting civil society听

Increasingly, police are cracking down on artists, evangelicals, lawyers, bloggers, social media figures, and professors who appear to be influenced by civil society ideas or refute the party's concept of China鈥檚 unity and its paramount role.听

鈥淎bout 300 rights lawyers are now detained, never has there been so many,鈥 says Teng Biao, a human rights lawyer at Harvard for a year. 鈥淭hese lawyers are moderate. They aren鈥檛 taking on sensitive issues, or defending Liu Xiaobo [the jailed Nobel Peace Prize winner] but are dealing with things like anti-discrimination and consumer rights.鈥澨

Document No. 9's main target is 鈥渃onstitutionalism.鈥 That is, a push to make the Communist Party more accountable 鈥 under, not above the rule of law 鈥 and to allow freer expression. (Liu Xiaobo鈥檚 Charter 08, for example, calls for experiments with competing systems of power and 鈥渁n end to the practice of treating words as crimes.鈥)听

Under Xi, words not cherished in the Leninist vernacular 鈥 such as dialogue, negotiation, power-sharing, rule of law, NGO, rights, and听mutual understanding 鈥 are听increasingly viewed with suspicion.听

In recent months, every day brings reports that sound like a trip down Red China memory lane: Police and goon squads have been closing rural libraries since some books promote civil society and offer places to gather and discuss. TV shows from the US are taken off the air. The party announced it will issue its own version of 海角大神 theology. An independent film festival in Beijing that ran for 10 years was not allowed to open for its 11th. 听

In September, during Uigher uprisings in Xinjiang, Ilhem Tohti, a moderate Uigher scholar in Beijing who advocated dialogue and who opposed violence and听separatism, was sentenced to life in prison.听

鈥淎 rural library has nothing to do with politics,鈥 says Mr. Teng. 鈥淚t is completely separate. But Xi is going after all civil society. He is actually implementing Doc. 9." 听

First comes Putin, next comes Xi?

Unlike Mao, who only traveled once outside China 鈥 to visit Joseph Stalin in Moscow 鈥 Xi has some cosmopolitan credentials. He lived briefly in the US, served in coastal Zhejiang province and in Shanghai, and oversaw the 2008 Beijing Olympic preparations. He has a daughter at Harvard and is married to a famous singer. Yet Xi has clearly set himself against Western style government 鈥 as has Mr. Putin.听

Putin may be the prototype new authoritarian. He seized Crimea, pampered crony capitalists, and speaks of a Slavic union based on what he calls 鈥淓urasian values.鈥 Xi is thought to share many of Putin鈥檚 notions that the US and Europe are demoralized and in a downward spiral as civilizations 鈥 and a new authoritarian axis bridging Asia is the next thing.

Xi is not yet perceived as a Putin-style bully however. He鈥檚 鈥渢aken a number of pages from Putin鈥檚 book,鈥 says Mr. Kelly of China Policy. 鈥淓xcept Xi has resources and capabilities Putin can only dream of.鈥澨

The question is whether Xi has created such turmoil and so many enemies that he must become an ever-harsher authoritarian to maintain his grip. (Intellectuals in Beijing seriously debate whether Xi is a hardline authoritarian or a new kind of totalitarian, the latter having truly unknown implications.)

The Chinese press says Xi sees himself as a man of destiny. And this may be true. He cut his teeth in the violent and inward Cultural Revolution and now sees China moving out as an equal to Japan, the US, and Europe.

Deng Xiaoping counseled the nation as it recovered from Mao that China should 鈥渉ide its light and bide its time.鈥 Yet Xi may believe those days are over. He has ten years in office to prove it.听

鈥淴i believes he can be a great leader, articulate a great vision,鈥 says a knowledgeable Beijing professional with ties to the party. 鈥淗e thinks the people will be the grass and he will be the wind. He will blow and they will bend.鈥

鈥淭he problem is that the qualities in Xi that make him effective now are not good for a next phase toward an open and more innovative economy and society. When will that come?鈥澨