海角大神

In northeast China, a test for Beijing's big bet on fairer growth

For decades, the Communist Party's fate was tied to the pace of economic growth. Now, amid a changing economy, President Xi has emphasized his vision for a fairer society. But that dream can seem distant in regions hard hit by the transition. 

|
China Daily/Reuters/File
Rescue workers of a coal mining company take part in an emergency rescue drill in Huaibei, Anhui province, China.

Early last month, Yang Yongsheng arrived in this hardscrabble mining citynear the Russian border听to look for work. He had fallen on hard times after a bad rice harvest and was eager to get out of farming. A coal miner told him he could make a decent wage in the mines spread out around Shuangyashan.听With nothing to lose, Mr. Yang decided to take the man's advice.

He found work, but authoritiesshut down the mine nine days later 鈥 one of the latest causalities in China鈥檚 nationwide effort to reduce overcapacity and shore up coal prices.听This northeastern province, Heilongjiang, has been among the hardest hit.听In 2016, the provincial government said it would听听in the next three to five years, eliminating tens of thousands of jobs.

Yang now spends his days wandering the streets in search of whatever work he can find. He鈥檚 happy that his wife found a job in a local restaurant, but the $330 it pays听per听month isn鈥檛 nearly enough听to support them and their teenage son. On the verge of exhaustion and destitution, Yang is at a loss about what to do. When he thinks about Chinese President Xi Jinping鈥檚听recent听promise to make a more prosperous and fairer society, his question is: When will I see it?

鈥淚 don鈥檛 believe in the Chinese Communist Party,鈥 he says over soup and lamb skewers in a small restaurant beneath a decrepit apartment building. 鈥淲hat they say is different from what I see in reality.鈥

For the past four decades, the Party鈥檚 fate was tied to economic development. Now that the pace has slowed, however, the widening inequality and pervasive corruption that accompanied China鈥檚 boom years have emerged as the greatest threats to its legitimacy. At a seminal party meeting in October, Mr. Xi redefined the 鈥減rincipal contradiction鈥 faced by Chinese people as one between people鈥檚 desire for a better life and 鈥渦nbalanced and inadequate development.鈥

Xie Yujuan/海角大神
A sign at a coal mine in Shuangyashan, China, reads "Deepen reforms to increase efficiency and accelerate the transformation for development." Dozens of coal mines have been closed in the region in recent years.

But the gap听between Mr. Xi鈥檚 vision of a fairer society and the actual lives of people like Yang is starkly visible in Shuangyashan. The city is a drab assortment of concrete housing blocks, dilapidated storefronts, and rusting factories surrounded by rolling hills and wind-swept fields. It looks forgotten, a relic of the past waiting to be repurposed for an uncertain future.

Many听of its residents are losing patience. The city鈥檚 economy has slowed to a crawl in recent yearsas China becomes less reliant on industrial growth. A plunge in coal prices in 2015 only accelerated听the collapse of the local coal industry. In March of the following year, thousands of workers took to the streets to protest against a state-owned mining company for unpaid wages.

The protests came and went, but not before sending a signal to Beijing about the risks from social tensions created by decades of rapid and unequal growth. Those risks are something Xi appears to now be taking seriously as he looks for new ways to defend the Party鈥檚 image.

鈥淭his is a crucial issue for every Chinese person,鈥 says Keegan Elmer, a researcher at China Labour Bulletin, a labor-rights group based in Hong Kong. 鈥淭hey know that inequality is growing day by day and that it's time for the average Chinese person to have a greater slice of the pie.鈥

Changing jobs and mindsets

Northeastern China presents an especially difficult challenge to Xi鈥檚 appeal for a brighter futurefor everycitizen. The听region鈥檚听three provinces听have some of the weakest economies in the country.听Collectively known as China鈥檚 rust belt, they鈥檝e struggled to overhaul bloated state-owned enterprises and reduce their dependence on coal and steel production. A听听measuring Chinese cities鈥 economic performance provides further evidence of this grim reality.听Out of the 226 third-tier cities included in the index, Shuangyashan ranks last. Many other cities in the northeast aren鈥檛 far ahead.

The economic听decline was on full display at an indoor market in central Shuangyashan in early November.听Stall owners complain about having fewer customers. Wholesalers complain about having fewer orders. And Mr. Yin, an affable man in his mid-40s who gave only his surname, tries not to complain about any of it.

鈥淭he economy isn鈥檛 good and it鈥檚 not easy to do business here, but there鈥檚 no free lunch,鈥 he says. 鈥淚f you work hard, you鈥檒l get what you deserve.鈥

Two years ago, Yin was laid off from a state-owned coal mine. He had worked there for 20 years. In his early days, he never expected to work another job in his life. Coal production was crucial to China鈥檚 fast-growing economy.听And while market reforms were well underway in much of the south and along the coast, the northeast clung to its socialist ways.听State-owned firms still dominated the economy,听and many people still believed that working for one of them all but guaranteed an 鈥渋ron rice bowl鈥 鈥 job security from cradle to grave.

But by 2014, it became clear that the northeast was long overdue for reforms. China鈥檚 economy was growing at its slowest rate in a quarter century,听weighed down by traditional industrial businesses struggling with excess capacity and dwindling demand.听The government soon began to shut down inefficient mines and factories.听In February 2016, the Labor Ministry听听to lay off 1.8 million steel and coal workers. Worried about their prospects in a bleak job market, workers began to organize strikes and protests across the country.

Authorities have responded to the unrest, including the incident in Shuangyashan, with a heavy hand. They鈥檝e quashed protests and arrested activists.听Xi appears willing to do whatever it takes to maintain loyalty to the ruling Communist Party at a time of economic uncertainty. In return, he has promised to lead China toward more balanced development.

鈥淧resident Xi wants to make a firewall between civil society and the middle class,鈥 says听Wu Qiang, a political scientist in Beijing who formerly taught at Tsinghua University. 鈥淗e sees civil society as a potential challenge to the Communist Party.鈥

That the party continues to portray itself as a guardian of worker鈥檚 rights is an irony not lost on some.听As for Yin, who works at a small lunch stall at the market, he says he鈥檚 learned a valuable lesson about socialism. All that remains of his iron rice bowl is the roughly $75 stipend he receives every month from the government. In three years, that too will end.

鈥淧eople鈥檚 minds have changed,鈥 Yin says. 鈥淵ou can鈥檛 just wait for the government. You need to go out and find work.鈥

Yet finding a new job is easier said than done for many laid-off state workers, especially as the government encourages investment in high-tech industries听unlikely to need their services.听Still, Beijing is looking for ways to help as it pushes to reduce surplus industrial capacity while avoiding widespread unrest. Last year, it earmarked about $15 billion for relocating and retraining programs for state workers.听Support has also come from outside the country. Earlier this month, Shaungyashan and three other cities in Heilongjiang secured a听听from the Asian Development Bank to help revitalize their economies.

In spite of such efforts, Fan Xingshen, an 85-year-old retired coal worker, says he sees little hope for Shuangyashan. After two of his sons were laid off from a local coal mine last year, he was happy to see them move south to search for better jobs. One moved to Beijing; the other to the port city of Tianjin.

鈥淭he good times are over,鈥 says Mr. Fan, who lives in the sclerosis ward of a state-run hospital, his lungs severely damaged from the 28 years he spent working underground. 鈥淭here鈥檚 nothing the government can do.鈥

Xie Yujuancontributed to this report.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to In northeast China, a test for Beijing's big bet on fairer growth
Read this article in
/World/Asia-Pacific/2017/1221/In-northeast-China-a-test-for-Beijing-s-big-bet-on-fairer-growth
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe