Young progressives flock to Sanders 鈥� but their grandparents prefer Mayor Pete
| IOWA CITY AND BETTENDORF, IOWA
Kathy McCue has been asking undecided voters a question: What kind of world do they want for their grandchildren?
Most of the time, the response has less to do with policies than values 鈥� such as responsibility, truth, and respect. And that鈥檚 her segue to talk about Pete Buttigieg, her favorite 2020 candidate and the person she thinks would usher in the best future. Even though he鈥檚 the same age as her children.听
The 2020 Democratic field of presidential candidates has made history for its number of women and candidates of color.听It also stands out for its age diversity. If elected, Mr. Buttigieg, the former mayor of South Bend, Indiana, would be the youngest president ever on Inauguration Day. Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, former Vice President Joe Biden, and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren would all be the oldest.
Why We Wrote This
The Democratic field features candidates who would be the oldest and youngest presidents ever. Many of their supporters seem to value qualities in candidates that complement, rather than mirror, their own.
And just as Mr. Buttigieg and Senator Sanders are decades apart, so are many of their supporters.
Mr. Sanders鈥� 2016 primary campaign famously saw the rise of 鈥�,鈥� the passionate young supporters who #FeeltheBern and are once again fueling the almost-octogenarian鈥檚 candidacy. Meanwhile, grandparents such as Ms. McCue are flocking to Mr. Buttigieg鈥檚 campaign.听
Much of it has to do with ideology. The bold policies and uncompromising style of Mr. Sanders, a democratic socialist, are in line with the views of many young people today, who lean further left than their elders. Mr. Buttigieg, by contrast, has tried to define himself as a more centrist figure, and projects a calm thoughtfulness on the stump that older voters say they appreciate.
At the same time, many specifically point to qualities in candidates that complement 鈥� rather than mirror 鈥� their own.听Young voters praise Mr. Sanders鈥� life experience and time-tested commitment to ideals, and are less concerned about his health and stamina, despite his heart attack this fall. Older voters wax enthusiastic about Mr. Buttigieg鈥檚 youthful vigor and dazzling intellect and aren鈥檛 as worried about his relatively short r茅sum茅.听
鈥淵ou might think people my age would automatically choose someone our age, but I feel like we are ready for a new generation to lead,鈥� says Ms. McCue. 鈥淗is age is not a problem for me 鈥� it鈥檚 an asset. There is this idea for fresh, new hope coming from him.鈥澛�
鈥淲e need a uniter鈥�
Many Buttigieg supporters 鈥� like Linda and Bob Ofner, both retirees 鈥� point out that his youth means he has skin in the game. Compared to the 鈥渙ld men鈥� in Washington, Mr. Buttigieg will actually be alive long enough to feel the long-term effects of his policies, says Ms. Ofner from her kitchen table in Bettendorf, Iowa, as the couple鈥檚 two dachshunds bark to be held.
Most important, she adds, Mr. Buttigieg understands that the country needs to stop fighting and come together.听鈥淢ore than anything we need a uniter,鈥� says Ms. Ofner. 鈥淚 think a lot of boomers feel that way.鈥澛�
Nestled between Christmas pillows in her living room in Iowa City, Ms. McCue expresses disappointment that she would have to miss an event with Mr. Buttigieg because it coincided with her oldest granddaughter鈥檚 fourth birthday, and 鈥淣ana鈥� had promised to be there.
She, too, highlights his ability to bring people together, suggesting it comes from a willingness to admit when he is wrong. That kind of humility and open-minded approach to problem-solving is 鈥渞efreshing鈥� in a politician, she says, and reminds her of her years as a teacher, when she encouraged her students to act in a similar way.听聽
鈥淗e鈥檚 how you hope all young men will grow up to be: truthful, trustworthy, responsible, no put-downs,鈥� says Ms. Ofner. 鈥淎t one of his first events people were saying, like, 鈥極h, I wish he were older, I wish this, I wish that鈥� 鈥� but then by the time he was done talking, everyone was cheering and crying.鈥�
A Civiqs and Iowa State University聽聽of likely Democratic caucus attendees found that 25% over the age of 65 say they will back the young mayor 鈥� more than any other Democratic candidate 鈥撀爓hile Mr. Buttigieg鈥檚 lowest levels of support are among those between the ages of 18 and 29.
The opposite is true for Mr. Sanders. The poll found that 35% of young Iowa Democrats say they鈥檒l support the Vermont senator 鈥� more than any other candidate 鈥� while just 9% of the oldest cohort favor him.
For most of these voters, the candidates鈥� main selling points are their policies, says Stella Rouse, an associate professor of politics at the University of Maryland.听鈥淭his whole idea of, 鈥榃e want someone from our generation to represent us,鈥� is overblown and over-simplistic,鈥� she says. 鈥淢illennials see [Sanders鈥橾 energy and his politics, and they are drawn to that. There is a huge cross-generational appeal.鈥�
Millennials and the appeal of socialism
Mr. Buttigieg casts himself , which baby boomers like Ms. McCue and the Ofners see as a good thing. They miss the 鈥渙ld days鈥� when compromise was still possible in Washington. They also oppose 鈥渇ree everything,鈥� which they believe other Democratic candidates are promising. The candidate who comes in second place with this age group, Mr. Biden, holds similar positions on these issues and is selling himself as able to win over moderates and anti-Trump Republicans, as well as those who feel nostalgic for a past America.听
Conversely, Mr. Sanders calls for a 鈥�21st-century economic Bill of Rights,鈥� a reassessment of the country鈥檚 vast income inequality, free college, and 鈥淢edicare for All.鈥� These proposals resonate with America鈥檚 youth, says Ms. Rouse, co-author of 鈥淭he Politics of Millennials.鈥� Having come of age in the shadow of the 2008 economic crisis, millennials now find themselves the best-educated generation in American history 鈥� and the worst paid.听
础听聽found that 51% of Americans between the ages of 18 and 29 have a positive view of socialism (the largest percentage of any age group), while just 45% have a positive view of capitalism (the smallest percentage of any age group).听
Waving a Bernie poster outside the New Hampshire Democratic Party state convention earlier this fall in Manchester, a cat ears headband adorning her pink hair, Alycia Tsoukalas says Mr. Sanders鈥� age doesn鈥檛 matter to her.听
鈥淗e鈥檚 for a $15 minimum wage, health insurance, LGBT rights, free college tuition 鈥� I mean, I鈥檓 in my final year and I鈥檓 scared to graduate,鈥� says Ms. Tsoukalas, a New England College student who works at a tattoo shop. 鈥淚 think it鈥檚 one of the coolest things ever that he is one of the oldest candidates but he鈥檚 for us, the young people.鈥澛�
Indira Gonzalez and Alana Lamontagne, nursing assistants from Manchester and Pelham, New Hampshire, respectively, agree. They support Mr. Sanders because his proposals would make their lives tangibly better, they say, which makes it feel as if he really cares about them.
鈥淓rasing student debt. Like, if he can get rid of that, then that鈥檚 a lot of peace of mind for us,鈥� says Ms. Gonzalez. 鈥淗e鈥檚 the only one really rooting for college students and people our age.鈥�
When Ms. Tsoukalas does think about Mr. Sanders鈥� age, she says she sees it as a good thing. He actually participated in the civil rights movement, she notes, whereas she has only read about it.
Just as Ms. McCue appreciates Mr. Buttigieg鈥檚 having a personal stake in the future, Ms. Tsoukalas appreciates Mr. Sanders鈥� firsthand knowledge of the past.听
鈥淚t means he has more life experience,鈥� says Ms. Tsoukalas. 鈥淎ge is just a number.鈥�
