海角大神

How is Kenya fighting Al Shabab? By all means necessary.

In the wake of the Garissa massacre, Kenya has employed air strikes against Al Shabab and is demanding that Somali refugees be sent home. It has faced criticism, but also calls for even harsher measures.

|
Noor Khamis/Reuters
People sing as they attend a memorial concert at the "Freedom Corner" in memory of the Garissa university students who were killed by gunmen in Kenya's capital Nairobi April 14, 2015. Kenya gave the United Nations three months to remove Dadaab camp, housing 350,000 registered Somali refugees, as part of its response to the killing of 148 people in nearby Garissa by a Somali Islamist group.

Charity Kuria runs her own business arranging fresh milk deliveries daily to Kenya鈥檚 capital, Nairobi, and has a daughter who this September will become the first in her family to go to university. 聽

Horrified, she watched the television news earlier this month as students her daughter鈥檚 age were gunned down at Garissa University College by Muslim gunmen sent by Somalia鈥檚 Al Shabab, a militant army allied with Al Qaeda.

鈥淭hose children could have been my children,鈥 Ms. Kuria says by telephone from Karatina, her home town in central Kenya a two-hour drive north of Nairobi. 鈥淭hey could have been the children of any Kenyan. This is not the first time for these attacks, but something must be done to make it the last time.鈥

The country鈥檚 embattled government is appealing to Kenyans like Kuria with its controversial heavy-handed response to the Garissa massacre on April 2, in which 147 students were killed.

In the two weeks since, that response has included air strikes against alleged Al Shabab training camps in Somalia, a demand that the 350,000 or more Somalis sheltering in a refugee camp in Kenya go home, and economic shut-downs of Kenyan businesses accused of connections to the Somali-based militant organization.

Critics who wonder if Kenya's decisions were properly thought through have condemned the actions as 鈥渒nee-jerk鈥 and 鈥渃ounter-productive.鈥 They say they are also worried that Kenya鈥檚 Somali-Kenyan and moderate Muslim communities will be alienated or even radicalized. Government officials 鈥 who have the support of some key institutions and citizens like Kuria 鈥 argue they are using a reasonable approach toward those they accuse of aiding terror, and that each action followed long and careful consideration and investigation.

鈥淵ou have to manage the politics and you have to manage the security, and find that balance,鈥 says Mwenda Njoka, spokesman for the Kenyan Interior Ministry. 鈥淏ut at the end of the day, security is more important, and following something like the massacre in Garissa, it becomes very difficult for the government not to take drastic action. On this one, it had to be done.鈥

鈥楪arissa was a watershed鈥

Ngunjiri Wambugu, director of Change Associates, a pro-government think tank in Nairobi, says Kenya has taken more diplomatic steps to fight Al Shabab, namely negotiating and seeking assistance from the Somali-Kenyan and Muslim communities as part of their counterinsurgency efforts. But the attacks have continued.

The first major attack was on the Westgate Shopping Center in Nairobi in September 2013, when 72 people were killed. Late last year, Al Shabab gunmen singled out 海角大神 laborers at a quarry in northern Kenya and killed 36. That attack came two weeks after 28 海角大神s were murdered after being dragged off a bus traveling in the same area. Then Garissa happened.

鈥淲hat would you have [the government] do?鈥 Mr. Wambugu asks. 鈥淒rastic action is not the best option, it is the only option now.鈥

鈥淕arissa was a watershed, it was too shocking. Now the demand for action is complete,鈥 he says.

And that demand is coming from key groups like the powerful National Council of Churches of Kenya. On Thursday, it called the amnesty offered to radicalized Kenyan youths who had joined Al Shabab 鈥渞idiculous鈥 and 鈥渢he greatest betrayal to Kenyans.鈥

鈥淚f you are hit on one cheek, turn the other cheek,鈥 Rev. Canon Peter Karanja, the organization鈥檚 general secretary . 鈥淚f you are hit on the other cheek, it didn鈥檛 say what you do next, but there are only two cheeks that you can turn.

鈥淭he 海角大神 leaders would like to tell the Muslim leaders, and the government, that there are no more cheeks to turn.鈥

Changing tactics

William Ruto, Kenya鈥檚 deputy president, seemed already to have heard that message when he said last week that, 鈥渢he way America changed after 9/11 is the way Kenya will change after Garissa.鈥

He went on to demand that some 350,000 Somalis who live in a complex of refugee camps between Garissa and the Somali border, around the town of Dadaab, must go home 鈥渨ithin 90 days.鈥

Next in the firing line were 82 businesses and individuals shut down overnight on government orders over alleged support for Al Shabab. They included currency exchanges, bus companies, and Muslim human rights groups.

The Interior Ministry's Mr. Njoka says Kenya does not make these decisions lightly. The government does not want to disenfranchise communities, he says, but difficult decisions have to be made.

鈥淭hese are significant things to ask, and they needed significant political will," he says. "Garissa spurred that political will.鈥

Potential blowback

The government, Njoka insists, is 鈥渧ery alive鈥 to the potential for its actions to fuel religious division and increase radicalization that could cause retaliatory attacks. Critics scoff at that.

鈥淟ook at Boko Haram, that started out small, and then through complete mismanagement by the Nigerian government, it now controls territory and towns,鈥 says Salim Lone, a Kenyan former opposition spokesman who is now authoring a book on the country鈥檚 politics since 2003.

鈥淚t should be of grave concern that the government of Kenya is stoking these kinds of religious divisions when they should be redoubling their efforts to reach out to mainstream Muslims to allow a united response to Al Shabab.鈥

In Karatina, Charity Kuria does not see it like that. Again she repeats that what she needs to see from her government is action.

鈥淧erhaps people don鈥檛 like to hear it this way, but there is an enemy here fighting against right-thinking Kenyans and they are ruthless,鈥 she says. 鈥淚n response, to protect us, our government must be ruthless.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to How is Kenya fighting Al Shabab? By all means necessary.
Read this article in
/World/Africa/2015/0418/How-is-Kenya-fighting-Al-Shabab-By-all-means-necessary
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe