海角大神

海角大神 / Text

UK loophole: Why your Facebook photos may show up on a billboard

New UK law has artists and social media users uneasy. The act would allow companies to use some images without the photographer's permission.

By Ben Frederick

British Parliament passed an act that could allow businesses in the UK to use photos obtained from Facebook and Instagram without permission.

Many photographers, amateur and professional, are fearful the act will enable their work to be exploited without credit, permission, or payment.聽

The UK government says the act streamlines copyright licensing for works of unknown authorship.

This alteration to copyright law was tagged into a larger act aimed at cutting through regulatory red tape. Under the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 鈥 which last week received Royal Assent after passing parliament 鈥 鈥渙rphan works,鈥 or works with an unknown author, could be used commercially or non-commercially.

The act alters the standing copyright regulations around 鈥渙rphan works鈥 by allowing businesses to pay a fee to use them if they can鈥檛 find the author. (The agency that receives the fee has yet to be established.) Usually, you鈥檇 have to wait for the copyright to expire to use an orphan work.聽

Orphan works include books, music, photos, and films of unknown authorship, but critics of the legislation say photos are particularly ripe for the taking.聽

The policy change still has one final tiny hurdle 鈥 that of authoring the 鈥渟tatutory instruments鈥 or delegated legislation 鈥 that is, the exact workings of the law have yet to be formalized. Lawmakers have outlined a general plan, and that plan has been approved, and now all that鈥檚 left is filling in the blanks. A statutory instrument has not been voted down in 36 years, making it doubtful that any will this time.聽

The UK government says the purpose of the alteration is to make obtaining the copyright license of legitimate orphan works more efficient. 鈥淭he powers [established in the act] do not remove copyright for photographs or any other works subject to copyright, nor do they allow anyone to use a copyright work without permission and free of charge,鈥 a spokeswoman for the Department of Business, Innovations and Skills told the BBC.

The problem many see is, when a picture gets posted online, it gets shared around and posted on others鈥 walls, tweeted, and cross-tweeted, to the point where the original author can be near impossible to find. The average Internet user doesn鈥檛 include their author info in the metadata of all of their Instagram photos, and many images are orphaned soon after they are uploaded to the Web.

A media company can claim an image without ID after making a 鈥渄iligent search鈥 for the owner. If they can鈥檛 find one, they can then sublicense the work 鈥 in other words, they can obtain a picture that鈥檚 not theirs and charge others to use it, but only if they can鈥檛 find the author.聽

Many foresee a barrage of legal complaints revolving around the 鈥渄iligent search鈥 portion of the law, and whether or not a company actually searched 鈥渄iligently.鈥

Greg Lastowka, professor of law at Rutgers School of Law-Camden, doesn鈥檛 think diligence will be quite so loosely interpreted. 鈥淭here are very powerful image search engines out there right now,鈥 he told MSN news. 鈥淯sing an image search technology that looks all over the Web for a photo, or matching specific attributes of a photo, you can do a pretty good job of tracking the creator.鈥

Some of those opposed are upset that the alteration to copyright law has been inserted into an act that has nothing to do with copyright law as a whole.

"If this is copyright legislation, this deserves an act called the Copyright Act," said intellectual property expert Iain Connor to the BBC. "This [alteration] should not be tagged into a piece of legislation that has nothing to do with copyright."

Anyone that wants to use an orphan work will have to prove to an independent body that it performed a diligent search, says the BBC, and that body would then allow them to pay a licensing fee. That independent body will be outlined in the statutory instruments that haven鈥檛 been written yet.