海角大神

海角大神 / Text

India election: a pivot to Hindu nationalism?

The India election that begins this week could catapult a Hindu nationalist, Narendra Modi, to power. How he defines the national interest will determine India's place in the world as a peaceful player.

By the Monitor's Editorial Board

Voters in India head to the polls in April and May for a five-week election expected to catapult a Hindu nationalist, Narendra Modi, to power. A former tea seller who leads the right-wing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Mr. Modi has long tied India鈥檚 identity and its interests to the dominant religion, Hinduism 鈥 an approach to governance that worries the country鈥檚 large Muslim minority as well as many others.

In 2005, for example, the US denied a visa to Mr. Modi based on reports that he looked the other way as chief minister of the state of Gujarat during deadly riots against Muslims in 2002. In recent months, the US has restored relations with him as it appeared he might become India鈥檚 next prime minister.

To his credit, Modi is also well known for building up his state鈥檚 economy and keeping a relatively clean record. Gujarat now produces nearly a quarter of India鈥檚 exports but has only 5 percent of its population. Many Indian voters, fed up with inflation, low job growth, and corruption, appear ready to back the BJP while handing a defeat to the ruling Congress party and its fading Nehru-Gandhi family dynasty.

Modi suggests he has set aside his long association with Hindu chauvinism in favor of practical management of the Indian economy. 鈥淚 am known to be a Hindu-nationalist leader,鈥 he says. But 鈥渕y real thought is 鈥榯oilets first, temples later鈥.鈥

In his few foreign-policy statements, however, he hints that he may turn India into a more muscular regional power. He has chided China for its 鈥渕ind-set of expansionism,鈥 for example, and often criticizes Pakistan. His right-wing nationalism showed up when he claimed a well-known political opponent is a 鈥淧akistani agent鈥 simply for a type of map used in a campaign ad.

India has fought three wars with Pakistan and has had a border skirmish with China. All three countries are now nuclear powers. So it is important to consider whether Modi will assert a national interest, based on beliefs about Hindu dominance that might worsen ties with those countries.

In this respect, he could be similar to Russia鈥檚 Vladimir Putin, who has lately linked the national interest to the state鈥檚 role in 鈥減reserving the dominance of Russian culture.鈥 And Modi may also be like China鈥檚 Xi Jinping, who recently gave the ruling Communist Party the task of building a 鈥渃ohesive鈥 national spirit based on defense of traditional social mores, epitomized in teachings attributed to Confucius and China鈥檚 past glory. Mr. Xi also highlights China鈥檚 ancient history as a seafaring power.

What鈥檚 worrisome about such definitions of national interests is that both Russia and China have relied on them in part to justify aggression against neighboring states.

Russia forcibly annexed Crimea last month to 鈥減rotect鈥 the Russian-speaking people in the peninsula against alleged Western encroachment in Ukraine.

China, meanwhile, has relied on ancient maps and historic trade routes to lay claim to islands long controlled by other Asian nations and that are far from Chinese shores.

How a nation defines its national interests these days has become more complex.

During the era of empires, it was defined largely by a sovereign ruler. During the cold war, each side asserted a better economic model (communism vs. capitalism). Since then, globalization, the growth of democracy, and the expansion of alliances such as the European Union have helped ito mute nationalism based on ideology, bloodlines, religion, or even territory. Nations that define interests along more universal values, such as individual freedom and rule of law, are rising in number.

Perhaps knowing this, Modi often repeats this line on the campaign trail: 鈥淚ndia鈥檚 government has only one religion: nation first, India first. And only one holy book: the Constitution.鈥

As the world鈥檚 largest democracy 鈥 a feat in itself given the country鈥檚 level of poverty 鈥 India may have helped shaved the edges off Modi鈥檚 Hindu-based nationalism. If he becomes its next leader, he will need to show a more expansive view of national interest than in the past. More countries are counting on India to be a peaceful global power.