Don't call Hillary Clinton 'disingenuous,' but really don't call her 'liar'
Disingenuous. The longtime political code word for 鈥渓iar,鈥� applying to someone who not only twists the truth but is seen as completely clueless in doing so.
鈥淒isingenuous鈥� is almost constantly in the news, but received new prominence this week in connection with Hillary Rodham Clinton. A pro-Clinton group called HRC Super Volunteers sent New York Times campaign reporter Amy Chozick a list of words it considered unacceptable in describing the likely Democratic presidential front-runner. 鈥淵ou are on notice that we will be watching, reading, listening and protesting coded sexism,鈥� the e-mail
The examples singled out included 鈥渟ecretive, polarizing, calculating, insincere, ambitious鈥� 鈥� and 鈥渄isingenuous.鈥� While the group may consider that last word as a pejorative, the reality is that it鈥檚 often a polite way of insulting someone without having to be so unseemly. (A similarly deployed euphemism is 鈥渕isleading.鈥�)
鈥淒isingenuous鈥� also popped up when Jon Stewart last week Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader. The Kentucky lawmaker had criticized Democrats for delaying a sex-trafficking bill because of what Senator McConnell called the appeasement of 鈥渓eft-wing special interest groups.鈥� Referring to antiabortion language that Republicans insisted be put in the bill, Mr. Stewart admonished McConnell for making 鈥渁 disingenuous point鈥�: 鈥淭he only reason the language is in there is because you鈥檙e bowing down to right-wing special interests.鈥�
Though this is quickly no longer becoming the case, it鈥檚 considered bad form 鈥� at least in person, as opposed to in print or online 鈥� to accuse someone of out-and-out prevarication. Then-Nebraska Democratic Sen. Bob Kerrey discovered this in 1996 when he President Bill Clinton as an 鈥渦nusually good liar鈥� in a magazine interview. And, of course, South Carolina GOP Rep. Joe Wilson caused an even bigger furor when he 鈥淵ou lie!鈥� at President Obama during a 2009 speech.
Hence the popularity of 鈥渄isingenuous.鈥� When Steve Rothman found himself in 2012 having to run against fellow New Jersey Democrat Bill Pascrell because of congressional redistricting, he put out a video showing the blustery Mr. Pascrell appearing tongue-tied in an MSNBC interview. Pascrell spokesman Sean Darcy retorted: 鈥淭his video is disingenuous to the point of being laughable.鈥�
More recently, new Iowa Republican Sen. Joni Ernst of Iowa said that when Mr. Obama vowed to work closely with her party after the GOP鈥檚 huge gains in the midterm elections, his promise was, , 鈥渁 little disingenuous. He鈥檚 had six years to work with Republicans, and now he鈥檚 offering a hand and being willing to sit down with Senator McConnell and our other soon-to-be colleagues.鈥� He鈥檚 been so disengaged and not willing to work with Republicans or even some members of his own party.鈥�
The Sunlight Foundation鈥檚 handy 鈥淐apitol Words鈥� tool, which combs the Congressional Record, has the usage of 鈥渄isingenuous鈥� has been fairly constant over the past two decades, with its usage between the parties split fairly evenly. The most frequent users? Now-retired Republican Sen. Judd Gregg of New Hampshire and McConnell鈥檚 arch-nemesis Harry Reid, the Senate minority leader.
Chuck McCutcheon and David Mark write their "Speaking Politics" blog exclusively for Politics Voices.
