海角大神

Who is Glenn Beck? Rally adds to his mystique.

A day after the Glenn Beck rally in Washington, the media was stumped by who the real Glenn Beck was and how he had motivated thousands of Americans Saturday.

This Sunday, apparently, no one knew who Glenn Beck was.

The "Chris Matthews Show" on NBC had a roundtable panel discussion about the man who claimed to be 鈥渞estoring honor鈥� in America, with panelists delving into Mr. Beck鈥檚 character as though he were lying on a couch in front of them.

贵辞虫鈥檚 Chris Wallace, who works in the same office as Beck, marveled that he still doesn鈥檛 鈥渒now" who Beck is.

And ABC鈥檚 Rick Klein called his power to attract audiences 鈥渢he most potent political force in American life today鈥� 鈥� even though Beck suggested his rally was not about politics.

Why all the confusion?

Granted, Beck casting the event in a religious light caused for some scratching of heads. But whatever the motivation for the rally, the result was hardly unfamiliar to Beck-watchers.

Beck, after all, is no cipher. He is on television no fewer than five times a week, and during those five hours of head shaking and finger-wagging, he is not exactly shy about sharing his opinion.

And the Beck who brought thousands of Americans 鈥� 65,000 or 650,000? 鈥� to the National Mall Saturday is no more or less than what he is at 5 p.m. nightly on Fox News: The voice of the conservative, middle class, and red-tinted core of the country, which sees in America鈥檚 future only increasing cause for alienation 鈥� illegal immigration, more entitlement programs, and a perceived decay of America鈥檚 sense of rugged individualism.

The Sunday post-mortems, then, had some savor either of triumph or panic at Beck's success. It was like that scene from 鈥淟ittle Shop of Horrors鈥� when the hapless Seymour wakes up to find his innocuous little plant has grown monstrous and taken over the entire greenhouse. Saturday was Beck鈥檚 greenhouse, and the entire country was made to watch.

'Gripping television'

With Fox's Mr. Wallace, Beck was given the platform to further add to his mystique as a conservative talisman. For critics, though, it was a spectacle as upsetting as it was surprising.

罢颈尘别鈥檚 Joe Klein decreed that Beck was a 鈥減aranoid lunatic who is a great entertainer, and he is exploiting something that always happens in our country when the economy is bad and when we are at war.鈥� Cue clips of World War II internment camps for Japanese-Americans and tales of German-speaking Americans being beaten up by fellow Americans.

It was, however, 鈥済ripping television,鈥� said the BBC鈥檚 Katty Kay on the "Chris Matthews" roundtable, expressing no doubts as to the rally's political purpose.

Beck is 鈥渁ppealing to a broader section of the American public that feels that it needs to put a check on the administration," she said. "If we see a big Republican turnout in November, it's going to be partly not because people are loving Republicans but because they will do anything to check the power that is there.鈥�

Ms. Kay had company in questioning Beck's motives. 鈥淏eck's claim that his rally is not political is laughable,鈥� says Matthew Hale, a political scientist at Seton Hall University, in an e-mail.

Political echoes

But is there something inherently wrong with that? Longtime journalist Donald Mazzella, who covered the Rev. Martin Luther King鈥檚 speech on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial 47 years ago, says in an e-mail: 鈥淩allies of this sort always have a political element attached."

"The original march was as much political as social and clearly galvanized a whole generation of activists and political activity,鈥� he adds.

Beck鈥檚 role today is to galvanize the other side of the political spectrum, Mr. Mazzella says, adding, "There seems to be a questioning of the Tea Party attendance, when the real question is: Why are so many apparently middle class people so concerned?鈥�

So, does the media think like Sen. Barbara Boxer (D) of California, who said: 鈥淭hey can鈥檛 be protesters, they鈥檙e too well dressed鈥�? Does a protest have to be liberal to be legitimate in their eyes?

Writer and book critic Antoinette Kuritz, who says she has in the past voted both sides of political tickets, thinks so.

People are trying to figure out Beck 鈥渂ecause of the way his influence has grown. Arguably, he will impact more voters than MTV or Bono or Alec Baldwin or even Oprah. And he is not espousing liberal causes."

"Glenn Beck has made a point: The people are rejecting the paternalism of this administration, of [House Speaker Nancy] Pelosi in particular," she says by e-mail. "They are tired of being told what is good for them, of having legislation thrust upon them with which they disagree. The people want a louder voice. They want to be heard. And, if necessary, they will band together until they are.鈥�

Religion and politics

The packaging of the event in religious overtones, however, caused discomfort in some quarters.

鈥淲hat is interesting to me is that Beck seems to see a benefit in cloaking his politics in religion, as if that somehow makes him safer and less threatening," says Mr. Hale, the political scientist. "It is as if he is arguing that religion is above the fray of messy and ugly politics.鈥�

鈥淭he danger of Mr. Beck's claim that he is focused on religion is that he is attempting to define being a 'good 海角大神' with a host of other values that have nothing to do with a person's faith," he adds. "There are religiously observant people in all faiths who would actually call themselves politically liberal, yet Mr. Beck seeks to deny that as a possibility.鈥�