海角大神

Not a suicide: Mexico murder case challenges views of gender violence

Six years after Mariana Lima鈥檚 brutal death, the case was reinvestigated, one of several small but significant shifts in a country roiled by gender-based violence.

|
Eduardo Verdugo/AP
A demonstrator carries a cross that reads in Spanish: "For you, for all" to protest violence against women on International Women's Day in Mexico City, March 8, 2016.

Six years after Mariana Lima鈥檚 brutal death was labeled a suicide, her mother can finally exhale. She dedicated the past several years to campaigning for her daughter鈥檚 case to be reinvestigated, and last month her efforts resulted in the arrest of Ms. Lima鈥檚 former husband on charges of femicide.

It鈥檚 a grim victory for Lima鈥檚 family and the relatives of the tens of thousands of others in Mexico who have lost their lives to femicide 鈥 the deliberate killing of a woman based on her gender. And it鈥檚 an important moment for Mexico, part of a series of small but significant shifts in the landscape of violence against women here.

鈥淭his reinvestigation has become a platform from which we can expect all other cases of violent murders of women to be investigated with due diligence and a gender perspective,鈥 says Rodolfo Dom铆nguez, the lawyer representing Lima鈥檚 family.

There were more than 16,000 femicides 鈥 or roughly seven per day 鈥 in Mexico between 2008 and 2014. That makes it one of the worst countries for gender-based violence in the world, ranking worse than already notorious India. Endemic impunity means murders go unpunished here, with only 1.6 percent of femicides in 2012 resulting in sentences.

Lima鈥檚 case, despite evidence of strangulation and a marital history of rape and physical violence, represents a universal challenge in cases of femicide in Mexico: rates of generalized violence are high, tending to inure people, and views on gender are often skewed.

A recent survey by the National Autonomous University (UNAM) found that 88 percent of Mexicans believe 鈥渧iolence [is] a fact of daily life.鈥 More than half of female respondents from Mexico state and Mexico City said they have experienced violence within the family, and 1 in 3 male respondents said it is acceptable to hit a woman 鈥渦nder certain circumstances.鈥

State governments are often criticized for being slow to publicly recognize the scale of the problem of female-targeted violence. Just last month, Mexico City Mayor Miguel Mancera was ridiculed when he proposed handing out whistles to women as a solution to warding off any unwanted attention.

But signs of changing views here are starting to emerge. They include a high-profile campaign against intimate partner violence by one of Mexico鈥檚 largest beer companies, Tecate, and an uptick in states implementing 鈥済ender violence alerts,鈥 which give them the flexibility to roll out a series of emergency measures to improve safety for women.

鈥淭he existence of gender violence has become an irrefutable issue within public opinion,鈥 says Laura Garcia, director of Semillas, a women鈥檚 rights NGO. 鈥淭his is very clear progress as only a few years ago it was much easier for governments to deny that we live in a culture where violence against women is systematic.鈥

'The reality of violence'

Lima鈥檚 murder took place in Mexico state, which has one of the highest femicide rates in the country. A 2011 report by the attorney general鈥檚 office seemed to place the blame on women themselves, claiming they 鈥済et involved with multiple partners ... work in bars where they associate with clients ... and go out on their own late at night.鈥

鈥淭heir attitude was dreadful,鈥 says聽Mr. Dom铆nguez, the lawyer. 鈥淲e reached a point where we weren鈥檛 going to seek any further contact with the authorities [on Lima鈥檚 case] as we saw no political will or intention to deal with the issue.鈥

But the Supreme Court ruled last year that Mexico state officials must reinvestigate Lima鈥檚 death taking femicide into consideration. It was the first time a Mexican court ruled that femicide should be the starting point for an investigation into a violent female death.

Although that victory came from the top-down, there have been plenty of grass-roots efforts as well.

Until a few years ago, gender alerts聽were written off as tools used solely to politically damage a state governor. The alerts, which can be called for by human rights organizations but only granted by state governments, trigger a series of emergency actions such as the creation of special victim units and dedicated investigation teams that allow authorities to address an immediate crisis. While they don鈥檛 pretend to attack the root of the problem, the alerts seek to lay the groundwork for later public policy efforts that target systemic change.

Public awareness campaigns, strategic lawsuits, and lobbying for femicide-specific legislation by NGOs like the National Citizens Observatory on Femicide have produced a flurry of gender-violence alerts in the past two years, with four now approved and a further eight under review.

鈥淭here is a saying in Mexico that dirty clothes should be washed at home, that gender violence should not be publicly discussed,鈥 says Patricia Galeana, an academic involved in the UNAM gender survey.

But she鈥檚 noted signs that that 鈥渄irty laundry鈥 is finally 鈥 if slowly 鈥 making its way into the public. Earlier this year, when a female journalist publicly denounced a man who groped her on the street in broad daylight, the reaction was explosive. Thousands of women took to social media to聽recount聽their own experiences with sexual聽harassment in Mexico.

鈥淭en years ago, no one talked about femicides," says Dom铆nguez. "but by naming the reality of violence you can start to change it."

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Not a suicide: Mexico murder case challenges views of gender violence
Read this article in
/World/Americas/2016/0729/Not-a-suicide-Mexico-murder-case-challenges-views-of-gender-violence
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe