海角大神

海角大神 / Text

Ice shelf collapse: 鈥楿nknown鈥 Antarctica still holds surprises

Antarctica holds mysteries with big implications for Earth鈥檚 environment. A recent ice breakup is just one sign of larger climate changes underway.

By Stephanie Hanes, Staff writer

In early March, analysts at the U.S. National Ice Center began to notice changes along the eastern coast of Antarctica.聽

First, a large piece of ice, some 13 nautical miles in length, broke off the remnants of an area known as the Glenzer ice shelf. Ice shelves are sections of glacial ice that extend off land and rest on the ocean, and occasionally 鈥渃alve,鈥 or break apart, to produce icebergs.

Although it鈥檚 less common for such an event to take place on the eastern side of Antarctica 鈥 the western side is far more dynamic and tends to be the focus of scientists who study glaciers 鈥 it is by no means unprecedented, says Christopher Readinger,聽the Ice Center鈥檚 lead Antarctic ice analyst.

He quickly put out a memo, informing sailors and scientists that a newly named iceberg, C-37, was now floating in what is already considered one of Earth鈥檚 most harrowing maritime environments.聽聽

But then, a week later, something else happened.聽

The ice shelf adjacent to Glenzer, a New York City-size mass called the Conger ice shelf, collapsed completely 鈥 the first time this had happened in East Antarctica since scientists began using satellites to record such events.

The collapse came around the same time as聽a stunning heat wave in the region, which had included temperatures reaching nearly 70 degrees Fahrenheit above normal. (This pushed the temperature to a relatively balmy 11 degrees F, compared with the typical 56 below zero.) Some scientists have described it as Earth鈥檚 most extreme heat wave ever recorded.

Mr. Readinger sent out another report and named a new iceberg, C-38, made from the ice that had been the Conger ice shelf. And scientists around the world began to scramble to understand what, exactly, was going on in Antarctica 鈥 a part of the world known to be a crucial regulator of global climate, but one still filled with mystery.

鈥淚t鈥檚 a gut check for the glaciology community鈥 says Peter Neff, a glaciologist with the University of Minnesota. 鈥淲e have record low sea ice [around East Antarctica]. We have a much stronger heat wave than we ever thought was possible. And an ice shelf collapsing in a place where we didn鈥檛 expect it to collapse. ... It causes concern for us that we鈥檙e not fully appreciating the vulnerability of East Antarctica.鈥

That vulnerability matters 鈥 not only for the ecosystems of this remote, southern continent, but for climate and sea levels worldwide. It is a reminder of how much scientists still don鈥檛 know about Antarctica, its ecosystems, and the Southern Ocean that surrounds it. And it shows the importance of the scientific and geopolitical collaboration that takes place on this continent, even as researchers struggle to understand it.聽

鈥淚t鈥檚 still an unknown place,鈥 says Catherine Walker, an assistant scientist at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. 鈥淔or the most part, it鈥檚 unexplored. You do your best [to understand it] with the measurements you can get. But events like this last week 鈥 we were all surprised.鈥

A continent鈥檚 complexities

On the one hand, the reason for the Conger ice shelf collapse and the preceding heat wave seems clear. A warming climate has created changes in Earth鈥檚 systems, such as rising ocean temperatures and shifts in the way atmospheric currents carry heat and moisture, that in turn lead to events like city-size ice blocks dropping off a continent.

But it鈥檚 also far more complicated than that.

Scientists are generally loath to say that any one event, such as an ice shelf collapse, is the clear result of climate change. These are natural systems, after all, and direct correlation is not always clear. Dr. Neff, for instance, collects ice cores to try to understand historical climate markers 鈥 and to see, for instance, whether East Antarctica has experienced this sort of heat wave before.聽

(To show just how complicated this is, the weather event scientists say led to the recent Antarctic heat 鈥 a band of warm, moisture-filled air called an 鈥渁tmospheric river鈥 鈥 also brings with it a huge amount of snow. And that snow builds glaciers. Which means it鈥檚 not even clear whether a heat wave results in net melting. As Dr. Neff says, 鈥淎dd tens of gigatons of snow over a couple of days to your glacier, and it can put a wrinkle in your model.鈥)

Meanwhile, when it comes to polar regions, Antarctica seems 鈥 at first glance, at least 鈥 to have been less affected by global warming than the north so far.聽

鈥淚f you look at a map of warming over the last 50 years, Antarctica still looks pretty blue, or cold, and the North Pole is red, or warming,鈥 says Dr. Walker. 鈥淲e hear more about Greenland聽and shrinking sea ice in the north.鈥

Indeed, scientists believe that Antarctica serves as a global air conditioner. While ocean waters around the world absorb a quarter of all the carbon humans put into the atmosphere, the Southern Ocean does the most work, absorbing about half of those molecules. And the same churning that makes it so treacherous to sail 鈥 or do research 鈥 on the Southern Ocean also pushes that heat and carbon into deeper water.

In other words, without the Southern Ocean, the world would be a whole lot hotter, many scientists say. (Again, it鈥檚 not quite so simple 鈥 the churning also brings up natural carbon from organisms decaying at the ocean floor. But the dominant theory about the Southern Ocean is that it is a carbon sink.)聽

But researchers also know Antarctica is changing.聽聽

鈥淲e have indications of really important changes,鈥 says Matt Long, an oceanographer with the National Center for Atmospheric Research. 鈥淭here are direct observations of warming. Of freshening. Of increased freshwater input. We don鈥檛 fully understand the implication of those changes for Antarctic marine ecosystems. That鈥檚 something crucial for the scientific community to engage in and for the international community to address.鈥

One impact of all the heat absorbed by the Southern Ocean seems to be that ice is thinning from below. Antarctica holds 90% of the world鈥檚 ice, and 70% of Earth鈥檚 freshwater volume, according to the National Science Foundation. This means that even partial melting could have a catastrophic impact on coastal communities around the world.聽聽

An international collaboration of scientists studying the Florida-size Thwaites Glacier on the western side of Antarctica, for instance, has warned of new cracks and melting in that ice.聽聽

Should that glacier fully collapse, it could raise global sea levels by feet 鈥 but again, by how much, and how fast, is up for debate.聽

The recent Conger collapse probably won鈥檛 have a big impact on sea levels, scientists say. Still, says Dr. Walker, they are monitoring it.聽聽

鈥淭he thing we鈥檙e all sort of interested in is the process,鈥 she says. 鈥淲hat happens, what鈥檚 next. That can help us learn what to expect from the bigger ones.鈥澛

All nations have a stake

If this isolated continent is the site of mysterious 鈥 and perhaps unnerving 鈥 changes, it might also be the location of big global answers, both scientific and geopolitical.

Not owned by any one country, Antarctica is governed internationally. The first Antarctic treaty, signed in 1959, demilitarized the continent and explicitly made it a region where countries would collaborate on scientific research. Since then, other agreements have banned mining, oil and gas exploration, and required any fishing industry activity meet conservation goals.聽聽

鈥淚nternationally, people often look at this treaty system as being very enlightened,鈥 says Claire 海角大神, executive director of the Antarctic and Southern Ocean Coalition. But there is still a need to monitor activity around the continent to ensure the goals of 鈥減eace and science鈥 are being maintained.

Different constituents, she and others say, have conflicting opinions about the best way to do this. For some, economic benefits, such as krill fishing, outweigh conservation efforts, such as setting aside waters as protected areas. To others, scientific exploration is worth disrupting ecosystems.聽

How Antarctica handles these conflicting goals, in the face of global change, can be illustrative.

鈥淚t鈥檚 a bit of a microcosm for the issue overall,鈥 says Dr. Long. 鈥淵ou have this global commons issue that characterizes the climate change problem. And then you have Antarctica, where various countries have different perspectives.鈥

And overall, Ms. 海角大神 says, the world needs to care about what happens here 鈥 and adjust its climate policies accordingly.聽

鈥淎ntarctica belongs to everyone,鈥 she says. 鈥淎nd everybody in the world has a stake in keeping Antarctica frozen.鈥