A mayor in Mozambique had a flooding master plan. Then came the cyclone.
Flooded buildings are seen in Beira, Mozambique, in the aftermath of Cyclone Idai, March 23, 2019. The city is building up its flood defenses to prepare for future storms.
Mike Hutchings/Reuters/File
BEIRA, MOZAMBIQUE; and JOHANNESBURG
When a huge cyclone whipped toward central Mozambique in March 2019, Daviz Simango was worried, but he wasn鈥檛 surprised.
As mayor of the coastal city of Beira, Mr. Simango had seen extreme weather events become more and more frequent, causing floods that overwhelmed his city鈥檚 aging trash-choked canals. He knew climate change was to blame and that his city needed to bolster its flood defenses.听
For as long as he鈥檇 been mayor, Mr. Simango, a trained civil engineer, had been working toward this goal. He had drawn up a master plan for making the city and its people flood-resistant by 2035. He鈥檇 tapped money and expertise from international donors to rehabilitate seven miles of colonial-era drainage canals. The city had also built a new wastewater treatment plant, started work on a major park, and scooped out massive water retention basins around the city to hold floodwaters.
Why We Wrote This
Preparing cities for climatic risks is a priority for developing countries like Mozambique. A 2019 cyclone was a lesson in the promise and limits of adaptation.
That day in March 2019, as Cyclone Idai鈥檚 105 mph winds shrieked over Beira, Mr. Simango wondered if it would be enough.
In many ways, Beira鈥檚 attempts to bulk up its flood defenses posed an urgent question: How far could a poor city in one of the world鈥檚 poorest countries protect itself against climate change? And what lessons might it offer to other parts of the world that face similar threats?听
鈥淲e want to avoid听being in a vicious cycle of having to rebuild over and over, and then having it destroyed鈥澨齜y听extreme weather听events, says Bontje Marie Zangerling, a senior urban specialist at the World Bank who has worked on the bank鈥檚 projects in Beira.听
When Albano Ant贸nio Carige awoke the next morning, much of Beira, a city of half a million people, was underwater.
Beira looked like it had been stripped for parts, says Mr. Carige, a city councilor. He was barely out of bed that morning when Mr. Simango was at his door, asking for keys to a city council car so he could drive around town and assess the damage.
In the days that followed, Mr. Simango was often spotted in the streets, his shirt sleeves rolled up and collared blue shirt half unbuttoned and wet with sweat.
鈥淗e was working a chainsaw, chopping the fallen trees in the middle of the street,鈥 recalls Maria Carlos Pedro, a Beira resident. 鈥淗is relation with everyone was the same. There was no difference. With him it was like that.鈥
A city of husks
But Beira鈥檚 rebuilding would mean more than just clearing rubble. Flooding had overwhelmed the city鈥檚 new canals, sending surges of water through its neighborhoods, while high winds had battered its buildings. Aerial photos showed tin roofs and tree branches poking out of a soup of murky brown water. The Red Cross estimated that 90% of the city was damaged.
As the floodwaters receded, Beira became overnight a city of husks 鈥 skeletal building frames and piles of rubble.
鈥淲e have been building this city more than 100 years, and in a few hours, everything went out,鈥 Mr. Simango
For Beira鈥檚 mayor, who had spent years preparing for a knockout storm, Cyclone Idai was a brutal setback. Across Mozambique, at least 598 people died and more than 130,000 had to flee their homes; Zimbabwe and Malawi also suffered major destruction.
But the preparation hadn鈥檛 been in vain. Take the city鈥檚 new drainage canals that overflowed when the rains fell: Neighborhoods abutting the canals suffered less flooding overall and the floodwaters receded more quickly, allowing residents to mop up and move back.
For Selemane Alberto, who lives in Munhava,听an area where storm drains had been improved before the storm, the difference was striking.
鈥淚n my neighborhood you would not walk a few steps without stepping on water, but [after Idai] it was different,鈥 he says. 鈥淎s much as it rains, you walk without having to take off your shoes.鈥
But the storm also clarified how much more needed to be done. While the extent of flooding was less than in previous storms, the cyclonic winds crumpled entire neighborhoods, peeling off roofs and sending trees and power lines crashing through buildings. 鈥淚f there was no wind,鈥 , 鈥渕aybe we could survive.鈥
Idai one of the worst weather events ever recorded in the Southern Hemisphere.
鈥淪uddenly you have a natural event that reveals all the problems 鈥 it鈥檚 the moment of the revelation,鈥 says Lizardo Narvaez, a senior disaster risk management specialist at the World Bank, who works on the bank鈥檚 projects in Beira. 鈥淚t鈥檚 not that the things weren鈥檛 like that before. They were. But now you have this momentum and everyone sees what needs to be addressed.鈥
Mr. Simango already knew well why action was needed. 鈥淐limate change is here,鈥 in 2018, a year before Cyclone Idai. 鈥淭hings are changing in the city.鈥
Build back better
In the weeks and months after the storm, money and expertise poured into Beira. At a conference held in Mozambique鈥檚 capital, Maputo, in June 2019, international donors pledged $1.2 billion for post-cyclone recovery.
鈥淭here is a need to build back better, to look at infrastructure, resilience of communities in a different way,鈥 Noura Hamladji, the U.N. Development Program鈥檚 deputy regional director for Africa, told the conference.
For Mayor Simango, that meant investing in better housing in Beira, so buildings wouldn鈥檛 collapse in cyclone winds. It meant expanding the canal system to informal shack settlements where drainage remained spotty. It meant fortifying the city鈥檚 sea walls and finishing a major urban park, which would serve both as a natural flood defense for the city and a public space for its young people.
Two and a half years after the storm, most of those projects have yet to break ground, which experts say is typical for large reconstruction efforts. The World Bank says it expects to begin work on coastal wall reconstruction and new drainage canals in 2023.
But one project that has been completed is the new park on the banks of the Chiveve River. 鈥淭his was the brainchild of the mayor,鈥 says Ms. Zangerling of the World Bank. 鈥淗e used to tell us stories of how for decades the area along the river was dilapidated, always flooded and crime ridden. Transforming it was a really important dream of his.鈥
The 108-acre park includes groves of replanted mangroves 鈥 a natural defense against flooding 鈥 as well as exhibition buildings, restaurants, a market, an open-air amphitheater, a botanical garden, and outdoor gyms. For Mr. Simango, it was a clean, spacious public area where city residents could spend time.
But the mayor never saw the project completed. In February this year, he suddenly fell ill. He was airlifted to a hospital in South Africa, where he died on Feb. 22, reportedly of complications from COVID-19. He was 57.
Only a week before he died, 鈥渨e were talking about how we could finish potholes鈥 and tar the rest of the city鈥檚 roads, says Mr. Carige, who replaced him as Beira鈥檚 mayor.
But despite Mr. Simango鈥檚 death, Mr. Carige says his predecessor鈥檚 legacy will live on in the projects he started to protect his city against climate change.
鈥淸He] is why, if you see, Beira city had an extraordinary revolution,鈥 he says.