海角大神

Fort Hood trial: Nidal Hasan rests his defense with no witnesses, no testimony

The court-martial for Maj. Nidal Hasan, accused of killing 13 fellow soldiers at Fort Hood in 2009, is now headed for closing arguments, the eventual verdict, and, if he鈥檚 found guilty, sentencing.

|
Brigitte Woosley/AP
In this court room sketch, Judge Col. Tara Osborn, top, Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan (r.) and defense attorney, Lt. Col. Kris Poppe are shown, Aug. 21, in Fort Hood, Texas.

Maj. Nidal Hasan, an Army psychiatrist whom the US military says killed 13 fellow soldiers in a brutal attack at Fort Hood, Texas, on Nov. 5, 2009, offered no defense in his defense on Wednesday, in essence displaying a willingness to die as a martyr for the cause of radical Islam.

The 12th day of Hasan鈥檚 court-martial inside a heavily fortified compound in Killeen, Texas, ended early Wednesday, as a much-anticipated statement from Hasan became a three-word anticlimax: 鈥淭he defense rests.鈥 The Army major, who is representing himself, had called no witnesses to the stand, and he also declined to testify himself.

The judge, Col. Tara Osborn, quickly ended the day鈥檚 session, setting the stage for closing arguments, the eventual verdict, and, if he鈥檚 found guilty, sentencing.

The trial was expected to take months, but Hasan barely spoke as military prosecutors put five dozen witnesses on the stand. Those witnesses included many soldiers who were there the day the prosecution says that Hasan, yelling 鈥淎llah is great鈥 in Arabic, fired at least 200 shots into a crowded soldier readiness center.

Like Hasan, the soldiers were getting ready for deployment to Afghanistan and Iraq. Hasan鈥檚 only stated defense, which was not allowed by the judge, was that he acted in defense of Islamic soldiers, the Taliban. He later said in court that he 鈥渟witched sides鈥 in the war on terror.

Terror-law experts have anticipated some kind of outburst from Hasan, who said in his opening statement that the evidence will show 鈥淚 am the shooter.鈥 That phrase helped prompt his appointed attorneys to demand to be removed from the case, because they couldn鈥檛, in good moral conscience, support a defendant with a death wish. (Even though Hasan is representing himself, he still has attorneys on the sidelines.)

The Army is seeking to execute Hasan if he is found guilty by a jury of higher-ranking officers. Hasan had told investigators that he will be a martyr even if the Army executes him, according to a 2010 Army report that was released last week.

Some law professors have speculated that Hasan鈥檚 lack of a defense is in itself a defense: Those who sentence him may not be willing to give him what he purportedly wants.

Hasan may still 鈥渓ay out his case, say he鈥檚 justified in what he did, that he would do it again, and that he welcomes death,鈥 says Jeffrey Addicott, a conservative terrorism law expert at St. Mary鈥檚 University in San Antonio. 鈥淭he jury may then be saying, 鈥楲et鈥檚 not give him what he wants,鈥 almost like reverse psychology. He may avoid the death penalty by seeking the death penalty.鈥

An alternative is a life sentence at the US Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth, Kan.

Hasan will have more opportunities to speak, including in any potential sentencing phase. Former Army judge advocate Geoffrey Corn, a law professor at South Texas College of Law in Houston, tells USA Today that Hasan鈥檚 passive strategy marks a defendant wanting to get on to sentencing, where he may be more able to voice his opinions and use the trial as 鈥渁 soapbox.鈥

The stakes are certainly high. For one, the trial marks the resolution of arguably the first major terrorist attack on US soil since 9/11 鈥 one that happened on President Obama鈥檚 watch. (The Pentagon, however, has officially classified the incident as workplace violence.)

Also, the Army hasn鈥檛 executed a US soldier since 1961, despite 16 capital convictions in the past 50 years. Of those death sentences, only three people remain on the military鈥檚 version of death row at Fort Leavenworth. The death sentences for the others were all overturned in various ways.

Fully aware of that poor capital-case record, the military justice system has allowed Hasan broad leeway throughout the process to thwart appeals. It鈥檚 allowed him to keep his beard, for example, against Army regulations, and let him defend himself, which opened the possibility of him cross-examining the same people he allegedly tried to kill in 2009.

Even one of the most controversial aspects of the government鈥檚 treatment of Hasan 鈥 the classification as workplace violence 鈥 is rooted, according to a Pentagon memo, in a desire by the government to not wreck the fairness of the trial by preemptively declaring him a terrorist.

As things turned out, Hasan questioned the testimony of those who were there in 2009 barely at all. One witness, Staff Sgt. Juan Alvarado, testified on Monday that he saw Hasan try to shoot a police officer, Sgt. Kimberly Munley, even after she鈥檇 been shot and was disarmed. 鈥淎re you saying it was clear that she was disarmed, that I continued to fire at her?鈥 Hasan asked, to which Alvarado replied, 鈥淵es.鈥

Given that he declined to take the opportunity to defend himself in front of the jury on Wednesday, that short exchange on Monday, so far, has been arguably Hasan鈥檚 best attempt at a defense 鈥 that he honorably killed soldiers he considered deadly enemies.

Other witnesses testified that Hasan appeared to avoid shooting at civilians, and prosecutors agreed, saying he had bought laser sights so as to better target only soldiers.

鈥淭he only person that鈥檚 important in his mind is, 鈥楬ow does Allah view what I鈥檓 doing?鈥欌 Mr. Addicott says. 鈥淗e can鈥檛 look in the mirror and say, 鈥業 murdered my fellow soldiers.鈥 He can鈥檛 admit that. He has to stick with the playbook, which is that, 鈥業鈥檓 doing this not because I deserve to be punished; I am steering this course because I deserve to go to paradise.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Fort Hood trial: Nidal Hasan rests his defense with no witnesses, no testimony
Read this article in
/USA/Justice/2013/0821/Fort-Hood-trial-Nidal-Hasan-rests-his-defense-with-no-witnesses-no-testimony
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe