海角大神

'Weinstein effect'? Exploring the link between power and predatory behavior.

Research shows that feeling powerful can incline some people toward impulsive, selfish behavior, findings that may explain the alleged behavior of Harvey Weinstein and others accused of sexually predatory behavior. 

|
Vince Bucci/Invision/AP/File
Harvey Weinstein arrives at the Oscars at the Dolby Theatre in Los Angeles in 2015. The New York Times and The New Yorker magazine have revealed allegations of sexual harassment and rape against the Hollywood producer going back decades.

鈥淚鈥檓 used to that,鈥 said Harvey Weinstein, in a telling moment, to the model Ambra Battilana Gutierrez.

It was March 2015, and Ms. Gutierrez was wearing a wire furnished by New York Police Department鈥檚 Special Victims Division, in a sexual abuse investigation of the Hollywood producer. As The New Yorker鈥檚 Ronan Farrow , Gutierrez asked Mr. Weinstein why, during a business meeting in his Tribeca office the previous day, he had lunged at her and groped her breasts. This was Weinstein's response: that he was used to it.

How does someone get used to committing sexual assault? While responsibility ultimately falls squarely on the perpetrator, experts say holding power can make it harder to control impulses and easier to justify selfishness, even to the point of disregarding other people鈥檚 humanity. The good news is that not everyone is influenced by power quite the same way, and that its effects can be mitigated with social equality.

鈥淪tatus and power can change the way people think and the way that they act,鈥 says Joe Vitriol, a postdoctoral researcher at Lehigh University in Pennsylvania who studies stereotyping and social cognition. 鈥淭hey perhaps are less concerned about the consequences of their behavior; they feel more entitled to resources.鈥

In extreme cases, power 鈥 defined as the ability to influence the world, particularly through social interaction 鈥 聽can fuel a sense of entitlement over other people's bodies and can smooth the path to sexual impropriety, or, as the cascade of revelations over the past month have shown, sexual assault.

鈥淢oney tends to create the context of the impulsive pursuit of sex,鈥 says Dacher Keltner, a psychologist at the University of California, Berkeley, who has studied power dynamics for two decades. 鈥淲ealthy people are more likely to have sexual affairs 鈥 they鈥檙e more likely to flirt inappropriately.鈥

This impulsive pursuit can include everything from , as journalist Mark Halperin admitted to last week, , as former president George H.W. Bush admitted to last week, to to women before having sex with them, as comedian Bill Cosby admitted to in 2005. And it can be prolific: on Saturday, actress Asia Argento who say they were victimized by Weinstein. For director James Toback, that number .

That said, people in positions of power can and do wield their power responsibly. Indeed, power typically flows to those who advance the greater good. But as a person rises higher in a social hierarchy, it can become more challenging to maintain a sense of kindness and empathy, a phenomenon that Keltner calls the .聽And social psychologists have repeatedly shown that power can often cloud people鈥檚 moral judgments. Understanding the way power can fuel harmful behavior can also help better mitigate its effects.

Lab experiments, surveys, and observational data reveal that the higher a person is on the socioeconomic ladder, the more likely he or she is , involving a cash prize, , and . On college campuses, male athletes, who tend to occupy the upper rungs of the campus social scene, are more likely to admit to . are more likely to cut off other motorists and blow through crosswalks with pedestrians waiting to cross. One experiment even found that rich people are actually more likely than poor people that had been set aside for children.

What's more, those who score high on a psychological measure that assesses a person鈥檚 likelihood of committing sexual harassment are more likely to unconsciously聽, which helps explain why many powerful men who make unwanted sexual advances seem surprised to learn that their actions are inappropriate. For those prone to sexual aggression, experts say, simply experiencing power can turn the mind to sex.

This association can lead powerful men to believe that sex is in the air, and that women are happy to be in their presence, an assertion that Keltner doubts. 鈥淥ur data are suggesting that it鈥檚 not necessarily thrilling and exhilarating, and it's more a source of anxiety and shame,鈥 says Keltner.

'Drunk' with power?

Like alcohol, power can have a disinhibiting effect, , increasing a person鈥檚 impulsivity, risk-taking behavior, and disregard for social conventions. Power can also interfere with the ability to pay attention to other people's emotions: Studies find that powerful people are less able to 鈥渞ead鈥 the faces of those around them.

Powerlessness, by contrast, inclines people to be more inhibited, more anxious and risk-averse, and more empathetic, although they more readily interpret ambiguous behavior as aggressive.

鈥淵ou鈥檙e sending out these signals of anxiety and fear, and regrettably powerful people don't pick them up, they don't discern that this person they're interacting with is worried or fearful about what might happen,鈥 says Keltner. 鈥淚 think a lot of problems ensue from that myopia.鈥

Power and powerlessness are not fixed traits: Indeed, they can be induced in a laboratory setting. In one experiment, known as the 鈥渃ookie monster鈥 study, Keltner and his colleagues gave groups of three people a group writing task, and randomly assigned one to a position of leadership. Thirty minutes into the task, the experimenter placed a plate of five cookies, allowing each subject to take one cookie and for at least one to comfortably take a second cookie, thus leaving one cookie on the plate for the three people.

Nearly every time, the leaders helped themselves to the final cookie. During the experiment, the researchers noticed that the leaders were more likely to chew with their mouths open, smack their lips, and let crumbs fall on their clothes.

In another experiment conducted in Keltner鈥檚 lab by psychologist Paul Piff, now a psychologist at the University of California, Irvine, subjects played a rigged game of Monopoly, in which one player, randomly selected with a coin toss, started the game with $2,000 and got to roll two dice, while the other player started with $1,000 and could roll only one die.

Within 15 minutes of play, the researchers observed changes in how the advantaged player behaved. They would speak more rudely, use dominant body language, slam their pieces on the board more loudly, and even hog a bowl of pretzels left out for the players.

After the advantaged player inevitably won, and the experimenters asked them about their experiences, they would attribute their success to their strategy in buying properties, not to the coin toss.

A just world?

鈥淲hat happens with people of status and privilege 鈥 earned or otherwise 鈥 is that, because they infer that they鈥檝e acquired that standing by virtue of characteristic qualities unique to them, while discounting the role of chance and situational factors or the presence of others,鈥 says Dr. Vitriol, 鈥渢hey believe that they鈥檙e entitled to the benefits that come with that social standing.鈥

Such rationalization is common. We are disposed to believe that the universe is basically fair, that smart, moral choices bring rewards and that unwise, wrongful actions invite trouble. At its best, this so-called just world hypothesis can give people a sense of control over their lives and can help them better accept negative events, experts say. At its worst, it can justify victim-blaming.

鈥淚t may be easier for some people to believe that women and victims of sexual violence and injustice are themselves to blame for these acts than to accept the possibility that we live in a chaotic, uncertain, and, at times, immoral world,鈥 says Vitriol. This thinking, he says, 鈥渄etracts 鈥 from perceiving the perpetrator as wholly responsible for leveraging their position of power and influence to exploit somebody in need.鈥

Reducing the potentially toxic effects of power will ultimately require making our hypothetically just world a reality. Take Hollywood. Even though women comprise 52 percent of moviegoers, among the top 100 grossing films of 2016, women made up聽聽and just 4 percent of directors. 鈥淚n really unequal situations where women don鈥檛 have power or money or authority within an organization there is more of this, 鈥業 have beauty and I鈥檒l trade it for wealth,鈥 鈥 says Keltner. But, he says, 鈥渨hen you move toward more egalitarian power structures with respect to gender, that doesn't work.鈥

And power does not affect everyone the same way. Power-holders who make an effort to take seriously the interests of the less powerful and link their power to socially responsible goals, as opposed to self-oriented ones, can use their power to

鈥淭his is not inevitable,鈥 says Dr. Keltner. 鈥淲hen you give really good people 鈥 nice people, kind people 鈥 power, they become kinder.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to 'Weinstein effect'? Exploring the link between power and predatory behavior.
Read this article in
/Science/2017/1030/Weinstein-effect-Exploring-the-link-between-power-and-predatory-behavior
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe