They came to the US for degrees. They fear being deported without them.
| Boston
They all have seen the video: R眉meysa 脰zt眉rk, a Tufts University doctoral student from Turkey, being snatched from a street in Somerville, Massachusetts, by masked undercover Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents.
International students interviewed say that Ms. 脰zt眉rk鈥檚 arrest has deeply unnerved them and their friends studying in the United States. Some have lost sleep. They have cried together. Many worry that they could be handcuffed next, and whisked off to jail or back to their home country without the degrees they came here for.
鈥淲e are in survival mode right now,鈥� says a Chinese doctoral student from a Boston-area university, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he is here on a student visa.
Why We Wrote This
鈥淲e are in survival mode,鈥� international students say of navigating a new landscape under the Trump administration. The arrest of a Tufts University doctoral student by undercover agents has had a chilling effect.
Professors and friends have told him to stay away from all protests 鈥� including one at a Tesla dealership, which he attended 鈥� and advised him not to travel back home. He asked for an adviser鈥檚 cellphone number and shared it with friends, in case anything happens to him.
鈥淭his is [taking] a big emotional toll,鈥� says the student. 鈥淭here are a lot of fellow students around me. We cried together many times because of this situation. It was just very cruel.鈥�
Several hundred students at colleges and universities in the United States have had their student visas revoked 鈥� including at Stanford; UCLA; the University of California, Berkeley; and other California campuses. An unknown number have been detained over the past month. Trump administration authorities say the visa revocations are for foreign policy reasons, including a portion sparked by pro-Palestinian protests across campuses. So far, the revocations represent just a fraction of the more than 1 million foreign students who study in the United States annually 鈥� most of whom pay full sticker price for an American higher education.
鈥淚f the United States government has national security concerns regarding a student and they feel that their visa should be revoked, they are within their rights to do that. But we are really trying to understand, in this new environment, what does that mean? What are these students doing that is triggering a national security concern?鈥� says Sarah Spreitzer, assistant vice president at the American Council on Education, which advocates for 1,600 colleges and universities.
Most international college students hold F-1 visas and are allowed to enroll as full-time students. They are allowed to travel in and out of the country, and enjoy most constitutional rights. They cannot vote or receive federal financial aid or other government benefits.
International students have brought a financial boon to both universities and the overall U.S. economy. In a 2023-2024 school year , 1.1 million international students added $43.8 billion to the economy and supported 378,175 jobs, the NAFSA Association of International Educators found. That was up from $26 billion a decade ago. Ms. Spreitzer is concerned that current policies could send students and researchers looking for berths in Canada or Europe instead.
How things have changed since March 8
The new climate for international students began March 8, when Mahmoud Khalil, a Palestinian graduate student at Columbia University and a green card holder, was detained near his school. Mr. Khalil had participated in rallies and sit-ins at Columbia and did on-camera interviews in support of Palestinians. His voice was a standout during campus upheaval over the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza. He was arrested in Manhattan, transferred to New Jersey, and then flown to a facility in Louisiana, where he currently remains while his court case plays out.
Other students, including Ms. 脰zt眉rk, are being held in the same facility.
On April 4, a judge ordered her case moved to Vermont. A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson has said that Ms. 脰zt眉rk engaged in activities in support of Hamas, which the U.S. government designates as a foreign terrorist organization. Specific evidence has not been released by the government. Many reports have mentioned an op-ed Ms. 脰zt眉rk co-authored criticizing the university鈥檚 response to the war in Gaza, but it is unclear whether that played a role in her detainment.
Badar Khan Suri, an Indian national postdoctoral fellow at Georgetown University, was taken into custody at his Virginia home before being transferred to Louisiana. A few international students whose visas were revoked, such as Cornell University鈥檚 Momodou Taal, have chosen to leave the country rather than risk incarceration and deportation.
At a late March press conference, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said have been revoked, though he added that the number 鈥渕ight be more, because we鈥檙e doing them every day,鈥� and was a combination of student and visitor visas.
鈥淲e gave you a visa to come and study and get a degree, not to become a social activist that tears up our university campuses,鈥� Mr. Rubio told reporters.
The state has the power to revoke student visas, all interviewed agree, but institutions are wanting to know the new rules so that they can help students navigate.
鈥淲e are very concerned about the fear that this is causing for our students, but then also trying to figure out how best our institutions can advise these students,鈥� says Ms. Spreitzer.
Her office doesn鈥檛 have an official number of how many students have been affected. Schools are not being reliably informed, she says 鈥� either about revoked visas or new initiatives such as consulates being instructed to search profiles of students applying for visas. She is bracing for additional changes, such as travel bans for international students and rule changes to the student visa program. Students aren鈥檛 clear on how or whether they can dispute claims about social media posts that threaten national security, she says. In some cases, there isn鈥檛 proof the student wrote messages being used against them.
鈥淭his is no longer a foreign-policy issue, this is no longer an issue of a war in a far-off land. This a question of what we鈥檝e been told all our lives are American values.听Because those are the things being torn away right now,鈥� says Hassan Kamal Wattoo, a Pakistani student at UC Berkeley School of Law who practiced law in his home country and clerked for its Supreme Court. 鈥淚t鈥檚 not just about us [foreign students] anymore, because it doesn鈥檛 stop with us. ... When you set a precedent of taking away individual freedoms from one segment of society, it鈥檚 inevitable that this will expand to others.鈥�
Mr. Wattoo says that he was born in a dictatorship and lived under military rule in which people were afraid to cross invisible lines of speech. 鈥淚鈥檝e seen this film before, and America is feeling really close to home these days,鈥� he says of Ms. 脰zt眉rk鈥檚 and others鈥� arrests. 鈥淭he general populace would be scared into silence. And that鈥檚 the same thing we鈥檙e seeing now. Like writing an op-ed can get you arrested, deported.鈥�
Is 鈥渄efend American values鈥� controversial?
The Student Press Law Center released a statement after Ms. 脰zt眉rk鈥檚 arrest, defending the tradition of debate generated by the opinion pages of student newspapers. 鈥淭he First Amendment is an asset, not an inconvenience,鈥� the statement read.
鈥淚鈥檝e read that [the Trump administration] said we can鈥檛 have these people disrupting campuses. Well, did Tufts complain to anybody? I mean isn鈥檛 it Tufts鈥� decision to say whether R眉meysa鈥檚 disruptive or not? Why does the federal government come in and decide that she鈥檚 been disruptive?鈥� asks Larry Feig, a professor of molecular and chemical biology at Tufts University School of Medicine.
Dr. Feig, who is Jewish, says he thinks deportations for people speaking out against the war is weaponizing the charge of antisemitism.
鈥淚 don鈥檛 think Trump gives a [darn] about antisemitism, and I think he just used this as a tool,鈥� says Dr. Feig.
Nathan Wolff, an associate professor of English at Tufts, who is also Jewish, agrees. Dr. Wolff says he believes Jewish people at Tufts have a moral responsibility to speak out and say that the actions taken by the government are not in their name and that they don鈥檛 condone the crackdowns.
鈥淩ight now, the main thing that I鈥檓 hearing is that, understandably, all international students and all students are deeply scared,鈥� Dr. Wolff says. It鈥檚 difficult to advise students on what rights they have or if their visas are in danger, he adds.
Meanwhile, the Boston-area Ph.D. student says he and his friends communicate daily. He is worried about multiple political social media posts he鈥檚 made that he thinks are too late to delete. He was planning to visit his parents in China, since he hasn鈥檛 been back in five years, but professors have told him not to even visit Boston鈥檚 Logan International Airport.
鈥淚 feel like now, a lot of people can鈥檛 see hope in the future, including myself,鈥� he says.
Mr. Wattoo also describes himself as disillusioned. When asked about a potential need for anonymity by a reporter, he responds, 鈥淎ll I am saying right now is to defend what we鈥檝e been told all our lives are American values. Free speech. Due process.听Should that be a controversial statement in America?鈥�
鈥淚f America has reached the point where saying 鈥業 support the First Amendment,听and I do not want the people I disagree with to be arrested鈥櫶齣s enough to have a very legitimate risk of me getting deported, that鈥檚 dystopian,鈥� he continues.
When asked if there鈥檚 anything that gives him hope, he pauses.
鈥淭he people maybe. I鈥檝e seen a lot of people who have been willing to, at great risk to themselves, speak up for what they think is right. And that has given me hope,鈥� he says. 鈥淏ut I don鈥檛 know if it鈥檚 enough. I don鈥檛 know if there are enough people听willing to speak up.鈥�
A Monitor correspondent contributed to this report.
