Ukraine gas talks fail again. Why that's a big deal.
The coming of winter ratchets up tension surrounding Ukraine gas talks, which fell short of a deal again this week. Still, hopes remain high that a deal will be reached to pay off Ukraine's gas debts and reopen the flow of Russian supplies.
The coming of winter ratchets up tension surrounding Ukraine gas talks, which fell short of a deal again this week. Still, hopes remain high that a deal will be reached to pay off Ukraine's gas debts and reopen the flow of Russian supplies.
Negotiations over a natural gas deal between Ukraine and Russia have faltered since the spring, but the standoff has taken on a new urgency as winter approaches.
Following the overthrow of Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovich in February, Russia altered the terms by which it sells natural gas to Ukraine. Along with Yanukovich, favorable pricing went away. In April, Russia nearly聽doubled the sale price聽of natural gas to Ukraine, from $268.50 per thousand cubic meters to $485.50.
This was a price that the Ukrainian government said it could not meet. Even worse, Russian gas company Gazprom demanded upfront payment for gas supplies, an issue that kept the two countries at odds for months. Gazprom聽cut off gas supplies to Ukraine in June, saying Ukraine had failed to pay its debt. (Related: Putin Threatens Gas Reduction To Europe)
A long-term solution has eluded Moscow and Kiev since, and talks have dragged on for months. It鈥檚 not just Ukraine鈥檚 problem, though: around聽40 percent聽of Europe鈥檚 gas imports from Russia travel across Ukrainian territory. So to a large extent, the standoff over pricing is a three-way dispute between Russia, Ukraine and the European Union. The supply cut-off in June underscored the threat to the rest of Europe.
It will be difficult to postpone a resolution any further. Russian Energy Minister Alexander Novak has聽demanded full payment in advance聽for gas deliveries in November and December. In addition, he says Gazprom must receive further debt payments from the Ukrainian government as a pre-condition to a deal.
Expectations were high that an agreement was imminent after some of the major stumbling blocks had been ironed out. Ukraine and Russia agreed on an聽interim price聽of $385 per thousand cubic meters through March 2015. Although the price is substantially lower than the price Russia originally demanded, it is still a victory for Moscow as it is above the聽average that other Gazprom customers pay聽-- around $350 per thousand cubic meters.
Nevertheless, no deal was cemented during talks in聽Brussels on Oct. 21聽because Ukraine is still short on funds. 鈥淭here is a cash gap for November and December and this cash gap requires financial resources,鈥澛燦ovak said, suggesting that the European Union should provide Ukraine with the money.
Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko has asked Brussels for 2 billion euros, but the EU Commission has thus far balked at the price tag.
But European officials are desperate to bridge the gap to avoid a confrontation over natural gas supplies, with colder weather beginning to set in. Gazprom has gone to great lengths to reassure its EU customers that gas supplies will not be affected by its decision to cut off Ukraine. But Russian President Vladimir Putin has聽threatened to reduce gas flows聽if Ukraine diverts supplies for its own use. (Related: Caspian Sea Could Be Key To Russian Control Of Eurasian Energy Markets)
Even still, a聽Citigroup report聽published in September found that the EU has stockpiled enough gas supplies to withstand a supply cut off from Russia, as long as the winter season was not abnormally cold.
Storage sites around Europe are聽nearly 100 percent full聽due to a proactive campaign to stash away supplies ahead of winter. And EU leaders have agreed to reverse gas flows from west to east to safeguard the more vulnerable countries in the former Soviet bloc from a supply disruption.
Despite the setback in the negotiations, all sides have agreed to meet again at the end of October. With funding the only outstanding issue remaining, the EU or the International Monetary Fund could seal the deal by issuing a loan to Ukraine. For that reason, hopes remain high that a deal will be completed soon.
By Nick Cunningham of Oilprice.com
More Top Reads From Oilprice.com:
No Shale Revolution For Europe
Should Europe Be Concerned About Russia鈥檚 Growing Energy Relationship with Asia
Russian Shale Boom Unlikely As Sanctions Force Another Company Out
厂辞耻谤肠别:听丑迟迟辫://辞颈濒辫谤颈肠别.肠辞尘/贰苍别谤驳测/骋补蝉-笔谤颈肠别蝉/鲍办谤补颈苍别-搁耻蝉蝉颈补-骋补蝉-顿别补濒-厂迟颈濒濒-笔辞蝉蝉颈产濒别-顿别蝉辫颈迟别-厂别迟产补肠办.丑迟尘濒