海角大神

At its peak in the 13th century, the Mongol Empire covered more than 9 million square miles, ranking as the largest contiguous land empire聽ever recorded. But despite the Mongols鈥櫬爃istorical dominance, their future 鈥� at least in high school history classes 鈥� is notably less certain.聽聽

In late May, the College Board鈥檚 Advanced Placement (AP) program, which develops tests that offer college credit to high-performing high schoolers, announced changes to its World History exam. Advanced students typically spend their sophomore year preparing for the test in a class that covers 10,000 years of human history. But driven by teacher concerns over this tremendous breadth, the College Board has removed any content prior to the year AD 1450, starting in the 2019-2020 school year.

Since then, a chorus of protests from students and teachers has echoed across the country. One petition started by a ninth-grade AP World History student to reverse the change has amassed . The new exam, opponents argue, eliminates valuable opportunities to study non-Western cultures outside of the context of European influence. The stakes are highest, they say, for students of color 鈥� whose own cultural histories hang in the balance.

鈥淲hat gets lost if you start [studying history] at the European Renaissance is you miss the whole point that these African and Asian cultures develop a lot of that science and math that then influences Europe. As a black or brown student, you don鈥檛 learn that it was your cultures that figured that out,鈥� says Amanda DoAmaral, a former AP World History teacher and founder of Fiveable, an online AP prep startup.

鈥淧art of what we [try] to do is just really reflect our students in what we鈥檙e teaching. And I think that鈥檚 true for all students... You still have to be there in the curriculum somewhere,鈥� she says.

An unwieldy topic

The AP World History Development Committee has consistently seen disappointingly low and uneven test results on the national level, says Richard Warner, a history professor at Wabash College in Crawfordsville, Ind., and a committee member.

鈥淔rom the College Board鈥檚 perspective, the unwieldiness of 10,000 years of history argued for making it a modern history course so that they could handle it a little bit better,鈥� Dr. Warner says.

In a 2017 College Board survey of 1,243 AP World History teachers, 79 percent stated that 鈥渢here is too much required content to cover in one academic year.鈥�

But not all AP World History teachers agree with that assessment. And many see the wide scope of the course as an essential part of building frameworks of understanding across time periods and world regions, says Laura Mitchell, a history professor at the University of California, Irvine and a former AP World History test-development committee chair.

A week ago, Dr. Mitchell released signed by all former chief readers and test development committee chairs that advocates against the College Board鈥檚 decision.

And despite the concern over breadth, 88 percent of 888 AP World History instructors in a teacher-led survey conducted聽after news of the exam changes broke disagreed with the new test format. Of that group, 53 percent opted for a new design that would include Period 3, a unit within the course that covers history from AD 600 to AD 1450.

The College Board has also developed a pre-AP curriculum that would include earlier world history. A statement provided to the Monitor by the College Board says the organization believes that the Period 3 content is 鈥渟o important that teachers and students must be given the time to study the topics ... with great care, including reading and analyzing the primary and secondary sources and writing essays that use evidence accurately and effectively.鈥�

But because this new course wouldn鈥檛 result in college credit, there鈥檚 a disincentive for advanced students to take it, says Dylan Black, the student behind the online petition. And although the course itself would be free for schools to offer, if they chose to provide professional development and unit exams from the College Board.

Impact on students of color

Tanariea Deloney is a sophomore at Skyview High School in Vancouver, Wash. As a black and Native American student, she says she has rarely seen herself represented in a positive light in history classes. But with AP World History, that changed dramatically. The course highlights powerful and wealthy kingdoms in West Africa, like the Mali Empire, and the technological advancements of indigenous communities in the Americas.

鈥淸It is] really important to me that I am knowledgeable about my culture... instead of just coming into class and starting with 鈥極h, so your culture got wiped out by these people,鈥� or 鈥榊our people were slaves,鈥� 鈥� she says.

Others in her class recognize that the benefits of the course apply to everyone. 鈥淚t's very important for people of color to know where they came from and what their ancestors did and the accomplishments they made, but it's also very important to [white people] as well,鈥� says Amy Cisneros, another Skyview AP World History student. 鈥淚t's very important to know about other cultures to bring diversity to their opinions. It helps to open up people鈥檚 eyes....鈥�

For most public school students in the US, says Mitchell, World History is the sole opportunity to explore regions outside of Europe before colonization.

That lack of representation came to the fore distributed by Ms. DoAmaral at this year鈥檚 AP World History Open Forum 鈥� where the changes were announced. On screen, she addresses Trevor Packer, the head of the Advanced Placement program, saying 鈥淧eriod 3 is so important to鈥� showing our black and brown and our Native students that their histories matter, their histories don鈥檛 start at slavery, their histories don鈥檛 start at colonization.鈥�

Mr. Packer did not respond to the Monitor鈥檚 requests for comment.聽

At Tanariea鈥檚 school,聽AP World History students regularly create banners at the end of the year to celebrate finishing the challenging course. This year, the banners abandoned typical congratulatory praise to embrace messages like 鈥�#SavePeriod3鈥� and 鈥�#NotMyCollegeBoard.鈥� were dotted with world flags and some featured symbols from early world history, including Mesopotamian Ziggurats and Egyptian pyramids, and were distributed via a Twitter account called 鈥淍SaveAPWorld1,鈥� started by a classmate.

Evaluating the responses

For now, the College Board is still considering how to respond to the outpouring of responses it has received, says Warner. Packer two weeks ago that suggested further changes to the test may be released in July. The World History Development Committee has been meeting to explore revisions to the exam, including pushing the start date back to AD 1200 鈥� which would include the rise of the Mongols.

But even as he works to respond to voices of concern and outrage, Warner values the investment students and teachers have in the course.

鈥淚 take it in a very positive way鈥� They're passionate about it鈥� [H]opefully they don't stop with this one initiative in terms of trying to make some kind of arrangement of peace with the community here. Hopefully we will be able to find other ways to bring people together on it,鈥� he says.