海角大神

NATO summit: Pugnacious Putin provides new purpose for alliance

By invading a neighboring country, Putin has reminded Europe and the Atlantic Alliance that NATO's original purpose 鈥 underpinning security and stability in Europe 鈥 is still necessary.

|
Alexei Nikolsky/Presidential Press Service/ RIA Novosti/AP
Russian President Vladimir Putin waves after a wreath laying ceremony at the monument to Soviet Marshal Georgy Zhukov in Ulan Bator, Mongolia, Wednesday, Sept. 3, 2014.

After a decade of NATO hand-wringing, deep thinks about the Atlantic Alliance鈥檚 purpose in a peaceful Europe, and experimenting with 鈥渙ut-of-area鈥 missions like Afghanistan, the organization that anchored the United States in postwar Europe once again seems confident about its 21st century existence.

That restored sense of purpose 鈥 which just six months ago seemed too much to hope for at this week鈥檚 NATO summit in Wales 鈥 can be attributed to no Alliance leader or far-flung mission, transatlantic experts say, but to Vladimir Putin.

By sending its troops over an internationally recognized border and annexing a piece of a neighboring country, Mr. Putin鈥檚 Russia has reminded Europe and the 28-member Alliance that NATO鈥檚 original purpose 鈥 underpinning security and stability in Europe 鈥 is still necessary.

鈥淚n some ways, NATO should thank Vladimir Putin because it was really searching for its purpose, post-[Afghanistan], and it was having a fairly significant identity crisis as people were looking toward the [Wales] summit nine, 12 months ago,鈥 says Heather Conley, director of the Europe Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. 鈥淚t has now not only been repurposed,鈥 she adds, 鈥渋t鈥檚 been reinvigorated.鈥

NATO leaders will still take up Afghanistan 鈥 in particular they will discuss how to pay the $5 billion bill to keep Afghanistan鈥檚 NATO-trained security forces operational for the coming years, and how much training and other assistance to provide after NATO鈥檚 security mission ends in December.

But what was once at the top of the agenda has receded several notches as Russia鈥檚 actions in Ukraine and the strong jitters they have sent pulsing through NATO鈥檚 former Soviet bloc members have moved to center stage.

鈥淣o one predicted that a portion of Europe would be annexed in 2014, that we would basically 鈥 have war between Russia and Ukraine,鈥 Ms. Conley says. 鈥淚 think it鈥檚 time we begin to state very clearly what this is,鈥 she adds, 鈥渁nd it has now required NATO to really adapt and change fairly dramatically.鈥

That adapting is being forced on the Alliance by the spectacle of a Russian triumph in eastern Ukraine even as the NATO summit unfolds.

Opening the summit Thursday, British Prime Minister David Cameron minced no words, declaring that 鈥淩ussian troops are illegally in Ukraine,鈥 despite official Russian insistence to the contrary.聽

NATO leaders were set to hold a meeting Thursday with Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko, the only non-NATO leader invited to the summit. Briefing leaders on a Russia-proposed cease-fire plan for eastern Ukraine, Mr. Poroshenko said he would order a start of a cease-fire on Friday provided that a planned international meeting on the conflict also proceeds on Friday.聽

The plan would freeze the fighting, a Poroshenko goal, but with pro-Russian rebels holding the territory they鈥檝e taken with Russian assistance 鈥 a clear defeat for the Ukrainian government.

With Russia鈥檚 expansionist maneuvers overshadowing their summit, NATO leaders are considering creation of a rapid-reaction force to defend threatened NATO members from outside aggression, and positioning more NATO assets in countries bordering Russia and feeling most threatened by it, such as the Baltic states and Poland.

But not all of NATO鈥檚 28 members agree on the degree of the Russian threat, with some governments concerned that any overly assertive action on Russia鈥檚 borders would prompt Moscow to reciprocate and thus set in motion a dangerous spiral.

NATO is expected to approve more extensive positioning of Alliance military assets in the 鈥渇rontline鈥 Baltic states and Poland, but they are expected to be labeled rotating assets to avoid conflicting with a 1997 agreement with Russia that no 鈥減ermanent鈥 military installations would be positioned in countries bordering Russia.

But even that step was nowhere on NATO鈥檚 agenda just a few months ago, and can be attributed to events in Ukraine. A 鈥減ersistent鈥 NATO presence in the Baltic states and Poland 鈥渨as never envisioned and would never have been part of the calculation were it not for Vladimir Putin鈥檚 actions,鈥 Conley says.

Also anticipated to cause heated debate at the Wales summit is the issue of NATO arming nonmember states 鈥 including Ukraine. So far Alliance members including the US have stuck to providing the Ukrainian military with nonlethal material and some intelligence support.

Speculation was growing Thursday that the US would announce some provision of defensive weaponry to Ukraine. But there are indications that even some minimal show of support for non-NATO militaries would not be well-viewed by Alliance publics.

A new Transatlantic Trends survey by the German Marshall Fund finds that while a slim majority of Americans supports arming and training non-NATO militaries like Ukraine鈥檚, an almost identical percentage of Europeans opposes such action.

One reason for that public reluctance is a desire to avoid antagonizing Russia, some foreign policy analysts say. And indeed, even the discussion of increased Alliance assistance to Ukraine was already prompting reactions from Moscow.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said in Moscow that any steps altering Ukraine鈥檚 鈥渘eutral鈥 status would pose a serious threat to regional security and prompt a Russian response.

Responding to President Obama鈥檚 insistence Wednesday that NATO鈥檚 door remains open to countries that meet Alliance standards, including democratic governance, Mr. Lavrov accused the US of choosing the 鈥減arty of war鈥 in Ukraine.

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to NATO summit: Pugnacious Putin provides new purpose for alliance
Read this article in
/USA/Foreign-Policy/2014/0904/NATO-summit-Pugnacious-Putin-provides-new-purpose-for-alliance
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe