海角大神

Morsi trial opens new battleground for Egypt's military and Islamists

Muslim Brotherhood supporters say former President Morsi and other leaders are victims of a political vendetta, pointing to police who killed protesters and still walk free.

|
Manu Brabo/AP
A supporter of Egypt's ousted President Mohamed Morsi chants slogans against the Egyptian Army outside of a police academy compound were the trial of Morsi is held in Cairo, Monday, Nov. 4, 2013.

Former President Mohamed Morsi was defiant as he appeared in court today, four months after he was ousted by Egypt's military.

Looking confident, the former president wore a suit instead of the white prison clothes worn by his co-defendants. Addressing the judge, he proclaimed himself the legitimate president of Egypt,聽rejected聽the authority of the court, and said those who ousted him should be聽tried聽instead. He and the Brotherhood leaders on trial with him raised the four-finger salute that has come to symbolize the opposition to the military-backed government.

It was his first聽public聽appearance since the military took him into custody on聽July 3, one year after he took office as Egypt's first freely elected president. Since then, he has been held largely incommunicado in an undisclosed location. State media reported he was taken to Borg Al Arab prison near Alexandria after the hearing, which was adjourned until聽Jan. 8.聽

The trial took place in the same venue as former President Hosni Mubarak's trial after the uprising that toppled him,聽highlighting the arc of Egypt's nearly three years of political turmoil that has also brought the military, which was a powerful institution under Mr. Mubarak, back into power.

Security was tight near the trial venue and throughout Cairo today, with Tahrir Square on lockdown and some schools closed. A small group of protesters gathered at the police academy on the outskirts of Cairo where the trial was held, while thousands gathered at the Supreme Constitutional Court to protest. But the government, in bringing them to trial, is riding a wave of popular anger at Morsi and the Brotherhood,聽the Islamist organization to which he belongs.

The trial comes amid a full-scale crackdown on the Brotherhood,聽in contrast to a near total lack of prosecutions of police for killing protesters.聽Together the聽developments give weight to聽accusations of a political vendetta聽and聽doubts about the聽credibility of the proceedings.聽

Khalil Al Anani, a senior fellow at the Middle East Institute in Washington, said both the Brotherhood and the military-backed government were using the trial to wage an 鈥渋mage battle.鈥 The Brotherhood strove to portray the military-backed government as illegitimate, while the military attempted to prove its control and show it can bring Morsi to justice.聽

鈥淚f聽we look at the political implications of this trial, it will deepen the crisis and increase the polarization in society,鈥 Mr. Anani says.聽

Morsi is standing trial with 14 others, including聽former聽presidential aides and top Brotherhood leaders.

They are charged with inciting violence in December 2012, when 11 people died in clashes between聽Morsi's聽supporters and opponents.

Protesters聽challenging聽the president had gathered near the palace, and the Muslim Brotherhood sent its supporters to remove them when the police refused.

In the ensuing clashes, Brotherhood supporters captured and detained protesters, beating them in an attempt to force confessions that they had been paid to protest. Morsi later appeared to reference the forced confessions in a speech. Many of the 11 people who died were Brotherhood supporters.聽

Morsi alienated many during his year in power by failing to right a sinking economy and by聽taking actions that were聽perceived as protecting the interests of Islamists, not all citizens. Millions of Egyptians聽turned out in the streets on聽June 30, asking him to step down and call early elections. On聽July 3, the military arrested him, named an interim president, and suspended the constitution, announcing plans to hold new elections.

In the wake of the coup, the new military-backed government launched a bloody crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood. Thousands of members have been arrested, including many top and mid-level leaders. On聽Aug. 14, security forces cleared Islamist sit-ins protesting the coup, killing hundreds. Dozens of police were also killed. The crackdown on the Brotherhood has wide support among Egyptians,聽partially because聽the government, along with state and private media,聽has聽branded聽group members as聽terrorists.

But at the Supreme Constitutional Court, where thousands gathered聽to reject the proceedings, protesters decried what they called a miscarriage of justice.

鈥淭he trial will not be fair at all,鈥 said protester Asmaa Mustafa, a teacher. 鈥淢ubarak corrupted the judges, the media, the police, the Army. So I think the judges are not fair 鈥 they are the same ones who acquitted Mubarak.鈥

Morsi provoked strong opposition in the judiciary when he attempted to reform the institution, saying he was trying to root out corruption. His opponents saw instead an attempt to curb their independence and push into retirement judges who were unfriendly to Islamists. Judges were also angered by Morsi's temporary decree to make his actions immune from judicial review.聽

Others said the trial was a way to justify the coup and the crackdown on the Brotherhood, and noted that police were not on trial for killing protesters.

鈥淲here are the dogs who killed the protesters? Why aren't they on trial?鈥 asked protester Mustafa Mohamed Gharib, a student at Al Azhar University. 鈥淚f Morsi is on trial, shouldn't his interior minister be on trial, too?鈥 he asked, referring to the government official in charge of police. 鈥淲e're here for our rights and for democracy. We won't sit and let tyrants run over us for another 60 years.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Morsi trial opens new battleground for Egypt's military and Islamists
Read this article in
/World/Security-Watch/2013/1104/Morsi-trial-opens-new-battleground-for-Egypt-s-military-and-Islamists
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe