海角大神

Mississippi most obese state: Southern diet or culture on the skids?

The Deep South has some of the highest obesity rates in the nation, according to the CDC, and Mississippi, once again, is the fattest. But it's not just the fried food that's to blame.

|
Rogelio Solis/AP
Trays of fried okra, peas and carrots, beans, rice, corn, blackeyed peas, ham, chicken, and chopped steak, attract customers to the one-room 'Country Boy's Produce' in downtdown Jackson, Miss., in 2004.

Fried catfish, hush puppies, piles of pork, shrimp po鈥檅oys 鈥 the delicacies of the South, as a recent obesity report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta seems to suggest, are also its enemy.

Southern states are, on par, the chubbiest (with Mississippi topping the list for the sixth year with 1 in 3 adults technically obese).

Most curiously, while the Southern diet hasn鈥檛 really changed much, the percentage of Mississippians who are obese has more than doubled in the last 20 years, from 15 to 35 percent since 1991 鈥 mirroring in large part what the CDC calls a 鈥渄ramatic鈥 belt-expansion across the country over that same time span. (A 5-foot-9 adult weighing 203 pounds is considered baseline obese by the CDC.)

But is the salty, rich grub that鈥檚 become synonymous with the region really the key reason why the South is losing the battle of the bulge? Or is that slab of BBQ ribs too easy of a target?

Some researchers suggest there are deeper cultural explanations to the Southern weight gain that go beyond fried chicken 鈥 including attitudes toward work and exercise, cultural norms for portion size, and the myriad daily decisions and associations that go into deciding what鈥檚 for supper 鈥 and that can inform the broader phenomenon of an increasingly fat America.

In that light, the culinary particulars of the Fried Chicken Belt are becoming increasingly interesting to researchers, some of whom are using the South and its distinctive grub to peer more closely at the聽 relationship between food, weight, and culture by studying a region that continues, thanks to the CDC鈥檚 careful waistline monitoring, to bear the brunt of foodie stereotypes and fat jokes.

鈥淚 think what we as Southerners take exception to are the stereotypes that don鈥檛 reflect the complexity and contradictions of the region, but Southerners are trying to puzzle through the obesity problem, and how to do it in a thoughtful way that does not rely on the fried chicken trope,鈥 says John T. Edge, the director of the Southern Foodways Alliance in Oxford, Miss. 鈥淭he real paradox is that we鈥檙e the region with the most munificent growing season of any, and why is this place that could take such advantage of a vegetable-based diet growing fatter and fatter?鈥

The University of Mississippi-based food culture research organization, where staff describe themselves as 鈥淐itizens of the Banana Pudding Republic鈥 who once constructed a 鈥渂acon tree鈥 with pork belly fruit, has launched an investigation into those and other paradoxes of Southern obesity. They鈥檒l publish their findings in an upcoming edition of their magazine, Gravy.

To be sure, local variations in diet may explain only a small part of the national obesity picture. "Certainly the Deep South has many of the highest rates, but it is a national problem,鈥 Dr. Jim McVay, chief of health promotion for Alabama鈥檚 Department of Public Health, tells the Associated Press.

Researchers have linked America鈥檚 huge jump in obesity over the last 20 years to fast food marketing 鈥 specifically how human brains tend to allow restaurants, by virtue of portion sizes and prices, to define how much is enough to eat. Others have pointed to the decline of outdoor play in favor of organized activities as a cause. There are deeper aspirations in the human psyche, too, to store calories when food is inexpensive and widely available 鈥 which in the US has become 24/7/365. That instinct may be greater in people who have less. The South, after all, is the nation鈥檚 poorest region and Mississippi the country鈥檚 poorest state.

鈥淐ollecting the maximum number of calories with the least amount of effort is, after all, the dream of every creature,鈥 concludes the New Yorker鈥檚 Elizabeth Kolbert in an essay on America鈥檚 weight gain.

If that鈥檚 true, then it may only make sense why denizens of the South 鈥 where the food tradition, not to mention the vittles themselves, is so rich and where聽 hard field work has nearly disappeared 鈥 may be particularly susceptible to weight gain.

As a region, Southerners moved off the land en masse just a couple of generations ago, a migration that partly clashed with the rise of cable TV, the Internet and video games. That cultural and demographic confluence may also have played a role in creating demand for larger and more indulgent portions.

鈥淚 think part of what鈥檚 happened is we鈥檝e taken ritual events, like harvest events, where there鈥檚 going to be indulgence and unusual pleasure of one kind or another and made them into things that are widely available and routine,鈥 says Ted Ownby, director of the Center for the Study of Southern Culture in Oxford, Miss. 鈥淭hat makes me think that any big change will come from a larger change in society rather than a new food pyramid.鈥

Another cultural clue to the Southern weight gap surrounds attitudes around exercise as distinct from hard, physical work 鈥 a distinction that鈥檚 being tapped into, for example, by a PR campaign called 鈥淟et鈥檚 Go Walkin鈥, Mississippi!鈥

鈥淚n many parts of the South, if you鈥檙e walking by the side of the road, you鈥檙e marked as not being able to afford a car 鈥 it鈥檚 not a virtuous activity,鈥 says Mr. Edge. 鈥淲hile hard work is valorized in the South, purposeful exercise is not valorized in the whole of the South as it is in other regions of the country.鈥

The South鈥檚 waistline, as a whole, has not yet stopped growing, according to the CDC. All 12 of the states that had obesity levels above 30 percent were in the Fried Chicken Belt: The Deep South and lower Midwest. The slimmest Americans are found in the Northeast and the Mountain West, particularly Colorado, where 1 in 5 residents are nevertheless obese.

"We've got to change some of the culture to make the healthy choice the easy choice," Victor Sutton, director of Mississippi鈥檚 Office of Preventive Health, told the AP.聽 "We're trying to get obesity to level off before we can start to get the rates to go down."

For now, in other words, it may not be enough to hold the slaw.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Mississippi most obese state: Southern diet or culture on the skids?
Read this article in
/USA/Society/2012/0814/Mississippi-most-obese-state-Southern-diet-or-culture-on-the-skids
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe