海角大神

How information overload helps spread fake news

Mathematical modeling of social networks reveals how misinformation finds its way to the top 鈥 and offers clues for how to dampen the spread of false information.

|
Jessica Gresko/AP/File
Flowers and notes left by well-wishers are displayed outside Comet Ping Pong, in December 2016. The Washington, D.C., pizza restaurant was the target of fake news stories linking it to a child sex trafficking ring.

A lie can travel halfway around the world, goes the well-known Mark Twain quote, before the truth can get its boots on.

Twain himself might have appreciated this quotation's self-reflexivity: There's of him ever having said or written it.

Today, with now turning to social media for news, many of us are getting misinformation 鈥 for instance, that , that a聽聽can survive on a 鈥渇ood-free lifestyle鈥澛犫 mixed in with the legitimate news articles in our feeds. And, as the news cycle accelerates, it's becoming harder to tell the difference.听

A new study reveals the mathematics underlying this phenomenon, modeling how information overload can erode an individual's ability to distinguish high-quality information from its opposite, causing falsehoods to propagate. But with a little effort, readers and social media platforms can cut the information surplus, perhaps sharpening our powers of discernment.听

鈥淥n a daily basis,鈥 says Daniel Levitin, a professor of psychology and behavioral neuroscience at McGill University in Montreal, 鈥渢he onslaught of information is preventing us from being evidence-based decision makers, at our own peril.鈥澛

Misinformation is as old as culture itself, and the phenomenon uncovered in this study shows its spread is not limited to one kind of social media.听

鈥淢any arguments around gossip and rumors are really driven by the same social mechanisms,鈥 says Brian Uzzi, the co-director of Northwestern University's Institute on Complex Systems in Evanston, Ill. 鈥淭he internet has essentially turbocharged the inclination of human beings to behave this way in regard to news and facts.鈥澛

A paper published Monday in the journal Nature Human Behaviour by an international team of researchers offers a mathematical model that demonstrates that, as information load increases, so do the odds that .听

鈥淚t was the first paper I've seen in this area that quantifies what many people thought was happening, and that's basically with limited attention we're unable to see the full range of potential arguments or sides of the story,鈥 says Dr. Uzzi, who has studied how social media users isolate themselves into echo chambers.听

Losing ability to tell fact from fiction

Using mathematical modeling, a team led by Xiaoyan Qiu and Diego Oliveira of Indiana University's Center for Complex Networks and Systems Research statistically confirmed that when flooded with a steady stream of high- and low-quality information, even the most critical readers start to lose their ability to tell fact from fiction.

鈥淓ven when individual users can recognize and select quality information,鈥 says study co-author Filippo Menczer, a professor of informatics and computer science at Indiana University, 鈥渢he social media market rarely allows the best information to win the popularity contest.鈥

The researchers suggest that social networks could curb information overload by aggressively limiting content shared by so-called bot accounts, software agents that flood social networks with low-quality information.听

鈥淒eceptive bots can be quite sophisticated and hard to recognize even for humans. And huge numbers of them can be managed via software, so it is difficult for operators to keep up,鈥 says Dr. Menczer.听

The research reveals some of the math that drives what psychologists have long known: Information overload makes it harder to make decisions. 鈥淭he key point of this article is what neuroscientists have been what showing on the biology side has very practical, real-world implications in our daily lives,鈥 says Dr. Levitin, the author of 鈥淲eaponized Lies: How to Think Critically in the Post-Truth Era.鈥

Fighting information overload

Levitin notes that the average American is exposed to about than in 1986. 鈥淚n the old days, I'd get the newspaper in the morning and I'd read about what happened yesterday,鈥 he says. 鈥淣ow, everyone seems to be addicted to what happened five minutes ago.鈥澛

Levitin recommends unplugging from the internet for a couple hours each morning and again each afternoon. 鈥淚f you're constantly checking your phone for the latest news, you're allowing your thoughts to become disrupted and fractionated and it becomes harder and harder to concentrate, and you get addicted to this constant stimulation,鈥 he says. 鈥淪o I think what we can do is give ourselves a break.鈥

But taking a break can be difficult for people who have become accustomed to steady social media contact with friends and family.鈥淭rouble arises when we use the same networks to access news,鈥澛爏ays Menczer,聽who advises against defriending or unfollowing those with different opinions, because echo chambers make users more susceptible to misinformation.

鈥淲e hope that by now, citizens and policymakers from across the political spectrum recognize the need for research to study digital misinformation and how to make the web more reliable,鈥 says Menczer. 鈥淲e are all vulnerable to manipulation irrespective of our political leanings.鈥

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to How information overload helps spread fake news
Read this article in
/Science/2017/0627/How-information-overload-helps-spread-fake-news
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe