海角大神

Pope's gender comments underscore uneasy fit with partisan politics

Many of the pope's gestures have momentarily thrilled progressives and angered conservatives. But others have left liberals disappointed, highlighting his unique role in political debates.

|
Luca Zennaro/Pool Photo via AP
Pope Francis speaks with journalists on board the flight from Baku to Rome on Sunday, Oct. 2, 2016.

Pope Francis said that gender theory was being taught in schools, and called it evidence of "ideological colonization" on Sunday,听reiterating earlier comments in which he condemned as "terrible" the idea that schools should educate children on the topic.听

In conversation with reporters accompanying him on a flight home from Azerbaijan, the pope recounted a conversation with a French man who lamented that his 10-year-old son wanted to be 鈥渁 girl鈥 when he grew up.听

鈥淭he father realized that at school they were teaching him gender theory, and this is against the natural things,鈥 the pontiff said, . 鈥淥ne thing is that a person has this tendency, this condition and even changes their sex, but it's another thing to teach this in schools in order to change the mentality.鈥

Such sentiments have tempered the excitement of social progressives who seemed to in the pope鈥檚 earlier, socially liberal pronouncements on shibboleths like homosexuality and divorce. And some commentators from those spheres have since urged readers , pointing to Francis鈥 refusal to decree changes to traditional Church doctrine on those topics, as well as his public battles with Argentina鈥檚 leaders over the 2010 legalization of gay marriage 鈥 a proposal he called a

But the larger point may be the difficulty听of sussing out how the pope believes universal tenets should be turned into local policy 鈥 even if the pope has undeniably tried to stoke the Church鈥檚 influence as a shaper of governments鈥 policy, from calling on Europe to "tear down" walls and accept refugees, to giving his blessing to deals struck between the US and rivals like Iran and Cuba.

One of the problems about being pope, says Francis Clooney, professor at Harvard Divinity School and director of the Center for the Study of World Religions, is the immensely diverse set of political situations with which a pontiff鈥檚 words carry weight.

鈥淚f he says something that seems to fit in New York, people in Nigeria are going to be saying that he鈥檚 not in fidelity with the teachings of the church 鈥 and vice versa,鈥 Dr. Clooney tells 海角大神.听

Francis鈥 earlier gestures of liberal-mindedness听on issues of gender and sexuality may be more of a reflection of his ideas about how pastors should lead their flock 鈥 less by censure and rebuke than by a gentler breed of guidance, an approach that goes back to his days as a bishop who became a familiar face in Buenos Aires slums.听

And his expressions of displeasure with the teaching of gender theory 鈥 a term that could encompass a vast realm of often-competing ideas about how gender is expressed and constructed听鈥 connects to his broader criticisms of global policies, in which Francis has suggested that wealthier, often more liberal countries'听economic heft can force secular attitudes on poorer ones. The pope, notes Reuters, has previously described as 听鈥溾 attempts from rich-country donors to tie development aid to liberal social policies.

The pope鈥檚 identity as a political figure may more closely resemble that of an arbiter of what governments should prioritize and what they should leave to be sorted out by the individual 鈥 , in an article defending the notion that Francis could be regarded as a 鈥渓iberal pontiff鈥.

鈥淸W]hat makes Francis different is really a matter of which Catholic beliefs he has elevated to the level of communal concerns 鈥 public policy 鈥 and which he has framed as individual choices,鈥 wrote the Atlantic's Molly Ball. 鈥淭o Francis, sharing wealth and fixing global warming are matters that governments should address, while not committing homosexual acts or having abortions are individual choices he endorses. (As he famously put it: 鈥淲ho am I to judge?鈥) This is quite different from the American Catholic church, which has poured its political energy into laws banning gay marriage and restricting abortion.鈥

The pope鈥檚 conservatism, then, might consist most crucially of all in what he 丑补蝉苍鈥檛 done.

鈥淗e鈥檚 the pope. He could change these teachings,鈥 says Clooney. 鈥淗e could announce that married men can be ordained, or that divorced and remarried Catholics be welcomed back to communion. He鈥檚 not living in a place where doctrine is set and won鈥檛 be interpreted.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Pope's gender comments underscore uneasy fit with partisan politics
Read this article in
/USA/2016/1005/Pope-s-gender-comments-underscore-uneasy-fit-with-partisan-politics
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe