海角大神

Clinton in India: a gentle reminder about all that Iranian oil

The US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton wants India to stop buying oil from Iran, given concerns over Iran's nuclear program. But can Delhi stop?

|
Harish Tyagi/AP
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton meets Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in New Delhi, India, Monday, May 7. Clinton urged energy-starved India on Monday to reduce its Iranian oil imports to keep up pressure on the Islamic republic to come clean about its nuclear program.

American Secretary of State this week is a gentle reminder that the US would like its closest ally in Asia to be a little less friendly with Iran.

India currently imports almost 80 percent of its oil, and some 11 percent of the total comes from Iran, in order to help fuel its solidly booming economy. That growth itself is welcomed by Washington, but a recently passed US law would impose sanctions on countries, like India, who purchase their oil from Iran, starting June 28. The US fears that Iran may be moving toward developing nuclear weapons, a charge that Iran denies.

"We believe, at this moment in time, the principal threat is a nuclear-armed Iran," with reporters in the eastern city of Kolkata. "We need India to be part of the international effort.... We hope they will do even more and we think there is an adequate supply in the market place as Saudi Arabia, Iraq. We think this is part of India's role in the international community."

Few expect India to turn off the spigots right away. Replacing $11 billion worth of Iranian oil each year isn鈥檛 easy. But for a variety of other reasons, including internal politics, some analysts say that India will be either unwilling or unable to deliver on Clinton鈥檚 request.

鈥淚t鈥檚 entirely reasonable to request this, but the question is; will they be able to pull it off?鈥 says Sumit Ganguly, a professor of political science and Rabindranath Tagore Chair of Indian Cultures and Civilizations at Indiana University. 鈥淚t comes down to coalition politics and a small number of people who still want to unfurl the banner of non-alignment.鈥

Matters are not made easier by the fact that the current government of India is a coalition propped up by smaller left-wing parties, adds Mr. Ganguly, none of whom are particularly fond of the United States or its push for open and free markets.

鈥淚ndia thus far has failed to come up with an answer to the question of what they want from the US, and what kind of relationship they want to have with the United States,鈥 says Ganguly. 鈥淚 fear that some people in the US are starting to ask, is this really worth it.鈥

If America and India didn鈥檛 have so , this might be considered to be a spat.

Both countries are nuclear-weapons states that are committed to preventing nuclear weapons from proliferating. Both countries seek lower trade barriers in general, and both countries want India to rise up as a regional economic power, as a counterbalance to the Asian giant, China. Both countries, too, favor stable democratic governance, and both see the rise of militant Islam 鈥 particularly from uncontrolled areas of Pakistan 鈥 as a threat.

Gone are the bad old days when post-colonial Indian governments viewed every action by Washington as an attack on its sovereignty, or when Washington viewed New Delhi as a pawn of the Soviet Union. Now, when Washington talks about India, it tends to coo.

Typical is this, assistant secretary of state for South and Central Asia, in a speech last May.

鈥淚ndia is a rising giant whose influence is being felt not only in the Indian Ocean, but clear across Asia Pacific to the shores of the Americas, in Africa, the Middle East, and in Central Asia,鈥 said Mr. Blake. 鈥淚ts rise 鈥 fueled by a young, optimistic, dynamic, educated population 鈥 may well be the biggest story of the 21st century.鈥

Even when it comes to Iranian oil, India and the US don鈥檛 need to agree to disagree. India simply hasn鈥檛 made up its mind, and some question whether India even has the option to consider a cutoff.

A 56-member delegation of the is also present in New Delhi to remind the Indian government that, as the chairman of the Iranian delegation said, 鈥測ou need oil and we need to sell.鈥

Again, in worse times, America might see this as Indian two-faced diplomacy. But the overall state of US-Indian relations is positive. The question is whether Clinton has the kind of leverage to get India to do more than what it is already willing to do, which in the case of Iranian oil, isn鈥檛 much.

Get daily or weekly updates from CSMonitor.com delivered to your inbox.听.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Clinton in India: a gentle reminder about all that Iranian oil
Read this article in
/World/Keep-Calm/2012/0507/Clinton-in-India-a-gentle-reminder-about-all-that-Iranian-oil
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe