海角大神

Why San Francisco is moving the homeless for Super Bowl 50

Hundreds protested on Wednesday as San Francisco officials moved dozens of homeless people off the streets in preparation for this weekend's big game.

|
Curtis Skinner/REUTERS
Demonstrators gather near Super Bowl City to protest San Francisco's response to homelessness in February, 2016. As many as 200 demonstrators rallied in downtown San Francisco on Wednesday near where Super Bowl festivities are being hosted, protesting what they say are the city's plans to clear away homeless people to make way for tourists and events.

San Francisco saw demonstrations Wednesday against a citywide order to clean up the streets in advance of Super Bowl 50. Approximately 200 people came together to protest the city鈥檚 handling of the issue.

Mayor Ed Lee聽 that the homeless would have to leave the streets in advance of the National Football League's championship game.

Although the Super Bowl is being held nearly an hour away at Levi鈥檚 Stadium in Santa Clara, San Francisco expects crowds of tourists to flood the city for fan events, concerts, and shopping in the days surrounding the event.

鈥淲e are always going to be supportive,鈥 said Mayor Lee in August, 鈥淏ut you are going to have to leave the street. Not just because it is illegal, but because it is dangerous.鈥

The Super Bowl festivities are concentrated in an area of the city called the Embarcadero, a space of several blocks that is normally inhabited by a number of homeless people.

In his August remarks, Lee identified drug addiction and mental illness as some of the major factors that brought his city鈥檚 homeless population to the streets.

According to officials, the city began its efforts early in an attempt to address the heart of the issue rather than temporarily moving people as the Super Bowl approached. Last January, the city opened a new shelter called the . The new center aims to provide not only shelter, but also services such as addiction rehabilitation and housing help.

Twenty four homeless people from the Embarcadero district were moved to the Navigation Center ahead of the Super Bowl. The shelter gave priority to homeless people from areas that would be highly visible to Super Bowl fans.

San Francisco鈥檚 Coalition on Homelessness says that 鈥渟treet cleaning鈥 efforts are taking place in other parts of the city that are not part of the Super Bowl festivities.

City officials claim that they are merely trying to keep homeless people out of the rain, which is especially strong this year due to El Ni帽o. Yet, despite assertions by city administrators that they are not trying to hide San Francisco鈥檚 homeless population, police have been from underpasses along the Super Bowl route.

According Maria Foscarinis, the executive director of the National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty, cities use existing laws against loitering or sitting down in public to criminalize homelessness. It is illegal for police to seize personal property such as tents, but she says they often do it anyway.

鈥淭he police told us that after the Super Bowl, y鈥檃ll can come back,鈥 one homeless man who identified himself simply as Aaron told The Wall Street Journal. Aaron and his wife Shawna recently lost their tent when by police.

Ms. Foscarinis says San Francisco鈥檚 high housing prices are part of the city鈥檚 larger problem. 鈥淯nless these underlying causes are addressed,鈥 she told 海角大神, 鈥渢his will continue to happen.鈥

Reuters reported that the homeless population and its advocates gathered on Wednesday to protest the city鈥檚 efforts. Protesters held their ground in a tent city erected in the Embarcadero district and advocated for their right to sleep on the streets.

Some have expressed frustration with the city鈥檚 recent attention to its 7,000-strong homeless population. One young woman, Nikki Millett, told Reuters that, "What I am against is that homelessness has been a huge problem in this city for a long time and Mayor Lee hasn't done anything about it until [the Super Bowl]."

Critics of the San Francisco鈥檚 Super Bowl preparations cite the city鈥檚 $4.8-million spending on the event鈥檚 festivities. Despite the city鈥檚 recent construction of the Navigation Center and another shelter called the Pier 80 shelter, some say that with two years to prepare, San Francisco in advance efforts to solve its homelessness problem. 聽

Street cleaning efforts like San Francisco鈥檚 are common in cities that are such as sporting events or political conventions.

Many Olympic host cities, including Atlanta, London, and Vancouver, have responded by shifting homeless people off of the streets. In Atlanta and Sydney, officials forcibly removed homeless people.

In London, where homelessness and 鈥渞ough sleeping鈥 rose in the year , officials worked to address the issue long term. Despite efforts, homelessness is still .

Homelessness has gained attention as an issue in recent months. In January, Seattle Mayor Ed Murray was in the midst of a speech about his own city鈥檚 homeless problem when five people were shot in a homeless tent city called 鈥渢he Jungle.鈥 New York Mayor Bill de Blasio also to forcibly move homeless people off the streets in early January.

Meanwhile, Foscarinis says the National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty has been working with the city. She says that although San Francisco has built additional shelter space, it simply isn鈥檛 enough to shelter the city鈥檚 homeless population.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Why San Francisco is moving the homeless for Super Bowl 50
Read this article in
/USA/USA-Update/2016/0204/Why-San-Francisco-is-moving-the-homeless-for-Super-Bowl-50
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe