Tips for making the best chocolate chip cookie
Heads up that I鈥檓 about to start a series of posts on different chocolate chip cookie recipes. I hadn鈥檛 started out with this series in mind. Instead, I had made a couple of different recipes at different times just to try them. And since I鈥檓 always behind on blogging, I鈥檝e had them for some time.
Then one weekend, my niece had asked if I could make chocolate chip cookies for her coworkers. She needed three dozen and most of the recipes I had pinned on my Pinterest board made anywhere from 12-18 cookies so I figured it would be a good chance to try out several cookie recipes at once. Which then led me to wonder about the differences between the recipes and how that would alter the texture or taste of any of them. It was the closest thing to 鈥渟cientific testing鈥� I was likely to do but this was something that has always been nagging at me (insert first world problem here).
Why were there so many variations and what really changed between them? Why was one cookie better than another? What made it so? What really constituted 鈥渂etter鈥�? How could varying different proportions of what are essentially the same base ingredients really changing the cookies? How do different ways to mix together cookie dough change the cookies themselves that much? So many questions, so many recipes to try.
I already had two by default before I even embarked on this, er, quest. Baking for my niece added another four kinds. And I added more from there.
Before I unveil them 鈥� and you know it鈥檒l be a protracted process with all of these different recipes 鈥� I鈥檒l give you a sneak preview of what I鈥檝e tried. First, let鈥檚 be clear. There鈥檚 never a bad chocolate chip cookie. Not the way I make them, says me immodestly. Second, regardless of the ingredients list, I have my own process for mixing cookie dough and baking cookies that has stood me in good stead through the years and countless cookie recipes. I will be sharing those so you, too, can make amazing, pack-the-pounds-on cookies that鈥檒l be worth those empty calories (let鈥檚 not kid ourselves). And third, remember, what鈥檚 鈥渢he best鈥� to one person may not be the best to another.
Just so you know, my criteria of what makes THE BEST chocolate chip cookies are they鈥檙e thick and chubby, loaded with milk chocolate chunks or chips (you can substitute semisweet if you鈥檙e not me), have crisp edges, chewy ooey gooey middles, and an amazing caramelized brown sugar flavor complemented by the melty goodness of (milk) chocolate chips/chunks. No nuts! If you like any of those things, read on, MacDuff. Loosen your belt, factor in extra workouts for the next few weeks, run an extra mile or five and kiss that bikini body goodbye.
Lastly, because there鈥檚 never a bad chocolate chip cookie (see above paragraph) but there are gradations of good cookies, rather than stack ranking each recipe by number, I鈥檓 going to group them into broader categories: good, great and best. Remember my picky scale? That means 鈥済ood鈥� to me is usually 鈥渢hese are delicious鈥� to most other people. 鈥淕reat鈥� to me = 鈥淥MG, these are amazing鈥� from others. My 鈥渂est鈥� means I had more than 1 cookie and other people鈥檚 reactions range from 鈥渢hat鈥檚 my favorite cookie ever鈥� to 鈥淚 hate you, I can鈥檛 fit into my clothes anymore, are there anymore cookies left?鈥�
To provide a little suspense, we鈥檒l start with the Good category, move to Great and end with Best. I encourage you to make your own experiments and decide where you鈥檇 put each cookie into which category.
Before we begin, here are my cookie tips for all of the recipes, no matter which one you try:
1. Use butter. If it isn鈥檛 butter, don鈥檛 bother. If you use margarine, I wash my hands of you. Really.
2. Milk chocolate chunks 鈥� I like to buy the Pound Plus bar from Trader Joe鈥檚, chop it up and use in ONE recipe. You can substitute semisweet if that鈥檚 what you prefer. I did have to use chocolate chips in some of the recipes out of necessity, meaning I didn鈥檛 have the TJ鈥檚 bar on hand when I made the dough,
3. Chill the dough. No matter what. Trust me. Portion into dough balls and chill, covered, in the refrigerator or put directly in freezer bags and put in the freezer. To develop the flavors the most, chill for 24 hours in the fridge, then, if you have the patience of a saint, put in the freezer for overnight then bake.
4. Substitute at least 1/4 cup of the granulated sugar with turbinado or raw cane sugar. It gives an extra crunch in the chewy texture of your cookie and makes them a little different. I didn鈥檛 do this with all of the cookies I tried but for the ones I did, I liked those cookies much better.
5. Use dark brown sugar, even if the recipe calls for light brown. Dark brown provides more caramelized brown sugar flavor.
Don鈥檛 bake at less than 350 degrees F. I often preheated the oven to 375 or even 400 degrees F., put the cookies in at 375 for a few minutes then lowered the heat to 350 or 360. This helps the cookies set faster before they spread too much. But I don't recommend baking the whole time at 375 or 400 or else the chips start to burn before your cookies are done. Ask me how I know.
6. Don鈥檛 overbake! Ever. Bake just until the edges are golden brown and the middles don鈥檛 look like raw melted dough. If the edges are already too brown and the middle still looks doughy, take them out anyway. Once they set, they鈥檒l still be okay.
7. Make the dough balls big, at least golf-ball size. This isn鈥檛 the time to be dainty.
8. Don鈥檛 bake too many at once. The beauty of making dough balls and freezing them is you can bake only as many as you need when you need them.
Related post on The Pastry Chef's Baking:
