海角大神

'Not my king': Why some Brits won't pledge allegiance to Charles

UK Opinion polls suggest opposition to the monarchy is growing. Over 1,500 republican activists plan to dress in yellow and stand along the coronation route in protest as King Charles鈥 coronation procession makes its way to Westminster Abbey on Saturday.

|
Jon Super/AP
Protestors wait for the arrival of King Charles III and Camilla, the queen consort, to visit the Odesa Central Library in Liverpool, England, on April 26, 2023. Opinion polls suggest opposition and apathy to the monarchy are both growing.

On his way to be crowned this week, King Charles III will travel by gilded coach through streets swathed in red, white, and blue Union flags 鈥 and pass a warning from history.

At Trafalgar Square stands a large bronze statue of King Charles I, the 17th-century monarch deposed by Parliament and executed in 1649. On Saturday, more than 1,500 protesters, dressed in yellow for maximum visibility, plan to gather beside it to chant 鈥淣ot my king鈥 as the royal procession goes by.

鈥淲e鈥檒l try and keep the atmosphere light, but our aim is to make it impossible to ignore,鈥 said Graham Smith, chief executive of the anti-monarchist group Republic.

The coronation, he said, is 鈥渁 celebration of a corrupt institution. And it is a celebration of one man taking a job that he has not earned.鈥

Republican activists have long struggled to build momentum to dislodge Britain鈥檚 1,000-year-old monarchy. But they see the coronation as a moment of opportunity.

Queen Elizabeth II, who died in September after 70 years on the throne, was widely respected because of her longevity and sense of duty. Charles is another matter, a 74-year-old whose family feuds and firm opinions on everything from architecture to the environment have been headline fodder for decades.

Opinion polls suggest opposition and apathy to the monarchy are both growing. In a recent National Center for Social Research study, just 29% of respondents thought the monarchy was 鈥渧ery important鈥 鈥 the lowest level in the center鈥檚 40 years of research on the subject. Opposition was highest among the young.

鈥淚 think it鈥檚 definitely shifting,鈥 said Mr. Smith, whose group wants to replace the monarch with an elected head of state. 鈥淧eople are quite happy to criticize Charles in a way they weren鈥檛 willing to necessarily in public about the queen.鈥

Millions in Britain will watch broadcasts when Charles is crowned in Westminster Abbey. Tens of thousands will line the streets, and neighborhoods across the country will hold parties.

But millions more will ignore the ceremonies. Some will attend alternative events, including a gig in Glasgow by tribute band the Scottish Sex Pistols, recapturing the spirit of punks who sang 鈥淕od save the queen, the fascist regime鈥 during the late queen鈥檚 1977 silver jubilee.

London鈥檚 Newington Green Meeting House, a gathering place for religious dissenters and radicals for 300 years, is holding an 鈥渁lternative community party,鈥 complete with food, drink, and 鈥渞adical and republican鈥 music.

General manager Nick Toner said that the event is for people who 鈥渄on鈥檛 want to sit through hours of footage of ceremonies, carriages, and endless Union Jacks, perhaps because they think it鈥檚 a waste of taxpayers鈥 money or even just plain old boring.鈥

While the BBC, Britain鈥檚 publicly owned national broadcaster, will offer wall-to-wall coronation coverage on Saturday, rival Channel 4 offers an alternative schedule, including a musical about disgraced royal Prince Andrew, soapy drama 鈥淭he Windsors鈥 and documentary 鈥淔arewell to the Monarchy.鈥

Some argue that it鈥檚 grotesque to spend millions on pomp and pageantry amid a cost-of-living crisis that has brought 10% inflation, driven thousands to food banks, and triggered months of strikes by nurses, teachers, and other workers seeking higher pay.

Even Charles鈥 slimmed-down ceremony 鈥 with about 2,000 guests instead of the 8,000 who attended the queen鈥檚 coronation in 1953 鈥 carries a big price tag for British taxpayers. The full cost won鈥檛 be known until afterward, but Elizabeth鈥檚 1953 coronation cost 912,000 pounds, the equivalent of 20.5 million pounds ($26 million) today.

Deputy Prime Minister Oliver Dowden, who helps oversee coronation arrangements, has argued that 鈥減eople would not want a dour scrimping and scraping鈥 at such a 鈥渕arvelous moment in our history.鈥 Coronation supporters argue that the celebrations will be a boost for Britain, attracting tourists and stimulating sales.

Not everyone is convinced.

鈥淚 disagree with it,鈥 said Philippa Higgins, a receptionist in London. 鈥淚 just think it seems a bit silly when we鈥檝e got so many people struggling, to have something so extravagant right now. But some people argue tradition, I suppose.鈥

Opposition to the lavish coronation is especially strong in Scotland and Wales, where some pro-independence nationalists see the monarchy as part of the United Kingdom they want to leave.

Some Scottish nationalists object to the Stone of Destiny 鈥 a 275-pound chunk of sandstone linked to both Scottish and English monarchs 鈥 being sent from Edinburgh to London to take its traditional place under the coronation chair. The iconic rock, a symbol of Scottish nationhood seized by an English king in the 13th century and not returned until 1996, had to be moved to Westminster Abbey in secrecy and amid tight security.

Charles is keen to be seen as a modern monarch, and Buckingham Palace has adapted some of the coronation鈥檚 ancient traditions for the 21st century. His coronation will be the first to feature contributions from Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, Muslim, and Sikh leaders, and the first to include female bishops.

Still, a suggestion from the Church of England that people watching the coronation on TV might want to swear allegiance to the king from their sofas has struck a sour note with some.

Charles is the monarch of 14 former British colonies as well as the U.K., and the king has tentatively addressed the legacy of the empire. He supports research into the monarchy鈥檚 links to the trans-Atlantic slave trade, and last year expressed 鈥減ersonal sorrow鈥 at the suffering caused by slavery 鈥 though he stopped short of saying sorry.

The number of Charles鈥 realms is likely to dwindle during his reign. Barbados became a republic in 2021, and Jamaica plans to do the same. New Zealand Prime Minister Chris Hipkins said this week he wants his country to jettison the crown, though he added that it鈥檚 not an 鈥渦rgent priority.鈥

Craig Prescott, a constitutional law expert at Bangor University in Wales, says that in the U.K., the monarchy is probably safe for now because of Britain鈥檚 tendency to 鈥渕uddle through鈥 and gradually adapt its politics and constitution to changing times.

鈥淐learly, if you were going to start from scratch, you would probably never choose one family and say, 鈥楾hey鈥檙e going to provide a head of state forever,鈥欌 he said. But the arrangement mostly works, and abolishing the crown 鈥渋sn鈥檛 on the horizon of any political party.鈥

Still, he sees danger ahead if a young generation that has endured years of austerity, pandemic, and economic pinch continues to struggle.

鈥淚f the monarchy stands for the status quo, the status quo isn鈥檛 necessarily great, in generational terms, for a certain section,鈥 Mr. Prescott said. 鈥淚f that continues, then that may be a problem for a lot of national institutions in 20 or 30 years鈥 time.鈥

This story was reported by The Associated Press. AP videojournalist Kwiyeon Ha contributed to this story.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to 'Not my king': Why some Brits won't pledge allegiance to Charles
Read this article in
/World/Europe/2023/0504/Not-my-king-Why-some-Brits-won-t-pledge-allegiance-to-Charles
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe