海角大神

In the NCAA March Madness basketball tournament, what鈥檚 a win worth to the little guys?

Small universities whose finances are pinched by changing student demographics might dream of being the next Gonzaga or Butler. But ephemeral successes might not be worth the investment.

|
John Minchillo/AP
New Orleans' Nate Frye (3) defends against Mount St. Mary's Junior Robinson (0) in the second half of a First Four game of the NCAA college basketball tournament on Tuesday, March 14, 2017, in Dayton, Ohio.

In the closing seconds of Tuesday night鈥檚 First Four match, Mount St. Mary University鈥檚 forward Chris Wray raced forward to bat down a long inbounds pass, then ran away with the ball, sealing a tight victory over the University of New Orleans.

The win earned Mount St. Mary鈥檚 a long-shot chance against first-seeded Villanova on Thursday 鈥 and at least a few precious days of national limelight for the Emmitsburg, Md., university of just over 1,500 undergraduate students.

That sudden crest into prominence is, of course, a perennial one for the small colleges and universities who slip into the higher seeds of the NCAA tournament every spring. And for the vast majority of programs, such moments are hard to count on, making sports investment a tough gamble for small-university administrators trying to make up for schools' growing financial pressures.聽But they can also be deeply alluring for campuses faced with stiffening competition for students.

鈥淚 would say that it can be a net gain for schools just like playing the left column at a roulette table in Vegas can be a net gain for gamblers,鈥 says Stephen Ross, the director of Pennsylvania State University鈥檚 Institute for Sports Law, Policy, and Research, in an interview with 海角大神.

Underdogs like Mount St. Mary wouldn鈥檛 bring home a big prize even for the most unlikely of upsets, since per-win March Madness payouts are distributed, , across the winner鈥檚 conference.

A few small colleges that pursued Division 1 sports programs have been able to parlay success into a stronger academic profile in the past, adds Mr. Ross. But there isn鈥檛 any literature examining how rare that crossover success really is.聽

If they're successful, "it puts them on the map," he says. "Student SAT scores go up, applications go up, alumni contributions go up. The question is for how many schools, and whether this is really a prudent investment for each school."

But "how many other schools have spent millions of dollars they could have spent on lower tuition or improved education on this pipe dream of athletic success?鈥 he asks.

With state funding down and costs rising, public universities have generated ire in recent years for pouring money into coaches鈥 salaries and other aspects of Division 1 sports programs while slicing away academic budgets. It鈥檚 a decision, some charge, that ultimately promotes a university鈥檚 name at the cost of its raison d鈥櫭猼re. 聽

The fiscal picture at private colleges is more mixed. But a post-2011 decline in college enrollment聽, especially those located in sparsely populated areas, as students are increasingly attending colleges closer to home, as the Washington Post reported this summer.

That could tempt administrators at small colleges to shift funding toward a Division 1 program 鈥 and 13 other school teams, the minimum number required聽by the NCAA for Division 1 certification 鈥 as a means of elevating the school鈥檚 national profile and generating school spirit.

鈥淭he fervor around the event itself makes it a community gathering point,鈥 says Ellen Staurowsky, a professor at Drexel University鈥檚 Department of Sport Management who has studied college sports financing. 鈥淪ome school administrators feel very strongly that this is the kind of rallying point that just can鈥檛 be created in any other way on campus, so there are clear benefits whether you have money coming in directly from the event or not.鈥

Should universities with scant room for error invest in athletic programs to drum up more applications and improve fundraising? It depends on how it鈥檚 done, Dr. Staurowsky tells the Monitor.

Would tournament win money be "like gravy for them, or are they living above their means and encountering a law of diminishing returns?" she asks. "I think it's that balancing act between whether or not you're growing your department within your means or taking too much risk."

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to In the NCAA March Madness basketball tournament, what鈥檚 a win worth to the little guys?
Read this article in
/USA/Society/2017/0315/In-the-NCAA-March-Madness-basketball-tournament-what-s-a-win-worth-to-the-little-guys
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe