海角大神

Race and class: New York mayoral contest's battleground

Democrat Bill de Blasio says New York is 'a tale of two cities' separating rich and poor. Republican Joe Lhota says that's 'nothing more than class warfare 鈥 an attempt to divide the city.'

|
Kathy Willens/AP
New York City Democratic mayoral hopeful Bill de Blasio embraces his son Dante, left, daughter Chiara, second from left, and wife Chirlane McCray, right, at his election headquarters after polls closed in the city's primary election Tuesday, Sept. 10, 2013.

As the New York mayoral election turns the bend toward its final stretch run to the Nov. 5 general election, an explosive set of themes have begun to emerge: race and class warfare.

A little over a month ago, few might have predicted such a volatile contrast between the candidates who won this Tuesday鈥檚 primary.

But the dramatic and unexpected victory of Public Advocate Bill de Blasio, the most liberal of the primary candidates, has turned the general election into a highly-charged debate about the Democrat鈥檚聽relentless focus on the economic divisions within the city, as well as his front-and-center use of his biracial family in the campaign. (A fraction of votes remain to be tallied before he is likely declared the party鈥檚 official nominee.)

Mr. de Blasio, who put together a startlingly broad-based coalition of the city鈥檚 diverse patchwork of Democrats, has illustrated his policies with an effective use of a Dickensian reference to 鈥渁 tale of two cities鈥 鈥 a not-so-subtle reference to the famous novel about French peasants and aristocrats, which ends at the guillotine.

His opponent, Republican Joe Lhota, the former city transportation chief, called de Blasio鈥檚 campaign slogan 鈥渘othing more than class warfare 鈥 an attempt to divide the city鈥 during his victory speech Tuesday night.

And on Thursday, his first day campaigning as the official Republican nominee, Mr. Lhota again lashed out at de Blasio鈥檚 campaign leitmotif.

鈥淐alling it a tale of two cities, that level of invective has no place in any campaign, at all,鈥 he said at one of his stops. 鈥淚t divides people. What we really need to do is to work together and provide a solution, not separating people and then saying that the ends justify the means.鈥

Outgoing Mayor Michael Bloomberg, the main target of de Blasio鈥檚 withering attacks during the primary, also suggested last week that de Blasio鈥檚 campaign was rooted in class warfare, adding it was racist, too. Mr. Bloomberg was careful, however, to say he was not calling de Blasio himself a racist. The Democratic candidate, who is white, is married to the black writer and political activist Chirlane McCray.

Still, the mayor鈥檚 comments were widely criticized, and Lhota, too, distanced himself from Bloomberg鈥檚 comments. During Sunday鈥檚 Republican debate, he said, "I don't think Bill de Blasio is running a racially motivated campaign. However, I have said I do believe he's running a campaign based on class warfare.鈥

Most observers pinpoint the moment the de Blasio phenomenon took off: when it released a , featuring the candidate鈥檚 son, Dante, who wears his hair in a striking Afro style.

He coyly listed the candidate鈥檚 policy positions, telling viewers Bill de Blasio was the only one with 鈥渢he guts to break from the Bloomberg years,鈥 including raising taxes on the rich to fund education and ending the 鈥渟top-and-frisk era that unfairly targets people of color.鈥 At the end of the commercial, Dante finally reveals the candidate is his dad.

鈥淚n one week at the beginning of August, Bill de Blasio came from far behind to being the frontrunner in this race, by coming out with one good TV ad that simultaneously introduced him, introduced his values, and introduced the issues that he was going to run on,鈥 says Bart Robbett, president of the Greater NYC Chapter of the American Association of Political Consultants.

Yet, apart from the current public advocate鈥檚 striking multicultural family, racially-charged issues have played a large role in the Democratic primary 鈥 and Democrats comprise six of seven registered voters in this city with more than 8 million residents.

鈥淎s much as Lhota may prefer to avoid the issue of race in this election, it is unlikely he'll be able to do that,鈥 e-mails Jeanne Zaino, professor of political campaign management at the New York University School of Continuing and Professional Studies. 鈥淭his is due in part to the type of campaign de Blasio is likely to run, but also to outside factors, such as the stop, question and frisk and Trayvon Martin cases.鈥

But the Lhota campaign is already actively courting support and funding from the city鈥檚 wealthy Wall Street class, some of whom have described the prospect of a Mayor de Blasio 鈥渢errifying.鈥 Many believe Lhota is the only hope to continue the business-friendly policies of the Bloomberg administration.

鈥淚n terms of broader themes, I think we will get not just a referendum on the Bloomberg era, but a referendum on the Dinkins era as well,鈥 e-mails Ms. Zaino, referring to former Mayor David Dinkins.

Indeed, Lhota has been rhetorically asking whether voters really want to go back to the time during the tenure of the city鈥檚 only black mayor 鈥 when de Blasio began his career in politics as a volunteer coordinator and aide in City Hall.

鈥淚n contrast, De Blasio will continue to critique the Bloomberg era and ask whether voters want to move forward with the New York City of [former mayor Rudy] Giuliani and Bloomberg,鈥 e-mails Zaino. 聽聽

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Race and class: New York mayoral contest's battleground
Read this article in
/USA/Politics/2013/0912/Race-and-class-New-York-mayoral-contest-s-battleground
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe